Less healthy, but more active: opposing selection biases when recruiting older people to a physical activity study through primary care

Harris, Tess J.; Victor, Christina R; Carey, Iain M.; Adams, Rika; Cook, Derek G.
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p182
Academic Journal
Background: Physical activity studies in older people experience poor recruitment. We wished to assess the influence of activity levels and health status on recruitment to a physical activity study in older people. Methods: Comparison of participants and non-participants to a physical activity study using accelerometers in patients aged ⩾?65 years registered with a UK primary care centre. Logistic regression was used to calculate odds ratios (OR) of participants in the accelerometer study with various adjustments. Analyses were initially adjusted for age, sex and household clustering; the health variables were then adjusted for physical activity levels and vice versa to look for independent effects. Results: 43%(240/560) participated in the physical activity study. Age had no effect but males were more likely to participate than females OR 1.4(1.1-1.8). 46% (76/164) of non-participants sent the questionnaire returned it. The 240 participants reported greater physical activity than the 76 nonparticipants on all measures, eg faster walking OR 3.2(1.4-7.7), or 10.4(3.2-33.3) after adjustment for health variables. Participants reported more health problems; this effect became statistically significant after controlling for physical activity, eg disability OR 2.4(1.1-5.1). Conclusion: Physical activity studies on older primary care patients may experience both a strong bias towards participants being more active and a weaker bias towards participants having more health problems and therefore primary care contact. The latter bias could be advantageous for physical activity intervention studies, where those with health problems need targeting.


Related Articles

  • A COMMUNITY APPROACH. Choudhury, Sultana // SportEX Health (14718154);Jul2009, Issue 21, p16 

    The article reports on the Fit for Fun scheme created through the collaboration among Redbridge Primary Care Trust (PCT), Redbridge Council for Voluntary Services (RCVS) and London Borough of Redbridge (LBR) to promote the benefits of exercise in Great Britain. It presents the mechanics in...

  • Call for clarity on public health.  // GP: General Practitioner;2/25/2011, p3 

    The article reports that general practitioner (GP) consortia in Great Britain need frameworks and information regarding the public health systems as they lack clarity on their responsibilities.

  • Exercise referrals.  // Pulse;3/8/2007, Vol. 67 Issue 9, p11 

    The article reports on the claims of an official National Health Service evaluation that referring patients to exercise instructors is an effective way of improving physical and mental wellbeing in Great Britain. The proportion of patients doing at least 150 minutes of moderate activity a week...

  • POLE TO POLE. Stewart, Gill // SportEX Health (14718154);Apr2009, Issue 20, p27 

    The article offers information on Nordic walking and its role in physical activity promotion in Great Britain. It notes that Nordic walking is considered as an effective outdoor walking technique. Participants push off through specifically designed Nordic walking poles, creating a total body...

  • LEARNING FROM AN EVALUATION. Cresswell, Jackie // SportEX Health (14718154);Jul2009, Issue 21, p19 

    The article presents an evaluation of the exercise referral scheme made by the British Heart Foundation's National Centre for Physical Activity and Health in Great Britain. The scheme aims for the advancement in health and well being of inactive clients through increasing their physical...

  • Randomised controlled trial of the effects of physical activity feedback on awareness and behaviour in UK adults: the FAB study protocol [ISRCTN92551397]. Watkinson, Clare; van Sluijs, Esther M. F.; Sutton, Stephen; Marteau, Theresa; Griffin, Simon J. // BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p144 

    Background: While there are increasing data implicating poor recognition of physical inactivity as a potential barrier to healthy behaviour change, the efficacy of feedback to promote physical activity is uncertain. Using a randomised controlled trial nested within a population-based cohort...

  • Committee wants multicraft group to monitor Griffiths.  // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);9/20/1986, Vol. 293 Issue 6549, p767 

    Focuses on the consultation services for primary care in Great Britain. Search for satisfactory community health doctors; Election of a district medical officer; Criticisms on the overall policy for the employment of community medical staff.

  • Help PCGs more, says Denham. Ward, Seamus // Public Finance;03/03/2000, p13 

    Reports on British Health Minister John Denham's call for health authorities to give greater support to primary care groups (PCG). Survey showing variations in the amount of money passed on to commissioning bodies; Role of PCG and primary care trusts in the government's plan to make the...

  • Can primary care groups and trusts improve health? Gillam, Steve; Abbott, Stephen; Banks-Smith, Jennifer // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);7/14/2001, Vol. 323 Issue 7304, p89 

    Discusses the role of Great Britain's primary care groups and trusts in improving the health of a population. Possible conflicts between a physician's role as patient advocate and population planner; Problems with inequality in health care; Evaluation of the progress of primary care groups in...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics