Should physicians be gatekeepers of medical resources?

Weinstein, Milton C
August 2001
Journal of Medical Ethics;Aug2001, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p268
Academic Journal
Physicians have an ethical responsibility to their patients to offer the best available medical care. This responsibility conflicts with their role as gatekeepers of the limited health care resources available for all patients collectively. It is ethically untenable to expect doctors to face this trade-off during each patient encounter; the physician cannot be expected to compromise the wellbeing of the patient in the office in favour of anonymous patients elsewhere. Hence, as in other domains of public policy where individual and collective interests conflict, some form of collective solution is required. Collective solutions may take the form of placing explicit resource constraints on resources available to physicians, or clinical practice guidelines that recognise cost-effective care as acceptable. Such solutions will be politically and ethically sustainable only if patients as citizens of the larger population accept the need for rationing of limited resources in health care.


Related Articles

  • The ethics of Soviet medical practice: Behaviours and attitudes of physicians in Soviet Estonia. Barr, Donald A. // Journal of Medical Ethics;Feb96, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p33 

    Presents a study on the attitudes and practices of physicians in the former Soviet republic, Estonia regarding issues of medical ethics. Survey sample and setting; Information about treatment risks and alternatives; Recognition of patients' rights pertaining to treatment.

  • Disciplining doctors: the need for better methods. Forsythe, Malcolm // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);5/21/1988, Vol. 296 Issue 6634, p1421 

    Focuses on the need for improving the attitudes of doctors concerning discipline. Criticisms on the application of the procedures for professional care; Argument on the charges for the pursuit of a doctor's profession; Process to be followed in the prosecution.

  • When I'm old give me a real doctor. Miller, A. E. // Medical Economics;09/06/99, Vol. 76 Issue 17, p117 

    Highlights a family physician's wish of having an old-fashioned physician to take care of him. Images evoked by the word `retirement'; Medicine as a dying art; Opinion on `patient autonomy'; Attributes of a doctor that the author wishes to have for himself.

  • Untitled.  // Second Opinion;Jan93, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p90 

    Reports on a survey of physicians regarding health care reform. Percentage of respondents who favor implementing a federally financed national health insurance program; Percentage who favor reform through a combination of government and private programs; Percentage who resist reform.

  • Personal View. Slater, S.D. // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);10/25/1986, Vol. 293 Issue 6554, p1096 

    Comments on the type of medical care given by doctors to persons infected with salmonella. Treatment of the nurses to the patient; Pathophysiology of the infection; Need to ensure proper care to individuals suffering the infection.

  • Greed and the medical profession. Crawshaw, Ralph // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);1/9/93, Vol. 306 Issue 6870, p151 

    Comments on the greed of medical professionals in the United States. Placement of profit before the well being of patients; problems encountered form greed of doctors; Approximation of the income of doctors.

  • Medical decisions concerning the end of life: A discussion... Asai, Atsushi; Fukuhara, Shunichi // Journal of Medical Ethics;Oct97, Vol. 23 Issue 5, p323 

    Explores possible barriers to develop an in-depth understanding of Japanese physicians' attitudes towards life-sustaining treatment and advance directives. Possible explanation for the inconsistent attitudes among physicians towards life-sustaining treatment; Physicians attitudes towards...

  • Aspects of ethics (1). Ryan, Michael // British Medical Journal;9/8/1979, Vol. 2 Issue 6190, p585 

    Focuses on the medical ethics practiced in the Soviet Union. Difference between the doctors practicing in the Western and Eastern democracies; Assessment on the extent of state responsibility for health services; Influence of the Communist Party on the imposition of health service.

  • Humanization of Care from the Perspective of the Family Health Strategy Teams in a City in the Interior of São Paulo, Brazil. Marin, Maria José Sanches; Storniolo, Luana Vergian; Moravcik, Maria Yvette // Revista Latino-Americana de Enfermagem (RLAE);Jul/Aug2010, Vol. 18 Issue 4, p763 

    This study analyzes the understanding of professionals composing teams of the Family Health Strategy concerning humanization of care. This qualitative survey was carried out in a city in the interior of São Paulo through interviews with 20 professionals. The data analysis method used was...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics