Learning from a Rapid Health Impact Assessment of a proposed maternity service reconfiguration in the English NHS

Fell, Greg; Haroon, Sophie
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p138
Academic Journal
Background: Within many parts of the country, the NHS is undertaking reconfiguration of services. Such proposals can prove a tipping point and provoke public protest, often with significant involvement of local and national politicians. We undertook a rapid Health Impact Assessment (HIA) of a proposed reconfiguration of maternity services in Huddersfield and Halifax in England. The aim of the HIA was to help the PCT Boards to assess the reconfiguration's possible consequences on access to maternity services, and maternal and infant health outcomes across different socio-economic groups in Kirklees. We report on the findings of the HIA and the usefulness of the process to decision making. Methods: This HIA used routine maternity data for 2004-2005 in Huddersfield, in addition to published evidence. Standard HIA techniques were used. Results: We re-highlighted the socio economic differences in smoking status at booking and quitting during pregnancy. We focused on the key concerns of the public, that of adverse obstetric events on a Midwife Led Unit (MLU) with distant obstetric cover. We estimate that twenty percent of women giving birth in a MLU may require urgent transfer to obstetric care during labour. There were no significant socio economic differences. Much of the risk can be mitigated though robust risk management policies. Additional travelling distances and costs could affect lower socioeconomic groups the greatest because of lower car ownership and geographical location in relation to the units. There is potential that with improved community antenatal and post natal care, population outcomes could improve significantly, the available evidence supports this view. Conclusion: Available evidence suggests that maternity reconfiguration towards enhanced community care could have many potential benefits but carries risk. Investment is needed to realise the former and mitigate the latter. The usefulness of this Health Impact Assessment may have been impeded by its timing, and the politically charged environment of the proposals. Nonetheless, the methods used are readily applicable to assess the impact of other service reconfigurations. The analysis was simple, not time intensive and used routinely available data. Careful consideration should be given to both the timing and the political context in which an analysis is undertaken.


Related Articles

  • Noticeboard.  // Paediatric Nursing;May2010, Vol. 22 Issue 4, p8 

    The article presents nursing news briefs. The charity WellChild of Great Britain is accepting 2010 award nominations. The National Health Service (NHS) is working on a maternity service feasibility study. Sigma Theta Tau International (STTI) is offering postdoctoral fellowships.

  • Letter from Westminster: A friend at the top. Warden, John // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);12/8/90, Vol. 301 Issue 6764, p1297 

    Presents letter on medicine in Great Britain. Appointment of Cabinet committees on National Health Service; Improvement of the maternity and neonatal services; Provision for the care of premature babies.

  • CAPITAL DELIVERY. Shepherd, Sonia // Nursing Standard;3/8/2006, Vol. 20 Issue 26, p54 

    The article discusses the leadership of Paulette Lewis in London's maternity services. National Health Service's chief executives in London appointed Lewis when the Healthcare Commission questioned the readiness of the England's maternity services. Lewis believes staff and users hold the answers...

  • Achieving a smoke-free hospital: reported enforcement of smoke-free regulations by NHS health care staff. Mark Shipley; Robert Allcock // Journal of Public Health;Mar2008, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p2 

    : Background In December 2006, all UK NHS trusts introduced smoke-free regulations prohibiting smoking on all NHS sites. These rules are to be enforced by all NHS trust staff. We have investigated the implementation of these regulations by health care workers when they encounter smokers on a NHS...

  • Cost of NHS stop smoking services increase £10m to £61m in 2007-08. Paton, Nic // Occupational Health;Oct2008, Vol. 60 Issue 10, p7 

    The article reports on the costs of stop smoking services by the Great Britain National Health Service (NHS) as of October 2008. The NHS spent almost £61 million (m) on services to help people stop smoking in 2007-2008, £10m more than in 2006-07 and almost £36m more than in 2001-02,...

  • National smoking cessation services at risk. Raw, Martin; Watt, Judith; Raw, David // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);11/17/2001, Vol. 323 Issue 7322, p1140 

    Editorial. Discusses smoking cessation programs in Great Britain run by the National Health Service. Success of behavioral support and prescriptions of nicotine replacement therapy or bupropion; Estimations of savings in medical costs from treating smokers; Concern that the services will be...

  • Smoking cessation advice. Newson, Louise // GP: General Practitioner;4/7/2006, p54 

    The article reports that in Great Britain the treatment of smoking-related disease costs the National Health Service between £1.4 billion and £1.5 billion a year. Nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) products approximately double the chance of long-term cessation. There is currently no...

  • Alcohol and obesity checks added to vascular screening. Praities, Nigel // Pulse;4/15/2009, Vol. 69 Issue 13, p3 

    The article reports on the expansion of the government's vascular screening programme in Great Britain, which includes alcohol misuse and obesity. It mentions that the new scheme is called the National Health Service (NHS) Health Checks and will include interventions for smoking cessation...

  • Fruit for Fags scheme offered to smokers.  // Nursing Standard;3/28/2007, Vol. 21 Issue 29, p8 

    The article reports on the initiative offered by the National Health Services (NHS) Trust to all inpatients smokers. The trusts provided an access to services that will help them quit smoking. Furthermore, patients admitted to hospitals run by the Pennine Acute Hospitals NHS Trust will be asked...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics