Teaching Holism in Environmental Ethics

Nelson, Michael P.
March 2010
Environmental Ethics;Spring2010, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p33
Students who enroll in my environmental ethics courses often come with a background in ecology and natural resources. Moreover, they often point to this background when they express their frustration with, or outright rejection of, individualistic or atomistic moral theories that simply strive to include individual living things within the purview of a moral community. They ultimately evoke the concept of holism as the source of their frustration. Addressing this concern requires trying to make sense of both the concept of holism generally and the supposed connection students sense between their training as young scientists and the attempt to ground a worthy environmental ethic. Many theories within the field of environmental ethics either evoke or rest upon the concept of holism. To date, however, the concept of holism has not been unpacked in any detail. To begin such an unpacking teachers need (1) to demonstrate how and when holism appears within the field of environmental ethics, (2) to explain the core idea underpinning holism and compare it to reductionism, and (3) to provide a general classification of how holism is employed in both a metaphysical and ethical sense within environmental ethics.


Related Articles

  • Conceptualizing Stewardship in Agriculture within the Christian Tradition. Paterson, John L. // Environmental Ethics;Spring2003, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p43 

    The concept of stewardship as re source development and conservation, a shallow environmental ethic, arises out of a domination framework. Stewardship as earthkeeping arises out of a keeping framework and falls somewhere between an intermediate and deep environmental ethic. A notion of...

  • An Evaluation of Engaging Volunteers to Restore Bottomland Forest (North Central Texas). Forbes, William; Forbes, Margaret; Stevens, Kevin; Dickson, Kenneth L.; Solis, Sonny // Ecological Restoration;Mar2008, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p18 

    The article reports on a study which evaluates an alternative to standard contracting of restoration services in North Central Texas. The researchers have conducted a survey on two groups of volunteers in restoration and monitoring environmental resources regarding the group's perceptions of the...

  • Bridging the Macro and the Micro by Considering the Meso: Reflections on the Fractal Nature of Resilience. Bergström, Johan; Dekker, Sidney W. A. // Ecology & Society;2014, Vol. 19 Issue 4, p1 

    We pursued the following three interconnected points: (1) there are unexplored opportunities for resilience scholars from different disciplines to cross-inspire and inform, (2) a systems perspective may enhance understanding of human resilience in health and social settings, and (3) resilience...

  • Holism, Reductionism and Communitarian Visions. Williams, Simon // Social Alternatives;Jan98, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p17 

    The article presents the author's views on the role played by social theories, including holism, reductionism, ecocommunalism, social ecology and bioregionalism in environmental studies. Holism is useful for pointing out how systems can be seen on many levels, as ecosystems, species, groups,...

  • THE ANT, THE GRASSHOPPER OR SCHRÖDINGER'S CAT:: AN EXPLORATION OF CONCEPTS OF SUSTAINABILITY. Grinde, John; Khare, Anshuman // Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy & Management;Jun2008, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p115 

    Living within the limits imposed by a finite earth may be the predominant challenge of the 21st century; however there is no agreement on what this means economically or politically. Continually increasing population and per capita consumption within a finite environment is a biologic...

  • "We still want no straddlers" Turnage, William A. // Wilderness (07366477);Summer1985, Vol. 48 Issue 169, p34 

    No abstract available.

  • Liberty of Ecological Conscience. Lercher, Aaron // Environmental Ethics;Fall2006, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p315 

    Our concern for nonhuman nature can be justified in terms of a human right to liberty of ecological conscience. This right is analogous to the right to religious liberty, and is equally worthy of recognition as that fundamental liberty. The liberty of ecological conscience, like religious...

  • Staying True to Trees: A Specific Look at Anthropocentrism and Non-Anthropocentrism. Diehm, Christian // Environmental Philosophy;2008, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p3 

    This essay examines how becoming familiar with trees in their specificity might impact how we position ourselves in the ongoing debate among environmental philosophers regarding anthropocentric and non-anthropocentric approaches to environmental ethics. It begins with an analysis of what the...

  • The Excluded Philosophy of Evo-Devo? Revisiting C.H. Waddington's Failed Attempt to Embed Alfred North Whitehead's "Organicism" in Evolutionary Biology. Peterson, Erik L. // History & Philosophy of the Life Sciences;2011, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p301 

    Though a prominent British developmental biologist in his day, a close friend of Theodosius Dobzhansky, and a frequent correspondent with Ernst Mayr, C.H. Waddington did not enter the ranks of "architect" of the Modern Synthesis. By the end of his career, in fact, he recognized that other...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics