Physician reports of medication use with explicit intention of hastening the end of life in the absence of explicit patient request in general practice in Belgium

Meeussen, Koen; Block, Lieve Van den; Bossuyt, Nathalie; Echteld, Michael; Bilsen, Johan; Deliens, Luc
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p186
Academic Journal
Background: Although the incidence of the use of life-ending drugs without explicit patient request has been estimated in several studies, in-depth empirical research on this controversial practice is nonexistent. Based on face-toface interviews with the clinicians involved in cases where patients died following such a decision in general practice in Belgium, we investigated the clinical characteristics of the patients, the decision-making process, and the way the practice was conducted. Methods: Mortality follow-back study in 2005-2006 using the nationwide Sentinel Network of General Practitioners, a surveillance instrument representative of all GPs in Belgium. Standardised face-to-face interviews were conducted with all GPs who reported a non-sudden death in their practice, at home or in a care home, which was preceded by the use of a drug prescribed, supplied or administered by a physican without an explicit patient request. Results: Of the 2690 deaths registered by the GPs, 17 were eligible to be included in the study. Thirteen interviews were conducted. GPs indicated that at the time of the decision all patients were without prospect of improvement, with persistent and unbearable suffering to a (very) high degree in nine cases. Twelve patients were judged to lack the competence to make decisions. GPs were unaware of their patient's end-of-life wishes in nine cases, but always discussed the practice with other caregivers and/or the patient's relatives. All but one patient received opioids to hasten death. All GPs believed that end-of-life quality had been "improved considerably". Conclusions: The practice of using life-ending drugs without explicit patient request in general practice in Belgium mainly involves non-competent patients experiencing persistent and unbearable suffering whose end-of-life wishes can no longer be ascertained. GPs do not act as isolated decision-makers and they believe they act in the best interests of the patient. Advance care planning could help to inform GPs about patients' wishes prior to their loss of competence.


Related Articles

  • Who makes crucial decisions on reproduction and contraception? Earle, Sarah; Tilley, Liz; Walmsley, Jan // Learning Disability Practice;Oct2012, Vol. 15 Issue 8, p34 

    This article describes the findings of an online survey exploring contraception for people with learning disabilities. The survey reveals that this is a complex subject but that in two thirds of cases the Mental Capacity Act 2005 was not being implemented. The subject is of particular relevance...

  • Purchasing drugs on the internet.  // GP: General Practitioner;12/9/2002, p48 

    Discusses concerns of general practitioners (GP) regarding patients' decision to purchase drugs on internet. Comments of GP Louise Warburton of Cannock, Staffordshire on absence of responsibility of GPs for problems from the purchase; Lack of information to compare various medications on...

  • Red flags: Is it the time to switch doctors? Conn, Doyt L. // Arthritis Today;May/Jun99, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p62 

    Advises arthritis patients on choosing their physicians and evaluating their competency. Importance of a self-determination of the type of the arthritis; Reservations about current doctor; Ability to provide information about additional non-drug treatment approaches; Refusal to prescribe oral...

  • Towards a feasible model for shared decision making: focus group study with general practices regis. Elwyn, Glyn; Edwards, Adrian // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);09/18/99, Vol. 319 Issue 7212, p753 

    Deals with a study which explored the views of general practice registrars about involving patients in decisions and assessed the feasibility of using the shared decision making model by means of simulated general practice consultations. Methodology; Suggestions for shared decision making;...

  • Idealistic, impractical, impossible? Shared decision making in the real world. Elwyn, Glyn // British Journal of General Practice;Jun2006, Vol. 56 Issue 527, p403 

    In this article, the author explores the presence of shared decision making in medicine in Great Britain in 2006. The author begins with the reactions of general practitioners to the expert patient programme. He then describes the position of the public on the involvement of patients in decision...

  • Participation of French general practitioners in end-of-life decisions for their hospitalised patients. Ferrand, E.; Jabre, P.; Fernandez-Curiel, S.; Morin, F.; Vincent-Genod, C.; Duvaldestin, P.; Lemaire, F.; Hervé, C.; Marty, J. // Journal of Medical Ethics;Dec2006, Vol. 32 Issue 12, p683 

    Background and objective: Assuming the hypothesis that the general practitioner (GP) can and should be a key player in making end-of-life decisions for hospitalized patients, perceptions of GP's role assigned to them by hospital doctors in making withdrawal decisions for such patients were...

  • Why are eligible patients not prescribed aspirin in primary care? A qualitative study indicating measures for improvement. Short, Duncan; Frischer, Martin; Bashford, James; Ashcroft, Darren // BMC Family Practice;2003, Vol. 4, p9 

    Background: Despite evidence-based guidelines, aspirin prescribing for the secondary prevention of stroke is sub-optimal. Little is known about why general practitioners do not prescribe aspirin to indicated patients. We sought to identify and describe factors that lead general practitioners...

  • A gruesomely inevitable choice.  // GP: General Practitioner;2/13/2009, p29 

    The author reflects on the difficulty to find a person who would chair a patient liaison group. She cites the qualities to consider when looking for a person to chair the patient group. She stresses that it was Mrs. Colon whom they find capable to lead and represent the group because of her...

  • Dealing with suicidal patients -- a challenging task: a qualitative study of young physicians' experiences. Sørensen Høifødt, Tordis; Talseth, Anne-Grethe // BMC Medical Education;2006, Vol. 6, p44 

    Background: Suicide is a major public health problem and treating suicidal patients represents one of the most challenging and complex clinical situations for young physicians. Education of physicians is considered an important strategy in suicide prevention. Young physicians often meet suicidal...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics