Reference Accuracy in Peer-Reviewed Pediatric Orthopaedic Literature

Davids, Jon R.; Weigl, Daniel M.; Edmonds, Joye P.; Blackhurst, Dawn W.
May 2010
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;May2010, Vol. 92-A Issue 5, p1155
Academic Journal
Background: Reference accuracy of articles published in the biomedical literature is determined by the presence of citation and quotation errors. A recent review demonstrated that the median citation error rate per biomedical journal was 39%, and the median quotation error rate per journal was 20%. Reference accuracy in pediatric orthopaedic articles has not been previously reported, to our knowledge. Methods: Two hundred references from twenty articles published in four peer-reviewed orthopaedic journals were randomly selected for assessment of citation and quotation accuracy. Full-text copies of all original references were obtained by interlibrary loan methods and reviewed directly to establish citation accuracy. The presence of citation errors was determined by a single investigator. The relevance of citation errors was determined by assessing the ease of reference retrieval through PubMed. Quotation accuracy was determined by two examiners who reviewed each of the twenty articles and 200 references to compare the claims made for the references in the article against the data and opinions expressed in the actual reference. Results: The total citation error rate across all of the journals was 26% (fifty-one of 200 references) with a 95% confidence interval of 16.5% to 37.3%. The median citation error rate per journal was 27% (range, 10% to 38%). Although citation errors were common, most were of minimal significance, as 196 of the 200 references could be retrieved with ease from PubMed. The total quotation error rate across all of the articles was 38% (152 of 398 reference citations) with a 95% confidence interval of 30.1% to 47.0%. The median quotation error rate per journal was 38% (range, 28% to 46%). Conclusions: Citation and quotation errors are common in the pediatric orthopaedic literature. Reference accuracy continues to be a substantial problem in the biomedical literature despite recent technological advances such as online databases, easily accessible search engines, and widely available bibliographic software.


Related Articles

  • How accurate are quotations and references in medical journal? de Lacey, Gerald; Record, Carol; Wade, Jenny // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);9/28/1985, Vol. 291 Issue 6499, p884 

    Assesses the accuracy of quotations and references in medical journals in Great Britain. Occurrence of errors in citation of references; Prevention of immediate identification of the source of the reference; Effect of inaccurate quotations and citations on the original author and the reader.

  • Omega yes, alpha no. von Lichtenberg, Franz // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;11/9/94, Vol. 272 Issue 18, p1412 

    Criticizes the omission of relevant references in some medical publications. Need for comprehensive literature search; Inadequacy of computers in identifying vintage medical literature.

  • Source Notes.  // Mark Morris;1994, p289 

    References for the quotations that appeared in the book "Mark Morris," by Joan Acocella are presented.

  • Correction.  // Journal of Mormon History;Fall2012, Vol. 38 Issue 4, preceding p1 

    The article provides corrections for the article "Eleven Witnesses Behold the Plates," by Gale Yancey Anderson from the Spring 2012 issue.

  • Notes for Contributors 2010.  // Studies in Hispanic Cinemas;Jan2011, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p79 

    The article notes the rules on the format and presentation of the articles published within the journal. It offers several guidance which includes the article's submission, presentation, quotations, references, illustrations and transliteration. It also states that the web references must have...

  • Textual Prostheses. Dworkin, Craig // Comparative Literature;Winter2005, Vol. 57 Issue 1, p1 

    Discusses the use of literary paratexts in contemporary writing. Description of the use of literary paratexts in the book "Topographie anecdotée du hasard"; Reasons of printers for employing a series of letters in alphabetical sequence to link the notes to the text; Difference between bottom...

  • Increased Responsibility and Transparency in an Era of Increased Visibility.  // PLoS Medicine;Oct2010, Vol. 7 Issue 10, p1 

    The authors reflect on the influence and role of medical journals in disseminating health information. The authors say that together with the influence of medical journals is a set of various responsibilities they are anticipated to accomplish. The authors highlight a study which analyzed...

  • Author self-citation in the diabetes literature. Gami, Apoor S.; Montori, Victor M.; Wilczynski, Nancy L.; Haynes, R. Brian // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;6/22/2004, Vol. 170 Issue 13, p1925 

    Background: Author self-citation is the practice of citing one's previous publications in a new publication. Its extent is unknown. We studied author self-citation, choosing the major clinical field of diabetes mellitus to represent the general medical literature. Methods: We identified every...

  • A bibliometric overview of public health research in Europe. Clarke, Aileen; Gatineau, Mary; Grimaud, Olivier; Royer-Devaux, Sandrine; Wyn-Roberts, Nia; Le Bis, Isabelle; Lewison, Grant // European Journal of Public Health;Aug2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 17, p43 

    Background: Our aim, within the collaborative study SPHERE (Strengthening Public Health Research in Europe), was to produce a bibliometric overview of public health research literature for Europe. Methods: A search strategy ('filter') was designed to interrogate the Science Citation Index (SCI)...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics