'People pull the rug from under your feet': barriers to successful public health programmes

Ritchie, Deborah; Gnich, Wendy; Parry, Odette; Platt, Steve
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p173
Academic Journal
Background: A community public health programme, 'Breathing Space', aimed to tackle smoking in a low income area in Scotland. This paper draws on the qualitative process evaluation of a community-based initiative 'Breathing Space', which set out to tackle smoking in a low income area of Scotland, in order to explore user perceptions of key factors affecting implementation, and in particular to explore the implications of participant knowledge and expertise for programme stability and continuity. Methods: The overall evaluation of Breathing Space used a quasi-experimental design and incorporated a detailed process evaluation. The process evaluation aimed to document development and implementation of the programme using a range of qualitative methods, including observation, in-depth interviews, focus groups and documentary analysis. The paper draws upon 59 semi-structured in-depth interviews which were carried out as part of the process evaluation. Findings: Staff numbers from the multi-agency partnership dwindled across the lifecouof the programme and respondents identified lack of continuity as a key issue. While staff changes are an anticipated problem in programme implementation, here we draw on concepts of technicality and indeterminacy to explore the different aspects of public health programmes which are forfeited when individuals leave. The paper argues that, while technical components of public health programmes (such as the importance of staff complement and continuity) are widely recognised, it is the more indeterminate aspects, including the loss of key theoretical understanding underpinning the programme, which most affect programme delivery. Indeed, the paper suggests that, where inadequate planning and resources threaten the continuity of indeterminate knowledge, the success of public health programmes may be especially jeopardised. Conclusion: Community-based programmes which rely strongly on partnership processes would benefit from early consideration of the potential risks associated with both expected and unexpected stakeholder change. Building in appropriate contingency plans is necessary for sustaining the theory and culture of the programme. Evaluations of innovative community development initiatives may benefit from a formative approach.


Related Articles

  • Keep on moving. Thatcher, Mike // Public Finance;11/19/2004, p4 

    Comments on the proposals for banning smoking in public places in England. British government's commitment to supporting healthier lifestyles; Indication that there can be no one-size-fits all solution to the problems of smoking, obesity, sexually transmitted diseases and mental illness; Need...

  • Evaluating the empowering potential of community-based health schemes: The case of community health policies in the UK since 1997. Paul Bridgen // Community Development Journal;Jul2004, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p289 

    Evaluating the empowering potential of community-based health promotion schemes is acknowledged as problematic, not least because of the conceptual ambiguity surrounding community empowerment. This paper discusses the problems involved in evaluating community empowerment, using policy...

  • Ministers launch new battle of the bulge. Ward, Seamus // Public Finance;1/25/2008, p8 

    The article reports that British ministers have launched a new initiative against obesity. The government describes the strategy as a first step in its attempt to address the problem that could result in almost 60 percent of British adults being obese by 2050. Money or other financial rewards...

  • Strengthening a Tobacco-Free College Campus Policy Through Signage: GIS Mapping for Advocacy to Improve Implementation. Bowrey, Brice L.; McLeod, Emmanuel J.; Kuteh, Jaleel D.; Duval, Garian I.; Sesay, Mahdi; Akou, Angela A.; Lee, Joseph G. L. // Health Promotion Practice;Mar2020, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p165 

    Implementing tobacco-free policies on university campuses has become increasingly common. However, promoting policy compliance remains a challenge. It is important to develop strategies that can overcome barriers to successful policy implementation and promote compliance. This Practice Note...

  • Cutting obstacles to healthy living is not nannying, says BMA. Ward, Seamus // Public Finance;7/16/2004, p10 

    Reports on the responsibility of the government to remove the barriers to healthier lifestyle according to the British Medical Association in Great Britain. Effectiveness of the laws on drink-driving safety belts; Need for government leadership on obesity and sexual health; Moral duty to ban...

  • Differences in socioeconomic and gender inequalities in tobacco smoking in Denmark and Sweden; a cross sectional comparison of the equity effect of different public health policies. Eek, Frida; Östergren, Per-Olof; Diderichsen, Finn; Rasmussen, Niels K.; Andersen, Ingelise; Moussa, Kontie; Grahn, Mathias // BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Denmark and Sweden are considered to be countries of rather similar socio-political type, but public health policies and smoking habits differ considerably between the two neighbours. A study comparing mechanisms behind socioeconomic inequalities in tobacco smoking, could yield...

  • Benefiting the consumer.  // Finance Week;9/1/2003, p42 

    Comments on the need for an assessment of the health care system in South Africa. Revision of professional fees and services; Appeal for the abolition of manufacturers' medicine discounts; Consumer response to health rates and medical care costs.

  • Curbing collusion.  // Finance Week;9/1/2003, p42 

    Focuses on the impact of competitive pricing on the provision of health care in South Africa. Government strategy against collusion and price-fixing in medical care; Power of choice among consumers; Viability of medical schemes.

  • At last.  // Finance Week;9/1/2003, p48 

    Focuses on the South African government's program against the AIDS epidemic. Appeal for the creation of a detailed plan for antiretroviral drug delivery; Preparation for funding, staff shortages and absence of support systems; Impact of the program on AIDS mortality.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics