TITLE

We're not short of people telling us what the problems are. We're short of people telling us what to do: an appraisal of public policy and mental health

AUTHOR(S)
Ono, Yutaka; Awata, Shuichi; Iida, Hideharu; Ishida, Yasushi; Ishizuka, Naoki; Iwasa, Hiroto; Kamei, Yuichi; Motohashi, Yutaka; Nakagawa, Atsuo; Nakamura, Jun; Nishi, Nobuyuki; Otsuka, Kotaro; Oyama, Hirofumi; Sakai, Akio; Sakai, Hironori; Suzuki, Yuriko; Tajima, Miyuki; Tanaka, Eriko; Uda, Hidenori; Yonemoto, Naohiro
PUB. DATE
January 2008
SOURCE
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8, p314
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Background: There is sustained interest in public health circles in assessing the effects of policies on health and health inequalities. We report on the theory, methods and findings of a project which involved an appraisal of current Scottish policy with respect to its potential impacts on mental health and wellbeing. Methods: We developed a method of assessing the degree of alignment between Government policies and the 'evidence base', involving: reviewing theoretical frameworks; analysis of policy documents, and nineteen in-depth interviews with policymakers which explored influences on, and barriers to cross-cutting policymaking and the use of research evidence in decision-making. Results: Most policy documents did not refer to mental health; however most referred indirectly to the determinants of mental health and well-being. Unsurprisingly research evidence was rarely cited; this was more common in health policy documents. The interviews highlighted the barriers to intersectoral policy making, and pointed to the relative value of qualitative and quantitative research, as well as to the imbalance of evidence between "what is known" and "what is to be done". Conclusion: Healthy public policy depends on effective intersectoral working between government departments, along with better use of research evidence to identify policy impacts. This study identified barriers to both these. We also demonstrated an approach to rapidly appraising the mental health effects of mainly non-health sector policies, drawing on theoretical understandings of mental health and its determinants, research evidence and policy documents. In the case of the social determinants of health, we conclude that an evidence-based approach to policymaking and to policy appraisal requires drawing strongly upon existing theoretical frameworks, as well as upon research evidence, but that there are significant practical barriers and disincentives.
ACCESSION #
51486806

 

Related Articles

  • Macao, Special Administrative Region, China.  // Mental Health Atlas: 2005;2005, p528 

    The article offers information about the public health surveillance for mentally ill in Macao, China. Accordingly, Macao has mental health policy and national mental health policy, while it lacks of national mental health program. Moreover, the country has no budget allocations for mental...

  • International observatory on mental health systems: structure and operation. Minas, Harry // International Journal of Mental Health Systems;2009, Vol. 3, p1 

    Introduction: Sustained cooperative action is required to improve the mental health of populations, particularly in low and middle-income countries where meagre mental health investment and insufficient human and other resources result in poorly performing mental health systems. The Observatory:...

  • Tokelau.  // Atlas Country Profiles on Mental Health Resources;2001, p505 

    An encyclopedia entry on the mental health resources in Tokelau is presented. It has no mental health policy, substance abuse policy and national mental health programme. Its national therapeutic drug policy/essential list of drugs was formulated in 1998. It does not consider mental illness as a...

  • Ex-Mental Patients and the New Snake Pits. ANDERSON, GEORGE M. // America;9/4/1976, Vol. 135 Issue 5, p90 

    The article discusses the increase in the number of mental patients being discharged in state mental institutions and transferred to privately operated facilities for the mentally impaired in the U.S. as of September 4, 1976. It cites financial reasons behind this move by state legislatures. It...

  • Antigua and Barbuda.  // Atlas Country Profiles on Mental Health Resources;2001, p146 

    An encyclopedia entry about the status of mental health services and policies in Antigua and Barbuda is presented. The country has no mental health and substance abuse policies. A national mental health programme and therapeutic drug policy are present. The latest law on mental health was...

  • French Polynesia.  // Atlas Country Profiles on Mental Health Resources;2001, p492 

    An encyclopedia entry for mental health resources in the French Polynesia is presented. The country has no mental health policy and national mental health programme. It offers disability benefits for people suffering from mental disorders. The country lacks community care facilities for mentally...

  • Wallis and Futuna.  // Atlas Country Profiles on Mental Health Resources;2001, p507 

    An encyclopedia entry for mental health resources in Wallis and Futuna is presented. It has no mental health policy, substance abuse policy and national mental health program. It does not offer disability benefits for persons suffering from mental illness. Community care facilities for mentally...

  • UK plans shake-up of mental health laws. Dyer, Clare // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);01/06/2001, Vol. 322 Issue 7277, p10 

    Reports that Great Britain is expected to implement policy changes regarding the treatment of individuals with severe personality disorders. Previous classification of such persons as psychopaths; Possibility that they will be detained for indefinite periods in medical facilities even if no...

  • Zimbabwe.  // Atlas Country Profiles on Mental Health Resources;2001, p141 

    An encyclopedia entry about the status of mental health services and policies in Zimbabwe is presented. The country has no mental health and substance abuse policies. A national mental health programme, mental laws and a therapeutic drug policy are present. Statistical figures pertaining to the...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics