The Cinquefoil Controversy: Restoring Relics between Managers and Purists

Deliège, Glenn
March 2010
Environmental Ethics;Spring2010, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p17
According to Michael Soulé, the debate over whether we should or should not actively manage our nature preserves has driven a deep wedge between "wilderness purists," who advocate a hands-off approach to nature, and "nature managers," who want to give nature a helping hand whenever the "fullness of the biota" is under threat. Although both camps share the same formal goal, i.e., preserving "authentic nature," managers and purists have differing views about what the "authenticity of nature" stands for. By introducing a third way of conceptualizing the authenticity of nature that holds the middle-ground between the authenticity of the purists and the managers-namely, natural areas as authentic relics-a bridge can be found between the two positions. As in the case of heath restorations in Flanders, Belgium, the theory of relics can provide an alternative way in which the concept of authenticity is used when evaluating preservation or restoration projects. Moreover, the conception of natural areas as relics is already tacitly at work within certain preservation and/or restoration practices. A comparison of the theory of relics with Robert Elliot's anti-restoration thesis as put forward in Faking Nature shows that the theory of relics can, to a large degree, save Elliot's anti-restorationist's stance in a world that is waking up to the reality of the "end of nature," while at the same time softening the rigid rejection of all restorative practices implied in the anti-restoration thesis.


Related Articles

  • "We still want no straddlers" Turnage, William A. // Wilderness (07366477);Summer1985, Vol. 48 Issue 169, p34 

    No abstract available.

  • REPORT OF THE SYMPOSIUM AND ROUND-TABLE DISCUSSION "TRAINING NEEDS AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR PROTECTED AREAS MANAGEMENT". Nathai-Gyan, Nadra; Sorenson, Lisa // Journal of Caribbean Ornithology;2008, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p102 

    The article offers information on the symposium and round-table discussion "Training Needs and Opportunities for Protected Areas Management." It aims to equip Carribean professionals with the suitable tools needed for the implementation of programmes on protected areas and natural resources....

  • Drug giant deals for rainforest Cullen, Nathan // Alternatives Journal;Fall1997, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p13 

    No abstract available.

  • The ethics-economics-policy paradigm: the foundation for an integrated land trust conservation decision-support model Nicholas, N. S.; Joslin, J. D. // Urban Ecosystems;Jul1999, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p83 

    This paper sets forth a transdisciplinary approach, based upon current trans-Atlantic research carried out in Britain and the U.S., on the complex and interdisciplinary relationship of the ethics-economics-policy paradigm. To provide the proper associations within the land trust framework, the...

  • Conceptualizing Stewardship in Agriculture within the Christian Tradition. Paterson, John L. // Environmental Ethics;Spring2003, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p43 

    The concept of stewardship as re source development and conservation, a shallow environmental ethic, arises out of a domination framework. Stewardship as earthkeeping arises out of a keeping framework and falls somewhere between an intermediate and deep environmental ethic. A notion of...

  • Geoethics. Senatskaya, G. S.; Němec, V. // Value Inquiry Book Series;2014, Vol. 276, p219 

    The article presents a definition of the term "geoethics." It refers to a set of moral standards used during exploration of the geosphere. Topics discussed include the acceptance of geoethics by the scientific community, the danger posed by exhausting Earth's resources and the use of geoethics...

  • Whose environment is this, anyway? Rosborough, Brian A. // Earthwatch: The Journal of Earthwatch Institute;Jul/Aug95, Vol. 14 Issue 4, p3 

    Focuses on the importance of ethics and not the numeric value in the preservation of the environment and its resources. Environment as a life-support system for the common nourishment of living things; Free goods and services as a diminishing resource; Inhabitants' battles about survival and...

  • Unbounded Wilderness. Lopez, Barry // Aperture;Late Summer90, Issue 120, p2 

    The article discusses issues on responsible land management for unbounded wilderness allocation in the North America. It was emphasized that the country has faced the crisis of wild landscapes that threaten wilderness preservation such as creeks, prairies and aquifers due to rampant real estate...

  • Pure numbers, invariants and symmetry in the evolution of life histories Charnov, E. L. // Evolutionary Ecology;Jul1991, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p339 

    No abstract available.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics