Japanese cancer patient participation in and satisfaction with treatment-related decision-making: A qualitative study

Watanabe, Yoshiko; Takahashi, Miyako; Kai, Ichiro
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p77
Academic Journal
Background: Over the last decade, patient involvement in treatment-related decision-making has been widely advocated in Japan, where patient-physician encounters are still under the influence of the long-standing tradition of paternalism. Despite this profound change in clinical practice, studies investigating the actual preferences of Japanese people regarding involvement in treatment-related decision-making are limited. The main objectives of this study were to (1) reveal the actual level of involvement of Japanese cancer patients in the treatment-related decision-making and their overall satisfaction with the decision-making process, and (2) consider the practical implications of increased satisfaction in cancer patients with regard to the decision-making process. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with 24 Japanese cancer patients who were recruited from a cancer self-help group in Tokyo. The interviews were qualitatively analysed using the approach described by Lofland and Lofland. Results: The analyses of the patients' interviews focused on 2 aspects: (1) who made treatment-related decisions (the physician or the patient), and (2) the informants' overall satisfaction with the decision-making process. The analyses revealed the following 5 categories of decision-making: 'patient as the active decision maker', 'doctor selection', 'wilfully entrusting the physician', 'compelled decision-making', and 'surrendering decision-making'. While the informants under the first 3 categories were fairly satisfied with the decision-making process, those under the latter 2 were extremely dissatisfied. Informants' views regarding their preferred role in the decision-making process varied substantially from complete physician control to complete patient control; the key factor for their satisfaction was the relation between their preferred involvement in decision-making and their actual level of involvement, irrespective of who the decision maker was. Conclusion: In order to increase patient satisfaction with regard to the treatment-related decision-making process, healthcare professionals in Japan must assess individual patient preferences and provide healthcare accordingly. Moreover, a better environment should be created in hospitals and in society to facilitate patients in expressing their preferences and appropriate resources need to be made available to facilitate their decision-making process.


Related Articles

  • Transforming the experience of cancer care: a qualitative study of a hospital-based volunteer psychosocial support service. Maja Regehr; Linda Rozmovits // Supportive Care in Cancer;Jul2009, Vol. 17 Issue 7, p801 

    Abstract Purpose  As volunteer support services for cancer patients evolve and seek to gain credibility and acceptance, it is important that these services be carefully evaluated. This paper describes findings from a research study conducted by the Healing Beyond the Body (HBB) program, a...

  • Returning to work after treatment for haematological cancer: findings from Australia. McGrath, Pam; Hartigan, Barbara; Holewa, Hamish; Skarparis, Maryanne // Supportive Care in Cancer;Sep2012, Vol. 20 Issue 9, p1957 

    Purpose: Despite the personal and economic importance of the issue of returning to work after cancer treatment, there are major limitations in the research literature on the topic. Indeed, in relation to the focus of the present article, the experience of return to work for Australian...

  • SCREENING OF GASTRIC CANCER IN LIVER TRANSPLANTATION PATIENTS: A CASE REPORT AND REVIEW OF LITERATURE. Dirican, Abuzer; Unal, Bulent; Bassulu, Nuray; Ozgor, Dincer; Kayaalp, Cuneyt; Yilmaz, Sezai // Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences;Jul2010, Vol. 26 Issue 3, p733 

    Liver and other solid organ transplant recipients are at an increased risk of developing several malignancies because of the immuno-suppressive treatment. Generally, patients who had a liver transplant have upper gastrointestinal tract complaints, which makes identification of gastric carcinoma...

  • Listening in on difficult conversations: an observational, multi-center investigation of real-time conversations in medical oncology. Kimball, Brittany C.; James, Katherine M.; Yost, Kathleen J.; Fernandez, Cara A.; Kumbamu, Ashok; Leppin, Aaron L.; Robinson, Marguerite E.; Geller, Gail; Roter, Debra L.; Larson, Susan M.; Lenz, Heinz-Josef; Garcia, Agustin A.; Braddock III, Clarence H.; Jatoi, Aminah; Zúñiga de Nuncio, María Luisa; Montori, Victor M.; Koenig, Barbara A.; Tilburt, Jon C. // BMC Cancer;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: The quality of communication in medical care has been shown to influence health outcomes. Cancer patients, a highly diverse population, communicate with their clinical care team in diverse ways over the course of their care trajectory. Whether that communication happens and how...

  • Development of a Telehealth Intervention for Head and Neck Cancer Patients. Barbara A. Head; Jamie L. Studts; Jeffrey M. Bumpous; Jennifer L. Gregg; Liz Wilson; Cynthia Keeney; Jennifer A. Scharfenberger; Mark P. Pfeifer // Telemedicine & e-Health;Jan2009, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p44 

    Head and neck cancer and its multidisciplinary treatment entail difficulties in communication confounded by the communication disabilities that may be associated with surgical treatment. In a population with a strong likelihood of limited computer skills, a simplified communication with video...

  • iCAD reports first European patients treated with Xoft.  // Medical Device Daily;5/14/2012, Vol. 16 Issue 93, p1 

    The article reports on the first European patients treated with the Xoft Axxent electronic brachytherapy system, the radiation therapy system of iCAD. The first hospitals in Europe that used the Xoft system for treating early stage breast cancer include Pius-Hospital Oldenburg in Germany and...

  • Ohio Cancer Hospital Will Serve More Patients From W.Va. WORKMAN, JIM // State Journal (WV);12/12/2014, Vol. 30 Issue 48, p9 

    No abstract available.

  • Cancer.  // U.S. News & World Report;7/23/2007, Vol. 143 Issue 3, p94 

    This article presents a list of the best U.S. hospitals for the treatment of cancer which is topped by the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center in Houston, Texas. Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in New York, Johns Hopkins Hospital in Maryland and the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota...

  • A Week In The Life At M.D. Anderson Cancer Center.  // Prevention;Oct2012, Vol. 64 Issue 10, p108 

    The article discusses the M.D. Anderson Cancer Center located in Houston, Texas which is a most innovative treatment center of the U.S. It consists of a world class staff of radiologists, oncologists and internists. It also organizes survivorship programs that provide meaningful services to...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics