Uncritical reverence in CM reporting: Assessing the scientific quality of Australian news media reports

Lewis, Monique; Orrock, Paul; Myers, Stephen
April 2010
Health Sociology Review;Apr2010, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p57
Academic Journal
Objectives: The study is an exploratory study of a media event in Australia based on the publication of two separate systematic analyses of complementary medicine (CM) therapies. The objective of the study was to measure the scientific quality of Australian newspaper media reports about two international peer-reviewed research papers reporting results on complementary medicines published in biomedical journals during Feb/March 2007. For purposes of clarity, we refer to the papers as the ‘Antioxidant Study’ (Bjelakovic et al 2007) and the ‘Prenatal Multivitamin Study’ (Goh et al 2007). Methods: We sourced articles that were published about the two research papers in mainstream metropolitan and national Australian newspapers during February and March 2007. We then applied a model of analysis called the Index of Scientific Quality (ISQ) to measure the scientific quality of the news reports. Results: We identified 14 newspaper articles and one newswire article about the Antioxidant Study and two newspaper articles about the Prenatal Multivitamin Study. Of the seven ISQ criteria, ‘validity’ and ‘precision’ were rated the least adequate, ‘important consequences’ of the research were reported partially in the Antioxidant Study and wholly in the Prenatal Multivitamin Study, and ‘opinion from fact’ was adequate in the majority of articles. Conclusion: This exploratory study conveyed an overall inadequacy in the scientific quality of the newspaper reporting about the two CM studies in major metropolitan and national Australian newspapers. Whilst we found that journalists were careful to attribute opinions to their sources, their reports conveyed a very limited understanding of biomedical research methodologies and a subsequent incapacity to scrutinise these methodologies with rigour.


Related Articles

  • Short Features and Brief Takes Issue 204. Coad, Cherry // Positive Health;Mar2013, Issue 204, p1 

    The article focuses on several health care companies in Great Britain. Organic Aromatherapy, a small company based in West Sussex is run by Sarah Williams ITEC MGPP AC regd internationally trained holistic bodywork therapist. Balens are a fourth generation, ethical, family business established...

  • What you should know about Iridology Constitutional Typing. Miller, Toni // Journal of the Australian Traditional-Medicine Society;Mar2014, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p70 

    The article discusses the constitutional approach in understanding advanced iridology techniques. It mentions the importance of constitutional typing as a module in physical assessment of the iris. It notes that the value of such approach lies in the understanding of the colour, structure, and...

  • Mixed Methods in CAM Research: A Systematic Review of Studies Published in 2012. Holmes, Michelle // Journal of Alternative & Complementary Medicine;May2014, Vol. 20 Issue 5, pA13 

    An abstract of the study "Mixed Methods in CAM Research: A Systematic Review of Studies Published in 2012" by Felicity Bishop and Michelle Holmes is presented.

  • Knowing the Score - the NLP SCORE Pattern. Coombes, Frances // Positive Health;Jan2015, Issue 219, p1 

    The article focuses on the techniques offered by neuro-linguistic programming (NLP) to help individuals think on a deeper level. Topics discussed include the need to understand the Symptoms, Causes, Outcomes, Resources and Effects (S.C.O.R.E.) in play in any given situation, the questions to ask...

  • Feng Shui to Warm the Heart. COLLINS, AMANDA // Oriental Medicine;Spring2014, p21 

    The article discusses the use of Feng Shui to improve human health.

  • Editorial Issue 219. Goodman, Sandra // Positive Health;Jan2015, Issue 219, p1 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various articles within the issue including a review of the book "You Can Beat Lung Cancer" by Carl Helvie, "How I Healed my Skin through Juicing Raw Fruit, Veg and Exercise" by Hanna Sillitoe, and "The Clinical Impact of Vitamin C: My...

  • Victoria Backs Pretend Medicine. Bowditch, Peter // Australasian Science;Jan/Feb2004, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p46 

    Questions the motives of the government of Victoria for establishing a research center for alternative medicines. Claims made by the Australian alternative medicine industry; Decision of the Victorian government to give the industry a grant to help set up the first research center for...

  • Demystifying 'Detox': What it Is and What it Isn't. Montgomery, Elizabeth // Positive Health;Jul2014, Issue 215, p1 

    The article focuses on toxicity and the reality of true detoxification, citing the long process involved in toxin removal. Topics discussed include the various detox approaches available, what a short detox is realistically able to achieve and the key lifestyle requirements to support the...

  • A Context Hypothesis on Biomedical Diagnoses in TCM Practice. Stuardi, Tracy // Journal of Alternative & Complementary Medicine;Sep2011, Vol. 17 Issue 9, p785 

    A letter to the editor is presented regarding the role of biomedical diagnosis in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) practice from the perspective of patients and practitioners.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics