Curbside Consultation Re-imagined: Borrowing from the Conflict Management Toolkit

Edelstein, Lauren; Lynch, John; Mokwunye, Nneka; DeRenzo, Evan
March 2010
HEC Forum;Mar2010, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p41
Academic Journal
Curbside ethics consultations occur when an ethics consultant provides guidance to a party who seeks assistance over ethical concerns in a case, without the consultant involving other stakeholders, conducting his or her own comprehensive review of the case, or writing a chart note. Some have argued that curbside consultation is problematic because the consultant, in focusing on a single narrative offered by the party seeking advice, necessarily fails to account for the full range of moral perspectives. Their concern is that any guidance offered by the ethics consultant will privilege and empower one party’s viewpoint over—and to the exclusion of—other stakeholders. This could lead to serious harms, such as the ethicist being reduced to a means to an end for a clinician seeking to achieve his or her own preferred outcome, the ethicist denying the broader array of stakeholders input in the process, or the ethicist providing wrongheaded or biased advice, posing dangers to the ethical quality of decision-making. Although these concerns are important and must be addressed, we suggest that they are manageable. This paper proposes using conflict coaching, a practice developed within the discipline of conflict management, to mitigate the risks posed by curbside consultation, and thereby create new “spaces” for moral discourse in the care of patients. Thinking of curbside consultations as an opportunity for “clinical ethics conflict coaching” can more fully integrate ethics committee members into the daily ethics of patient care and reduce the frequency of ethically harmful outcomes.


Related Articles

  • Use of the Medical Ethics Consultation Service in a Busy Level I Trauma Center: Impact on Decision-Making and Patient Care. Johnson, Laura S.; Lesandrini, Jason; Rozycki, Grace S. // American Surgeon;Jul2012, Vol. 78 Issue 7, p735 

    The purposes of this study were to assess reasons for consultation of the Ethics Consultation Service for trauma patients and how consultations impacted care. We conducted a review of ethics consultations at a Level I trauma center from 2001 to 2010. Data included patient demographics, etiology...

  • How physicians face ethical difficulties: a qualitative analysis. Hurst, S. A.; Hull, S. C.; DuVal, G.; Danis, M. // Journal of Medical Ethics;Jan2005, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p7 

    Background: Physicians face ethical difficulties daily, yet they seek ethics consultation infrequently. To date, no systematic data have been collected on the strategies they use to resolve such difficulties when they do so without the help of ethics consultation. Thus, our understanding of...

  • Ethics in nursing. Taylor, Carol // Australian Nursing Journal;Dec2004/Jan2005, Vol. 12 Issue 6, p11 

    Discusses the work ethics in nursing. Reason behind the importance of the promotion of individual and institutional ethics in nursing; Influence of nurses to facilitate ethical decisions in medical care; Capability of a nurse to initiate ethics consult.

  • Feminist Values and Bioethics Practice: Strangers at the Bedside? Miller, Jessica Prata // APA Newsletters;Fall2005, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p3 

    The article discusses feminist medical ethics consultation. It explains the facilitation model of ethics according to the report "Core Competencies for Health Care Ethics Consultation" from the American Society for Bioethics and Humanities. In the author's opinion, the social context in ethics...

  • Saturday Morning Postmortem. Cohn, Felicia; Aulisio, Mark; Lantos, John D. // Hastings Center Report;Mar2010, Vol. 40 Issue 2, p4 

    Several letters to the editor are presented in response to the article "Saturday Morning in the Clinic" by Kyle Galbraith and Joshua Perry in the September-October 2009 issue.

  • Grassroots Origins, National Engagement: Exploring the Professionalization of Practicing Healthcare Ethicists in Canada. Frolic, Andrea // HEC Forum;Sep2012, Vol. 24 Issue 3, p153 

    Canadian ethicists have a long legacy of leadership in advocating for standards and quality in healthcare ethics. Continuing this tradition, a grassroots organization of practicing healthcare ethicists (PHEs) concerned about the lack of standardization in the field recently formed to explore...

  • Clinical Ethics Consultation in the United Kingdom. McLean, Sheila A. M. // Diametros: An Online Journal of Philosophy;Dec2009, Issue 22, p76 

    The article reports on the implications of clinical ethics consultation for health care professionals in Great Britain. It discusses factors that encouraged physicians to request for ethics consultation, concerns about clinical ethics committees (CECs) and the impact of ethical dilemmas on...

  • BIOETHICS AT MIDLIFE the dilemmas facing a field in flux. Ipaktchian, Susan // Stanford Medicine;Winter2011, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p8 

    The article focuses on bioethics which intends to argue ethical issues related to bioscience and medicine. It states that bioethics is the focus of various individuals in the U.S. in which it is the principal field of clinical practice and research. It says that ethics consultation is a rare...

  • Echo Calling Narcissus: What Exceeds the Gaze of Clinical Ethics Consultation? Bishop, Jeffrey; Fanning, Joseph; Bliton, Mark // HEC Forum;Mar2010, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p73 

    Guiding our response in this essay is our view that current efforts to demarcate the role of the clinical ethicist risk reducing its complex network of authorizations to sites of power and payment. In turn, the role becomes susceptible to various ideologies—individualisms, proceduralisms,...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics