Learning from a Rapid Health Impact Assessment of a proposed maternity service reconfiguration in the English NHS

Fell, Greg; Haroon, Sophie
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p138
Academic Journal
Background: Within many parts of the country, the NHS is undertaking reconfiguration of services. Such proposals can prove a tipping point and provoke public protest, often with significant involvement of local and national politicians. We undertook a rapid Health Impact Assessment (HIA) of a proposed reconfiguration of maternity services in Huddersfield and Halifax in England. The aim of the HIA was to help the PCT Boards to assess the reconfiguration's possible consequences on access to maternity services, and maternal and infant health outcomes across different socio-economic groups in Kirklees. We report on the findings of the HIA and the usefulness of the process to decision making. Methods: This HIA used routine maternity data for 2004-2005 in Huddersfield, in addition to published evidence. Standard HIA techniques were used. Results: We re-highlighted the socio economic differences in smoking status at booking and quitting during pregnancy. We focused on the key concerns of the public, that of adverse obstetric events on a Midwife Led Unit (MLU) with distant obstetric cover. We estimate that twenty percent of women giving birth in a MLU may require urgent transfer to obstetric care during labour. There were no significant socio economic differences. Much of the risk can be mitigated though robust risk management policies. Additional travelling distances and costs could affect lower socioeconomic groups the greatest because of lower car ownership and geographical location in relation to the units. There is potential that with improved community antenatal and post natal care, population outcomes could improve significantly, the available evidence supports this view. Conclusion: Available evidence suggests that maternity reconfiguration towards enhanced community care could have many potential benefits but carries risk. Investment is needed to realise the former and mitigate the latter. The usefulness of this Health Impact Assessment may have been impeded by its timing, and the politically charged environment of the proposals. Nonetheless, the methods used are readily applicable to assess the impact of other service reconfigurations. The analysis was simple, not time intensive and used routinely available data. Careful consideration should be given to both the timing and the political context in which an analysis is undertaken.


Related Articles

  • In brief.  // Practice Nurse;9/4/2009, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p7 

    This section offers news briefs concerning medical care in Great Britain. Cancer Research UK found that ovarian cancer rates have fallen by almost 20% in a decade. A King's Fund report revealed that new research is needed into the clinical and cost-effectiveness of complementary therapies....

  • VIEWSJOIN THE DEBATE.  // Pulse;9/8/2010, Vol. 70 Issue 25, p22 

    The article presents the topics on online debate including the call for 100% Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF) thresholds, the rejection of the National Health Service (NHS) Direct, and a search fro new QOF targets.

  • A million must march against NHS reforms. Moore, Simon // Pulse;3/16/2011, Vol. 71 Issue 10, p14 

    The article discusses the impact of the reformation of the National Health Service (NHS) to healthcare as gross domestic product (GDP) in Great Britain.

  • 'Robin Hood' cuts to PMS.  // Pulse;11/24/2010, Vol. 70 Issue 36, p3 

    The article reports on the Robin Hood-style of redistributing cash from Personal Medical Service (PMS) to General Medical Service (GMS) practices by the Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) of Great Britain.

  • Trusts write termination clauses into PMS contracts. Iacobucci, Gareth // Pulse;5/25/2011, Vol. 71 Issue 19, p1 

    The article reports on the changes in Personal Medical Services (PMS) contracts in Great Britain wherein managers of the National Health Service (NHS) are creating unlawful variation clauses into the contracts which grant them to terminate PMS contracts whenever general practitioners (GPs)...

  • IN BRIEF.  // Pulse;5/25/2011, Vol. 71 Issue 19, p7 

    The article offers news briefs related to medicine and health care in Great Britain including the changes made in the National Health Service's (NHS) complaint procedures, the national guidance on migrant tuberculosis screening, and the use of azithromycin to lower acute exacerbations of chronic...

  • NHS is doing more for less, say auditors. Williams, David // Public Finance;11/20/2009, p13 

    The article discusses the report "More for Less" from the Audit Commission which found that primary care trusts appear to be taking initiatives to increase productivity but they fail to transfer care to the community in Great Britain.

  • Meddling and bearing witness. Smith, Jane // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);8/16/2008, Vol. 337 Issue 7666, p359 

    The article discusses various reports published within the issue including one by Gwyn Bevan on reforms which have been made to Great Britain's National health Service and another by Rhema Vaithianathan and Geraint Lewis on proposals for independence from the National Health Service.

  • Community shift criticised.  // Pulse;5/19/2010, Vol. 70 Issue 17, p7 

    The article focuses on the survey concerning the impact of transforming community services in the National Health Services (NHS) Alliance which discussed by general practitioner Michael Dixon at the Annual Conference of Community in Great Britain.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics