Positive deviance control-case life history: a method to develop grounded hypotheses about successful long-term avoidance of infection

Friedman, Samuel R; Mateu-Gelabert, Pedro; Sandoval, Milagros; Hagan, Holly; Jarlais, Don C. Des
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8, p94
Academic Journal
Background: Prevalence rates for long-term injection drug users in some localities surpass 60% for HIV and 80% for HCV. We describe methods for developing grounded hypotheses about how some injectors avoid infection with either virus. Methods: Subjects: 25 drug injectors who have injected drugs 8-15 years in New York City. 17 remain without antibody to either HIV or HCV; 3 are double-positives; and 5 are positive for HCV but not HIV. "Staying Safe" methodology compares serostatus groups using detailed biographical timelines and narratives; and information about how subjects maintain access to physical resources and social support; their strategies and tactics to remain safe; how they handle problems of addiction and demands by drug dealers and other drug users; and how their behaviors and strategies do or do not become socially-embedded practices. Grounded theory and life-history analysis techniques compare and contrast doubly-uninfected with those infected with both viruses or only with HCV. Results: Themes and initial hypotheses emerging from analyses included two master hypotheses that, if confirmed, should help shape preventive interventions: 1) Staying uninfected is not simply a question of social structure or social position. It involves agency by drug injectors, including sustained hard work and adaptation to changing circumstances. 2) Multiple intentionalities contribute to remaining uninfected. These conscious goals include balancing one's need for drugs and one's income; developing ways to avoid drug withdrawal sickness; avoiding situations where other drug users importune you to share drugs; and avoiding HIV (and perhaps HCV) infection. Thus, focusing on a single goal in prevention might be sub-optimal. Other hypotheses specify mechanisms of enacting these intentionalities. One example is finding ways to avoid extreme social ostracism. Conclusion: We have identified strategies and tactics that some doubly-uninfected IDUs have developed to stay safe. Staying Safe methodology develops grounded hypotheses. These can be tested through cohort studies of incidence and prevention trials of hypothesis-based programs to help drug injectors make their injection and sexual careers safer for themselves and others. This positive deviance control-case life history method might be used to study avoiding other infections like genital herpes among sex workers.


Related Articles

  • Knowledge of the Most-at-Risk Populations about Human Immunodeficiency Virus Prevention. Ebadian, A.; Alli, V.; Sedghi, H.; Chaharborj, S. Seddighi; Fudziah, I. // American Journal of Applied Sciences;2009, Vol. 6 Issue 11, p1921 

    Problem statement: In this study we tried to assess the knowledge of general population (15-45 years), injecting drug users, female sex workers, MSM and male prisoners about HIV prevention in Iran. Approach: Respondents are asked the following set of prompted questions: (a) Can we reduce the...

  • Recommendation for Control and Prevention of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) Infection in Intravenous Drug Users. Brickner, Philip W.; Torres, Ramon A.; Barnes, Mark; Newman, Robert G.; Des Jarlais, Don C.; Whalen, Dennis P.; Rogers, David E. // Annals of Internal Medicine;5/15/89, Vol. 110 Issue 10, p833 

    Provides information on several recommendations to control the spread of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) in intravenous drug users. Efficacy of HIV antibody testing; Details on free distribution of clean needles and syringes; Role of education for the prevention of infection associated with...

  • Risk, Vulnerability and Gender in the Caribbean Context of HIV. Barrow, Christine // Journal of Eastern Caribbean Studies;Dec2011, Vol. 36 Issue 4, p1 

    An introduction to the journal is presented wherein the editor discusses various articles published within the issue on topics including the success story of reduction in HIV transmission from mothers to their babies, the vulnerabilities of women in the Caribbean context of HIV, and the links...

  • Human immunodeficiency virus, AIDS, and drug consumption in South America and the Caribbean: epidemiological evidence and initiatives to curb the epidemic. Hacker, Mariana A.; Malta, Monica; Enriquez, Melissa; Bastos, Francisco I. // Revista Panamericana de Salud Publica;Oct/Nov2005, Vol. 18 Issue 4/5, p303 

    Objective. The paper reviews data on drug use in relation to the spread of human immunodeficiency virus and AIDS in South America and the Caribbean. Methods. Information was gathered by thoroughly reviewing major bibliographic databanks, web sites of international institutions and regional...

  • Drugs, sex work, and HIV in three South African cities. Leggett, Ted // Society in Transition;2001, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p101 

    Prostitutes in urban areas in South Africa were studied to examine the extent to which drug addiction has led to prostitution. Samples drawn from sex workers in Johannesburg, Durban and Cape Town were studied. The hypothesised link between drug addiction and prostitution was not found. Running...

  • Criminalisation, human rights and sex work in the Pacific. Worth, Heather; McMillan, Karen // Human Rights Defender;Jul2014, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p26 

    No abstract available.

  • REAL AND PERCEIVED HIV RISK BY POPULATION DENSITY: AN EXPLORATORY EXAMINATION. Leukefeld, Carl G.; Farabee, David; McDermeit, Melissia; Dennis, Michael L.; Wechsberg, Wendee M.; Inciardi, James A.; Surratt, Hilary L.; Compton, Wilson M.; Cottler, Linda B.; Klein, Hugh; Hoffman, Jeffrey A.; Desmond, David; Logan, T. K. // Journal of Drug Issues;Fall2001, Vol. 31 Issue 4, p889 

    Little is known about HIV and its primary routes of transmission in less populated areas. The purpose of this exploratory study was to contrast the real and perceived HIV risk among out-of-treatment drug users in a multi-site sample of low-, medium-, and high-population density counties in six...

  • Subtype-specific Transmission Probabilities for Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 among Injecting Drug Users in Bangkok, Thailand. Hudgens, Michael G.; Longini, Jr., Ira M.; Vanichseni, Suphak; Hu, Dale J.; Kitayaporn, Dwip; Mock, Philip A.; Halloran, M. Elizabeth; Satten, Glen A.; Choopanya, Kachit; Mastro, Timothy D. // American Journal of Epidemiology;Jan2002, Vol. 155 Issue 2, p159 

    The Bangkok (Thailand) Metropolitan Administration cohort of injecting drug users (IDUs) consisted of 1,209 IDUs initially seronegative for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) who were followed from 1995 to 1998 at 15 Administration drug treatment clinics. At enrollment and approximately every 4...

  • National Response to HIV/AIDS in India. Bachani, Damodar; Sogarwal, Ruchi // Indian Journal of Community Medicine;Oct2010, Vol. 35 Issue 4, p469 

    The article offers information on the National AIDS Control Programme (NACP), which was developed with address the continuous spread of HIV in India. The epidemiology of HIV in India is described, along with the four-pronged strategy implemented by NACP to address it. A discussion on the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics