Population tobacco control interventions and their effects on social inequalities in smoking: placing an equity lens on existing systematic reviews

Main, Caroline; Thomas, Sian; Ogilvie, David; Stirk, Lisa; Petticrew, Mark; Whitehead, Margaret; Sowden, Amanda
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p178
Academic Journal
Background: With smoking increasingly confined to lower socio-economic groups, the tobacco control community has been urged to identify which population-level tobacco control interventions work in order to help tackle smoking-related health inequalities. Systematic reviews have a crucial role to play in this task. This overview was therefore carried out in order to (i) summarise the evidence from existing systematic reviews of population-level tobacco control interventions, and (ii) assess the need for a new systematic review of primary studies, with the aim of assessing the differential effects of such interventions. Methods: Systematic review methods were used to evaluate existing systematic reviews that assessed a population-level tobacco control intervention and which reported characteristics of included participants in terms of at least one sociodemographic or socio-economic factor. Results: Nineteen systematic reviews were included. Four reviews assessed interventions aimed at the population level alone, whilst fifteen included at least one primary study that examined this type of intervention. Four reviews assessed youth access restrictions, one assessed the effects of increasing the unit price of tobacco, and six assessed smoking bans or restrictions. Of the eight remaining reviews, six assessed multi-component community based interventions, in which the population-level interventions were part of a wider tobacco control programme, and two assessed the impact of smoking bans or restrictions in reducing exposure to environmental tobacco smoke. We found tentative evidence that the effect of increasing the unit price of tobacco products may vary between ethnic and socio-economic groups, and between males and females. However, differences in the context and the results of different reviews made it difficult to draw any firm conclusions. Few identified reviews explicitly attempted to examine differences in intervention effects between socio-demographic groups. Therefore on the basis of these reviews the potential for smoking bans, and youth access restrictions to decrease social inequalities in smoking remains unknown. Conclusion: There is preliminary evidence that increases in the unit price of tobacco may have the potential to reduce smoking related health inequalities. There is a need for equity effects to be explicitly evaluated in future systematic reviews and in primary research assessing the effects of population tobacco control interventions.


Related Articles

  • Why do Danish adolescents take up smoking? Holm, Klavs; Kremers, Stef P.J.; de Vries, Heins // European Journal of Public Health;Mar2003, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p67 

    Describes the demographic differences between non-smoking and smoking adolescents in Denmark. Perceptions of adolescents on the advantages and disadvantages of smoking; Factors that relate to the initiation of adolescent smoking; Estimation of annual mortality associated with tobacco...

  • Smoking Decisions from a Teen Perspective: A Narrative Study. Baillie, Lynne; Lovato, Chris Y.; Johnson, Joy L.; Kalaw, Cecilia // American Journal of Health Behavior;Mar/Apr2005, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p99 

    Objective: To explore the transitional phase between experimental and regular smoking from the perspective of teens. Method: Narrative analysis of semistructured, individual interviews. Results: The need to belong and immediate social gain are major themes influencing teen smoking decisions....

  • When Genetic Disease Devastates Families …. St. John, Gloria // Homeopathy Today;Spring2012, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p24 

    A personal narrative is presented which explores the author's experience of helping Lisa with Huntington's disease with homeopathy.

  • The Influence of Three Mass Media Campaigns on Variables Related to Adolescent Cigarette Smoking: Results of a Field Experiment. Bauman, Karl E.; LaPrelle, John; Brown, Jane D.; Koch, Gary G.; Padgett, Connie A. // American Journal of Public Health;May91, Vol. 81 Issue 5, p597 

    Background: This paper reports findings from -A field experiment that evaluated mass media campaigns designed to prevent cigarette smoking by adolescents. Methods: The campaigns featured radio and television messages on expected consequences of smoking and a component to stimulate personal...

  • What are the main sources of smoking cessation support used by adolescent smokers in England? A cross-sectional study. Shaikh, Wasif; Nugawela, Manjula D.; Szatkowski, Lisa // BMC Public Health;2015, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Adolescent smoking is a worldwide public health concern. Whilst various support measures are available to help young smokers quit, their utilization of cessation support remains unknown. Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted using data from the 2012 Smoking, Drinking and...

  • Former Smokers Can Regain Health and Improve Quality of Life.  // Ascribe Newswire: Medicine;6/10/2004, p74 

    A new analysis of data on smoking and health finds that smokers who quit before the age of 35 have a reasonable chance to regain their health over time and to live as long and as well as people who have never smoked. The Duke University Medical Center researchers who performed the analysis said...

  • Keeping the Focus on Public Health: The Struggles of a Tobacco Prevention Task Force. Shillis, Jacquie A.; Hall, Beverly A.; Sneden, Gail G.; Gottlieb, Nell H. // Health Education & Behavior;Dec2003, Vol. 30 Issue 6, p771 

    The article focuses on a case study examining the struggles of the Texas Inter-agency tobacco prevention task force. The Texas Inter-agency tobacco gained internal victories such as the creation of a comprehensive statewide plan to reduce tobacco use but could not sustain a policy success in the...

  • Smoking prevalence and its characteristics among the population aged 25-64 years according to the postal surveys of Kiev residents. Kvasha, Elena; Krasovsky, Konstantin S. // Tobacco Control & Public Health in Eastern Europe;2012, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p17 

    Tobacco smoking (TS) is considered one of the main negative factors influencing health of Ukraine's population. To shape policies aimed to prevent and decrease harmful effects of TS on health and economics, it is necessary to have evidence-based information about prevalence of this risk factor...

  • Nonprofit Organizations versus Government Agencies to Reduce Tobacco Use. Carver, Vivien; Reinert, Bonita; Range, Lilian M.; Campbell, Catherine; Boyd, Nicole // Journal of Public Health Policy;2003, Vol. 24 Issue 2, p181 

    Tobacco settlement money can be allocated to nonprofit organizations or government agencies. Both have advantages and disadvantages. Nonprofit organizations may have relatively (a) more efficiency/flexibility, but less accountability; (b) narrower focus, but less experience; (c) more ability to...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics