Absolute risk representation in cardiovascular disease prevention: comprehension and preferences of health care consumers and general practitioners involved in a focus group study

Hill, Sophie; Spink, Janet; Cadilhac, Dominique; Edwards, Adrian; Kaufman, Caroline; Rogers, Sophie; Ryan, Rebecca; Tonkin, Andrew
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p108
Academic Journal
Background: Communicating risk is part of primary prevention of coronary heart disease and stroke, collectively referred to as cardiovascular disease (CVD). In Australia, health organisations have promoted an absolute risk approach, thereby raising the question of suitable standardised formats for risk communication. Methods: Sixteen formats of risk representation were prepared including statements, icons, graphical formats, alone or in combination, and with variable use of colours. All presented the same risk, i.e., the absolute risk for a 55 year old woman, 16% risk of CVD in five years. Preferences for a five or ten-year timeframe were explored. Australian GPs and consumers were recruited for participation in focus groups, with the data analysed thematically and preferred formats tallied. Results: Three focus groups with health consumers and three with GPs were held, involving 19 consumers and 18 GPs. Consumers and GPs had similar views on which formats were more easily comprehended and which conveyed 16% risk as a high risk. A simple summation of preferences resulted in three graphical formats (thermometers, vertical bar chart) and one statement format as the top choices. The use of colour to distinguish risk (red, yellow, green) and comparative information (age, sex, smoking status) were important ingredients. Consumers found formats which combined information helpful, such as colour, effect of changing behaviour on risk, or comparison with a healthy older person. GPs preferred formats that helped them relate the information about risk of CVD to their patients, and could be used to motivate patients to change behaviour. Several formats were reported as confusing, such as a percentage risk with no contextual information, line graphs, and icons, particularly those with larger numbers. Whilst consumers and GPs shared preferences, the use of one format for all situations was not recommended. Overall, people across groups felt that risk expressed over five years was preferable to a ten-year risk, the latter being too remote. Conclusions: Consumers and GPs shared preferences for risk representation formats. Both groups liked the option to combine formats and tailor the risk information to reflect a specific individual's risk, to maximise understanding and provide a good basis for discussion.


Related Articles

  • Communicating cardiovascular risk. Manis, Kosta // Pulse;Sep2014, p106 

    The article offers a three-stage guide for general practitioners (GPs) to use to communicate the risk of cardiovascular disease to patients. It mentions the need to assess the numeracy skills and reading level of the patient at the start of the consultation. It notes that the scepticism of the...

  • Study backs folic acid for all.  // Pulse;11/30/2006, Vol. 66 Issue 45, p23 

    The article discusses that general practitioners should prescribe folic acid supplements for patients to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disorder. The Wolfson Institute of Preventive Medicine analyzed the link between the concentration of serum homocysteine and ischemic heart disease and...

  • Is the Physician’s Behavior in Dyslipidemia Diagnosis in Accordance with Guidelines? Cross-Sectional Escarval Study. Palazón-Bru, Antonio; Gil-Guillén, Vicente F.; Orozco-Beltrán, Domingo; Pallarés-Carratalá, Vicente; Valls-Roca, Francisco; Sanchís-Domenech, Carlos; Martín-Moreno, José M.; Redón, Josep; Navarro-Pérez, Jorge; Fernández-Giménez, Antonio; Pérez-Navarro, Ana M.; Trillo, José L.; Usó, Ruth; Ruiz, Elías // PLoS ONE;Mar2014, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p1 

    Background: Clinical inertia has been defined as mistakes by the physician in starting or intensifying treatment when indicated. Inertia, therefore, can affect other stages in the healthcare process, like diagnosis. The diagnosis of dyslipidemia requires ≥2 high lipid values, but...

  • Framingham has 'no clinical utility'. Swan, David // Pulse;7/4/2012, Vol. 72 Issue 24, p12 

    The article offers information on the research which shows the need for general practitioners (GPs) to switch to QRISK2 algorithm for use in cardiovascular risk score than Framingham risk score because of the absence of clinical utility.

  • Prize-winning paper.  // GP: General Practitioner;6/16/2003, p12 

    This article focuses on a photograph of general practitioner Pippa Oakeshott and her colleagues Francesco Cappuccio, Pasquale Strazzullo and Sally Kerry, who have won £1,000 for highlighting the problems of using cardiovascular risk estimates across different ethnic populations.

  • Lifestyle interventions cut risk of CVD. Pownall, Mark // GP: General Practitioner;9/8/2006, p8 

    The article focuses on a study by EuroAction on lifestyle intervention to reduce risk factors of cardiovascular disease. 10,792 high risk cardiovascular patients from across Europe were studied and it was found out that lifestyle intervention by a trained nurse, alongwith a general practitioner,...

  • AHA Cardiovascular Disease Prevention Guidelines. Morantz, Carrie; Torrey, Brian // American Family Physician;9/15/2002, Vol. 66 Issue 6, p1110 

    Deals with the updated recommendations of the American Heart Association for cardiovascular disease prevention. Risk factor screening; Details of global risk estimation.

  • Levels of cardiovascular disease risk factors in Singapore following a national intervention programme. Cutter, Jeffery; Tan, Bee Yian; Suok Kai Chew // Bulletin of the World Health Organization;2001, Vol. 79 Issue 10, p908 

    Objective To evaluate the impact of the National Healthy Lifestyle Programme, a noncommunicable disease intervention programme for major cardiovascular disease risk factors in Singapore, implemented in 1992. Methods The evaluation was carried out in 1998 by the Singapore National Health Survey...

  • Cardiovascular: Heart tool boosts GP care. Robinson, Stephen // GP: General Practitioner;3/31/2014, p50 

    GPs should use a new computer tool to estimate patients' lifetime risk of cardiovascular disease and intervene much earlier to reduce risk, experts have said.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics