Comparison of PubMed and Google Scholar Literature Searches

Anders, Michael E.; Evans, Dennis P.
May 2010
Respiratory Care;May2010, Vol. 55 Issue 5, p578
Academic Journal
BACKGROUND: Literature searches are essential to evidence-based respiratory care. To conduct literature searches, respiratory therapists rely on search engines to retrieve information, but there is a dearth of literature on the comparative efficiencies of search engines for researching clinical questions in respiratory care. OBJECTIVE: To compare PubMed and Google Scholar search results for clinical topics in respiratory care to that of a benchmark. METHODS: We performed literature searches with PubMed and Google Scholar, on 3 clinical topics. In PubMed we used the Clinical Queries search filter. In Google Scholar we used the search filters in the Advanced Scholar Search option. We used the reference list of a related Cochrane Collaboration evidence-based systematic review as the benchmark for each of the search results. We calculated recall (sensitivity) and precision (positive predictive value) with 2 x 2 contingency tables. We compared the results with the chi-square test of independence and Fisher's exact test. RESULTS: PubMed and Google Scholar had similar recall for both overall search results (71% vs 69%) and full-text results (43% vs 51%). PubMed had better precision than Google Scholar for both overall search results (13% vs 0.07%, P < .001) and full-text results (8% vs 0.05%. P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that PubMed searches with the Clinical Queries filter are more precise than with the Advanced Scholar Search in Google Scholar for respiratory care topics. PubMed appears to be more practical to conduct efficient, valid searches for informing evidence-based patient-care protocols, for guiding the care of individual patients, and For educational purposes.


Related Articles

  • Alabama Member Breaking New Ground.  // AARC Times;Apr2014, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p54 

    The article reports on AARC member Darrell Fixler, who serves as a firefighter-respiratory therapist for the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Fire Department. In his role, Fixler is working closely with VA facilities in his area in an effort to develop a new ambulance service that will...

  • Bifurcate To Survive! Racine, Drew // American Libraries;Sep2006, Vol. 37 Issue 8, p34 

    The article highlights the report Perceptions of Libraries and Information Resources released in the U.S. The survey confirms that longstanding view that people think of books when they think of libraries, but the information they use is overwhelmingly in electronic format, mostly from...

  • A Network System of Medical and Welfare Information Service for the Patients, Their Families, Hospitals, Local Governments, and Commercial Companies in a Medical Service Area. Matsumura, Kouji; Antoku, Yasuaki; Inoue, Reika; Kobayashi, Mariko; Hanada, Eisuke; Iwasaki, Yasutaka; Kumagai, Yasushi; Iwamoto, Haruya; Tsuchihashi, Saburo; Iwaki, Miho; Kira, Jun-ichi; Nose, Yoshiaki // Journal of Medical Systems;Jun2002, Vol. 26 Issue 3, p249 

    A service information system using the Internet, which connected the various people who are related to medical treatment and nursing welfare, was constructed. An intractable neurological disease patient who lives in the Onga district, Fukuoka, Japan, and the people who are related to the service...

  • Power Searching Strategies for Success. Kassel, Amelia // Searcher;Apr2001, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p36 

    Suggests an effective Web searching method. Variables which can be used to alert searchers in using commercial databases; Tools that can be used for power searching on the Web; Routines involved in power searching.

  • Getting To Know the Invisible Web. Smith, C. Brian // Library Journal;Summer2001 Net Connect, Vol. 126 Issue 11, p16 

    Presents tips for using search engines to access the so-called invisible web, or information which is available but not easily accessed by the average Internet user. Reasons why standard search engines cannot find this information, including hindrances by sites which require registration;...

  • Trexy maps out web trail guides. Caldwell, Tracey // Information World Review;Apr2006, Issue 223, p4 

    Reports on the launch of the Trexy search trail technology developed by a London-based company in April 2006. Capacity of the system to trace the previous online researches; Remarks from Trexy developer Megan Hamilton on the features of the technology; Importance of the search engine to...

  • A PRIMER ON THE WEB INFORMATION RETRIEVAL PARADIGM. Bhatia, M. P. S.; Khalid, Akshi Kumar // Journal of Theoretical & Applied Information Technology;7/1/2008, Vol. 4 Issue 7, p657 

    The unabated growth of the Web and the increasing expectation placed by the user on the search engine to anticipate and infer his/her information needs and provide relevant results has fostered the development of the field of Web Information Retrieval (Web IR). The recent surveys claim that 85%...

  • The Death of Full-Text Searching. Beall, Jeffrey // PNLA Quarterly;Winter2006, Vol. 70 Issue 2, p5 

    Provides information on full-text searching, a process used to retrieve information. Impact of the increase in online resources on full-text searching; Features of a metadata-enabled search engine; Comparison of the precision of full-text retrievals and metadata retrievals.

  • Target the right search solution. Khan, Kamran // Communications News;Dec2000, Vol. 37 Issue 12, p76 

    Provides information on Boolean search, a concept of finding information over the Internet. Words that determine results being used in the Boolean searching; Information on concept searching; How natural-language searching differs from Boolean and concept searching.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics