Multiple barriers against successful care provision for depressed patients in general internal medicine in a Japanese rural hospital: a cross-sectional study

Ohtsuki, Tsuyuka; Inagaki, Masatoshi; Oikawa, Yuetsu; Saitoh, Akiyoshi; Kurosawa, Mie; Muramatsu, Kumiko; Yamada, Mitsuhiko
January 2010
BMC Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 10, p30
Academic Journal
Background: A general internist has an important role in primary care, especially for the elderly in rural areas of Japan. Although effective intervention models for depressed patients in general practice and primary care settings have been developed in the US and UK medical systems, there is little information regarding even the recognition rate and prescription rate of psychotropic medication by general internists in Japan. The present study surveyed these data cross-sectionally in a general internal medicine outpatient clinic of a Japanese rural hospital. Methods: Patients were consecutively recruited and evaluated for major depressive disorder or any mood disorder using the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ). Physicians who were blinded to the results of the PHQ were asked to diagnose whether the patients had any mental disorders, and if so, whether they had mood disorders or not. Data regarding prescription of psychotropic medicines were collected from medical records. Results: Among 312 patients, 27 (8.7%) and 52 (16.7%) were identified with major depressive disorder and any mood disorder using the PHQ, respectively. Among those with major depressive disorder, 21 (77.8%) were recognized by physicians as having a mental disorder, but only three (11.1%) were diagnosed as having a mood disorder. Only two patients with major depressive disorder (7.4%) had been prescribed antidepressants. Even among those (n = 15) whom physicians diagnosed with a mood disorder irrespective of the PHQ results, only four (26.7%) were prescribed an antidepressant. Conclusions: Despite a high prevalence of depression, physicians did not often recognize depression in patients. In addition, most patients who were diagnosed by physicians as having a mood disorder were not prescribed antidepressants. Multiple barriers to providing appropriate care for depressed patients exist, such as recognizing depression, prescribing appropriate medications, and appropriately referring patients to mental health specialists.


Related Articles

  • Cross-sectional survey of patients in receipt of long-term repeat prescriptions for antidepressant drugs in primary care. Cruickshank, Gillian; MacGillivray, Steve; Bruce, David; Mather, Anne; Matthews, Keith; Williams, Brian // Mental Health in Family Medicine;2008, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p105 

    This cross-sectional survey describes the clinical characteristics of 92 patients from across 12 general medical practices, in receipt of a long-term repeat prescription of an antidepressant for the treatment of depression. Psychiatric diagnoses were determined using the Schedule for Clinical...

  • Time for a rethink of treatment for patients with depression in primary care. Arroll, Bruce; Moir, Fiona // British Journal of General Practice;Sep2010, Vol. 60 Issue 578, p641 

    The authors advocate the development of nonpharmacological strategies as treatment for depression in primary care setting in Great Britain. They references several articles and studies highlighting the benefits of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. They argue that clinicians' belief in...

  • Physical activity as a treatment for depression: the TREAD randomised trial protocol. Baxter, Helen; Winder, Rachel; Chalder, Melanie; Wright, Christine; Sherlock, Sofie; Haase, Anne; Wiles, Nicola J.; Montgomery, Alan A.; Taylor, Adrian H.; Fox, Ken R.; Lawlor, Debbie A.; Peters, Tim J.; Sharp, Deborah J.; Campbell, John; Lewis, Glyn // Trials;2010, Vol. 11, p105 

    Background: Depression is one of the most common reasons for consulting a General Practitioner (GP) within the UK. Whilst antidepressants have been shown to be clinically effective, many patients and healthcare professionals would like to access other forms of treatment as an alternative or...

  • Phone therapy improves depression. Baines, Emma // GP: General Practitioner;9/6/2004, p11 

    The article cites that psychotherapy via the telephone improves the effectiveness of antidepressants in patients taking them for the first time. It showed that patients taking antidepressants who also received telephone psychotherapy were more likely to show improvement in their depression than...

  • Better Integration of Mental Health Care Improves Depression Screening and Treatment in Primary Care. PHILLIPS JR., ROBERT L.; MILLER, BENJAMIN F.; PETTERSON, STEPHEN M.; TEEVAN, BRIDGET // American Family Physician;11/1/2011, Vol. 84 Issue 9, following p2 

    The article discusses how better mental health care integration can improve the screening and treatment for depression in primary care. It is said that screening for depression in primary care remains at a low level and financial support for the integration of mental health care into primary...

  • Doing well by yourself. Wallace, John // Mental Health Today;Sep2006, p12 

    The article offers information on Scotland's national pilot program which focuses on ways to tackle depression. In 2003, Scotland has launched the national Doing Well by People With Depression program to explore new approaches to the treatment of depression at the primary care level. The...

  • Impacting Late Life Depression: Integrating a Depression Intervention into Primary Care. Oishi, Sabine M.; Shoai, Rebecca; Katon, Wayne; Callahan, Christopher; Un�tzer, J�rgen // Psychiatric Quarterly;Mar2003, Vol. 74 Issue 1, p75 

    Care for depression in late life is often less successful in primary care than in carefully controlled clinical trials. Collaborative care models attempt to integrate mental health services into primary care. The authors conducted two focus groups and semi-structured individual interviews with...

  • Predictors of outcome in a primary care depression trial. Walker, Edward A.; Katon, Wayne J.; Russo, Joan; Von Korff, Michael; Lin, Elizabeth; Simon, Greg; Bush, Terry; Ludman, Evette; Unützer, Jürgen; Walker, E A; Katon, W J; Russo, J; Von Korff, M; Lin, E; Simon, G; Bush, T; Ludman, E; Unützer, J // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Dec2000, Vol. 15 Issue 12, p859 

    Objective: Previous treatment trials have found that approximately one third of depressed patients have persistent symptoms. We examined whether depression severity, comorbid psychiatric illness, and personality factors might play a role in this lack of response.Design:...

  • ORIGINAL ARTICLE Primary Care Patients with Depression Are Less Accepting of Treatment Than Those Seen by Mental Health Specialists. Van Voorhees, Benjamin W.; Cooper, Lisa A.; Rost, Kathryn M.; Nutting, Paul; Rubenstein, Lisa V.; Meredith, Lisa; Nae-Yuh Wang; Ford, Daniel E. // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Dec2003, Vol. 18 Issue 12, p991 

    This study examined whether depressed patients treated exclusively in primary care report less need for care and less acceptability of treatment options than those depressed patients treated in the specialty mental health setting after up to 6 months of treatment. Cross-sectional study....


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics