The reliability of the twelve-item general health questionnaire (GHQ-12) under realistic assumptions

Hankins, Matthew
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p355
Academic Journal
Background: The twelve-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12) was developed to screen for non-specific psychiatric morbidity. It has been widely validated and found to be reliable. These validation studies have assumed that the GHQ-12 is one-dimensional and free of response bias, but recent evidence suggests that neither of these assumptions may be correct, threatening its utility as a screening instrument. Further uncertainty arises because of the multiplicity of scoring methods of the GHQ-12. This study set out to establish the best fitting model for the GHQ-12 for three scoring methods (Likert, GHQ and C-GHQ) and to calculate the degree of measurement error under these more realistic assumptions. Methods: GHQ-12 data were obtained from the Health Survey for England 2004 cohort (n = 3705). Structural equation modelling was used to assess the fit of [1] the one-dimensional model [2] the current 'best fit' three-dimensional model and [3] a one-dimensional model with response bias. Three different scoring methods were assessed for each model. The best fitting model was assessed for reliability, standard error of measurement and discrimination. Results: The best fitting model was one-dimensional with response bias on the negatively phrased items, suggesting that previous GHQ-12 factor structures were artifacts of the analysis method. The reliability of this model was over-estimated by Cronbach's Alpha for all scoring methods: 0.90 (Likert method), 0.90 (GHQ method) and 0.75 (C-GHQ). More realistic estimates of reliability were 0.73, 0.87 and 0.53 (C-GHQ), respectively. Discrimination (Delta) also varied according to scoring method: 0.94 (Likert method), 0.63 (GHQ method) and 0.97 (C-GHQ method). Conclusion: Conventional psychometric assessments using factor analysis and reliability estimates have obscured substantial measurement error in the GHQ-12 due to response bias on the negative items, which limits its utility as a screening instrument for psychiatric morbidity.


Related Articles

  • Rule changes for data protection exemption forms. Baines, Emma // GP: General Practitioner;2/23/2004, p19 

    General practitioners involved in cervical screening programmes no longer have to worry about filling out exemption forms to comply with the Data Protection Act. Under recent Great Britain's Department of Health guidelines, a Personal Care Trust chief executive or director of public health can...

  • Cost effectiveness of home based population screening for Chlamydia trachomatis in the UK: economic evaluation of chlamydia screening studies (ClaSS) project. Roberts, Tracy E.; Robinson, Suzanne; Barton, Pelham M.; Bryan, Stirling; McCarthy, Anne; Macleod, John; Egger, Matthias; Low, Nicola // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);8/11/2007, Vol. 335 Issue 7614, p291 

    ABSTRACT Objective To investigate the cost effectiveness of screening for Chlamydia trachomatis compared with a policy of no organised screening in the United Kingdom. Design Economic evaluation using a transmission dynamic mathematical model. Setting Central and southwest England. Participants...

  • Vascular screening: localism gone mad.  // Pulse;2/18/2009, Vol. 69 Issue 5, p15 

    The author reflects on the plan of the British government to conduct a vascular screening programme across the country. The author asserts that the arguments for local policies to health needs are well-rehearsed but no less powerful. The author emphasizes that challenges such as obesity,...

  • Out-of-hours survey 2004. Slingsby, Carole // Medeconomics;Sep2004, Vol. 25 Issue 9, p25 

    This article presents information on a survey conducted by the journal "MedEconomics" and NHS Alliance to study trends in Primary Care Trusts (PCT)'s out-of-hours funding in Great Britain. Of the 94 PCTs taking part in the poll, 90 per cent say that the annual expense of providing out-of-hours...

  • End of life care. Davies, Sue // Primary Health Care;Oct2007, Vol. 17 Issue 8, p30 

    The article focuses on the steps of improving the palliative care provision for adults in Great Britain. The End of Life Care program by the National Health Service (NHS) offers options and high quality care to adults and establishes the preferred terminology as end of life care. The Gold...

  • Discrimination not always what it seems? Bright, Les // Nursing Older People;Jun2005, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p8 

    The article focuses on the politics of health care in Great Britain. However, the politics of health care is more subtle than it appears to be while the politicians are involved, leaning as it does in part on scholarship and clinical judgment, and perhaps bolstered by prejudice, too. Social...

  • IN BRIEF.  // Nursing Standard;12/7/2005, Vol. 20 Issue 13, p11 

    This article offers news briefs related to public health in Great Britain. According to the annual Scottish Health Survey, fewer residents of Scotland are dying prematurely from cancer, heart disease and stroke. However, obesity levels and alcohol consumption are increasing, especially among...

  • Chlamydia screening stalls.  // Pulse;6/14/2007, Vol. 67 Issue 23, p4 

    The article reports on the findings of the survey regarding the progress of the National Chlamydia Screening Programme in Great Britain. Based on the study, the program is struggling to build uptake to the levels demanded to battle infection rates and has been lambasted for relying on the...

  • 'Patient Experience' warning.  // Pulse;11/30/2006, Vol. 66 Issue 45, p5 

    The article reports on the implementation of the Patient Experience Survey by the Department of Health to assess health services in Great Britain. The survey was being sent to five million people to measure the performance of general practitioners. According to the chief executive of Picker...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics