Validity of self-reported weight, height and resultant body mass index in Chinese adolescents and factors associated with errors in self-reports

Xiaoyan Zhou; Dibley, Michael J.; Yue Cheng; Xue Ouyang; Hong Yan
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p190
Academic Journal
Background: Validity of self-reported height and weight has not been adequately evaluated in diverse adolescent populations. In fact there are no reported validity studies conducted in Asian children and adolescents. This study aims to examine the accuracy of self-reported weight, height, and resultant BMI values in Chinese adolescents, and of the adolescents' subsequent classification into overweight categories. Methods: Weight and height were self-reported and measured in 1761 adolescents aged 12-16 years in a crosssectional survey in Xi'an city, China. BMI was calculated from both reported values and measured values. Bland-Altman plots with 95% limits of agreement, Pearson's correlation and Kappa statistics were calculated to assess the agreement. Results: The 95% limits of agreement were -11.16 and 6.46 kg for weight, -4.73 and 7.45 cm for height, and -4.93 and 2.47 kg/m2 for BMI. Pearson correlation between measured and self-reported values was 0.912 for weight, 0.935 for height and 0.809 for BMI. Weighted Kappa was 0.859 for weight, 0.906 for height and 0.754 for BMI. Sensitivity for detecting overweight (includes obese) in adolescents was 56.1%, and specificity was 98.6%. Subjects' area of residence, age and BMI were significant factors associated with the errors in self-reporting weight, height and relative BMI. Conclusions: Reported weight and height does not have an acceptable agreement with measured data. Therefore, we do not recommend the application of self-reported weight and height to screen for overweight adolescents in China. Alternatively, self-reported data could be considered for use, with caution, in surveillance systems and epidemiology studies.


Related Articles

  • The relationship between meal frequency and body mass index in black and white adolescent girls: more is less. Franko, D. L.; Striegel-Moore, R. H.; Thompson, D.; Affenito, S. G.; Schreiber, G. B.; Daniels, S. R.; Crawford, P. B. // International Journal of Obesity;Jan2008, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p23 

    Objective:To document meal frequency and its relationship to body mass index (BMI) in a longitudinal sample of black and white girls from ages 9–19 years.Design:Ten-year longitudinal observational study.Subjects:At baseline, 1209 Black girls (539 age nine years, 670 age 10 years) and...

  • Web-Based Self-Reported Height, Weight, and Body Mass Index Among Swedish Adolescents: A Validation Study. Ekström, Sandra; Kull, Inger; Nilsson, Sara; Bergström, Anna // Journal of Medical Internet Research;Mar2015, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p1 

    Background: Web-collected height and weight are increasingly used in epidemiological studies; however, the validity has rarely been evaluated. Objective: The aim of the study was to validate self-reported height, weight, and corresponding body mass index (BMI) among Swedish adolescents aged...

  • Commentary: The quest for weight standards. Flegal, Katherine M. // International Journal of Epidemiology;Aug2010, Vol. 39 Issue 4, p963 

    The author discusses the compilation of height and weight standards in 1897 used by insurance companies, which focused on measured factors with good predictive values, rather than causal factors in health research. She notes the start of the wide use of body mass index (BMI) with standardized...

  • CHANGES IN ESTONIAN SCHOOL STUDENTS' HEIGHT AND WEIGHT IN THE LAST TEN YEARS. Koskel, Säde; Tiit, Ene-Margit; Kaarma, Helje // Papers on Anthropology;2010, Vol. 19, p211 

    The article presents, according to age groups, data on Estonian school students' (aged 7-18 years) height, weight and body mass index collected from schools in recent years. The data are compared with similar data collected ten years before -- in 1998. For statistical comparison, the t-test is...

  • Even fatter.  // Journal of Chinese Medicine;Jun2006, Issue 81, p72 

    The article discusses research being done on obesity. It references a study by M. Ezzati et al published in a 2006 issue of "Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine." A 50% inaccuracy in body mass index statistics was revealed due to weight understatement and height understatement based on...

  • INACCURACIES IN SELF-REPORTED WEIGHT AND HEIGHT VARIES BY ETHNICITY AND SEX.  // Ethnicity & Disease;Winter2012, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p113 

    The article presents an overview of a study which examined self-assessed body height, body weight and body mass index (BMI) in the U.S. based on race and ethnicity and gender.

  • BODY MASS INDEX AND BODY FAT CONTENT IN ADOLESCENT GIRLS. Glogowska, Joanna; Stupnicki, Romuald // Papers on Anthropology;2008, Vol. 17, p72 

    The aim of the study was to assess the degree of overweight and/or underweight tendencies in non-urban, adolescent girls from the South-Eastern part of Poland. A group of 30 girls aged 14.5-15.5 years participated in the study. The girls were examined twice, 6 months apart, with respect to body...

  • Longitudinal BMI percentile curves by maturity status of Japanese children. Tsutomu Mino; Malina, Robert M.; Koichi Nariyama // Anthropological Review;2012, Vol. 75 Issue 1, p33 

    The objective of the research was to prepare longitudinal percentile curves for the BMI (kg/m2) relative to time before and after peak height velocity (PHV) in Japanese boys and girls born between 1989 and 1991. Stature and weight were measured in every April from 6.5 to 16.5 years for 283 boys...

  • A PATH ANALYSIS ON THE NOURISHMENT DIRECTED HAEMOGLOBIN STATUS AND: RESULTING ENDURANCE CAPACITY OF ADOLESCENT INDIAN RURAL GIRLS. Panjikkaran, Seeja Thomachan; Usha, V. // Journal of Dairying Foods & Home Sciences;2010, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p47 

    A significant positive correlation of blood hemoglobin status and the endurance capacity as the function of nutritional status of a cross-sectional population of adolescent rural girls (13-15 years) of Thrissur district, Kerala State, India has been reported. Anthropometric measurements revealed...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics