Surgical Compared with Conservative Treatment for Acute Nondisplaced or Minimally Displaced Scaphoid Fractures

Buijze, Geert A.; Doornberg, Job N.; Ham, John S.; Ring, David; Bhandari, Mohit; Poolman, Rudolf W.
June 2010
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jun2010, Vol. 92-A Issue 6, p1534
Academic Journal
Background: There is a current trend in orthopaedic practice to treat nondisplaced or minimally displaced fractures with early open reduction and internal fixation instead of cast immobilization. This trend is not evidence–based. In this systematic review and meta–analysis, we pool data from trials comparing surgical and conservative treatment for acute nondisplaced and minimally displaced scaphoid fractures, thus aiming to summarize the best available evidence. Methods: A systematic literature search of the medical literature from 1966 to 2009 was performed. We selected eight randomized controlled trials comparing surgical with conservative treatment for acute nondisplaced or minimally displaced scaphoid fractures in adults. Data from included studies were pooled with use of fixed–effects and random–effects models with standard mean differences and risk ratios for continuous and dichotomous variables, respectively. Heterogeneity across studies was assessed with calculation of the 2 statistic. Results: Four hundred and nineteen patients from eight trials were included. Two hundred and seven patients were treated surgically, and 212 were treated conservatively. Most trials lacked scientific rigor. Our primary outcome parameter, standardized functional outcome, which was assessed for 247 patients enrolled in four trials, significantly favored surgical treatment (p < 0.01). With regard to our secondary parameters, we found heterogeneous results that favored surgical treatment in terms of satisfaction (assessed in one study), grip strength (six studies), time to union (three studies), and time off work (five studies). In contrast, we found no significant differences between surgical and conservative treatment with regard to pain (two studies), range of motion (six studies), the rates of nonunion (six studies) and malunion (seven studies), and total treatment costs (two studies). The rate of complications was higher in the surgical treatment group (23.7%) than in the conservative group (9.1%), although this difference was not significant (p = 0.13). There was a nearly significantly higher rate of scaphotrapezial osteoarthritis in the surgical treatment group (p = 0.05). Conclusions: Based on primary studies with limited methodological quality, this study suggests that surgical treatment is favorable for acute nondisplaced and minimally displaced scaphoid fractures with regard to functional outcome and time off work; however, surgical treatment engenders more complications. Thus, the long–term risks and short–term benefits of surgery should be carefully weighed in clinical decision–making.


Related Articles

  • Bilateral Trans-Scaphoid Perilunate Fracture Dislocation. Seung-Bum Chae; Jun-Ho Nam // Journal of the Korean Society for Surgery of the Hand;Sep2015, Vol. 20 Issue 3, p127 

    Bilateral trans-scaphoid perilunate fracture dislocations are uncommon and have been rarely reported in the literature. Furthermore, it is more difficult to manage in the case of Fenton's syndrome (scaphocapitate fracture syndrome, trans-scaphoid trans-capitate fracture dislocation). These...

  • Scaphoid Fractures: What's Hot, What's Not. Geissler, William B.; Adams, Julie E.; Bindra, Randy R.; Lanzinger, William D.; Slutsky, David I. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;1/18/2012, Vol. 94-A Issue 2, p169 

    The article discusses important facts that orthopaedic surgeons should know about scaphoid fractures. It says that scaphoid fractures can be considered as the most prevalent type of fracture in the carpal bone. According to the authors, around 60 to 70 per cent of carpal fractures are all...

  • Current Concepts in the Treatment of Scaphoid Fractures. Sauerbier, Michael; Germann, Günter; Dacho, Andreas // European Journal of Trauma;Apr2004, Vol. 30 Issue 2, p80 

    Fractures of the carpus are frequent injuries and typically result from of a fall onto the outstretched hand. Scaphoid fractures are the second most frequent fracture type of the hand (80%). 95% of the patients with acute scaphoid fractures are male, and the average age is approximately 25...

  • Reliability and validity of carpal alignment measurements in evaluating deformities of scaphoid fractures. Roh, Young; Noh, Jung; Lee, Beom; Baek, Jong; Oh, Joo; Gong, Hyun; Baek, Goo // Archives of Orthopaedic & Trauma Surgery;Jun2014, Vol. 134 Issue 6, p887 

    Purpose: Several radiographic carpal alignment indices are used to evaluate the deformities of scaphoid fractures. The purpose of this study was to determine the reliabilities and validities of radiographic carpal alignment indices commonly used to evaluate deformities of scaphoid fractures....

  • Palmar dislocation of the scaphoid and lunate as a unit. Raemisch, Michael E.; Rotman, Mitchell B. // Orthopedics;Nov2004, Vol. 27 Issue 11, p1199 

    This article presents a case study of scaphoid and lunate palmer dislocation in a 33-year-old right-handed man. Carpal dislocations and fracture dislocations are common injuries of the wrist. The man was presented to the emergency room with left wrist pain and swelling after an assault, which is...

  • Musculoskeletal: what is different in children? Playing dodge ball: falls, wrist pain. Swischuk, Leonard // Emergency Radiology;Feb2015, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p79 

    The article describes the case of a 12-year-old male patient who complained of pain and swelling on his left wrist following a dodge ball game. Particular focus is to common fractures of the carpal bones, as well as the patient's mechanism of injury. Topics discussed include radiographic...

  • Segmental fracture of the scaphoid: report of a rare fracture pattern. Assunção, RE; Yates, P; Hargreaves, DG // Archives of Orthopaedic & Trauma Surgery;Sep2005, Vol. 125 Issue 7, p479 

    Introduction:To the best of our knowledge, there are no reports in the orthopaedic and trauma literature of true segmental fracture of the scaphoid bone. We present such a case with a brief discussion of the morphology and mechanisms of injury of scaphoid fractures and the problems they present,...

  • Functional outcome and cost-effectiveness of pulsed electromagnetic fields in the treatment of acute scaphoid fractures: a cost-utility analysis. Hannemann, Pascal F. W.; Essers, Brigitte A. B.; Schots, Judith P. M.; Dullaert, Koen; Poeze, Martijn; Brink, Peter R. G. // BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders;2015, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Physical forces have been widely used to stimulate bone growth in fracture repair. Addition of bone growth stimulation to the conservative treatment regime is more costly than standard health care. However, it might lead to cost-savings due to a reduction of the total amount of...

  • Some aspects of the fractured scaphoid. Thomas, Tudor L. // Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine;Nov1981, Vol. 74 Issue 11, p800 

    Ninety-three patients who presented at a district general hospital in one year with a suspected or actual scaphoid fracture were studied. Certain changes in the accepted management of scaphoid fractures, particularly the radiology of these fractures, are suggested. These changes could result in...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics