Intraobserver and Interobserver Agreement in the Measurement of Displaced Humeral Medial Epicondyle Fractures in Children

Pappas, Nick; Lawrence, John T.; Donegan, Derek; Ganley, Ted; Flynn, John M.
February 2010
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Feb2010, Vol. 92-A Issue 2, p322
Academic Journal
Background: Fractures of the humeral medial epicondyle occur frequently in children. The decision to pursue operative or nonoperative treatment often hinges on the amount of perceived fracture displacement. This study was performed to assess both intraobserver and interobserver agreement in the measurements of displacement of these fractures on radiographs by orthopaedic surgeons with various levels of training. Methods: We performed a retrospective review of the radiographs of thirty-eight patients with a fracture of the medial epicondyle of the humerus. Digital anteroposterior, lateral, and oblique radiographs of each involved elbow made at presentation were presented to five separate reviewers with different levels of orthopaedic training, including two junior residents (junior residents 1 and 2), one fellow, one junior attending surgeon, and one senior attending surgeon. Each reviewer recorded the amount of perceived displacement in millimeters. A difference of >2 mm between measurements represented clinical disagreement between reviewers. lntraobserver and interobserver agreement was assessed by calculating both the intraclass correlation coefficient and the percentage of clinical disagreement between ratings. Results: The intraclass correlation coefficients for intraobserver agreement regarding the measurements on the anteroposterior radiographs were 0.24 (95% confidence interval, 0.00 to 0.68) for junior resident 1, 0.82 (95% confidence interval, 0.41 to 0.95) forjunior resident 2, 0.83 (95% confidence interval, 0.46 to 0.96) for the senior attending surgeon, 0.92 (95% confidence interval, 0.69 to 0.98) for the junior attending surgeon, and 0.98(95% confidence interval, 0.92 to 1.00) for the fellow. The combined intraclass correlation coefficient for intraobserver agreement was 0.76. The reviewers as a group disagreed with their own measurements an average of 26% of the time. The intraclass correlation coefficient for interobserver reliability with regard to the measurements on the anteroposterior radiographs for the group was 0.80 (95% confidence interval, 0.64 to 0.89), and the reviewers disagreed with each other an average of 54% of the time. The intraclass correlation coefficient for interobserver agreement was 0.28 (95% confidence interval, 0.03 to 0.76) for the measurements on the lateral radiographs and 0.62 (95% confidence interval, 0.34 to 0.89) for the measurements on the oblique radiographs, with reviewers disagreeing an average of 87% of the time with regard to the measurements on the lateral radiographs and 64% of the time with regard to the measurements on the oblique radiographs. Conclusions: lntraobserver agreement with regard to measurement of displacement of medial epicondyle fractures of the humerus varied among the reviewers but was low overall. Interobserver agreement was best for the measurements on the anteroposterior radiographs, but this was also low overall. These findings cast doubt on whether the amount of perceived displacement should be used as a criterion for choosing operative or nonoperative management of fractures of the humeral medial epicondyle. Agreement may be improved to acceptable levels by adopting a standard set of measurement guidelines, which include use of the anteroposterior radiograph when possible and consistently measuring at the point of maximal displacement.


Related Articles

  • Three-and Four-Part Proximal Humerus Fractures. Min, William; Davidovitch, Roy I.; Tejwani, Nirmal C. // Bulletin of the NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases;2012, Vol. 70 Issue 1, p25 

    The recent increase in life expectancy is expected to bring about a concurrent rise in the number of proximal humerus fractures. Those presenting with significant displacement, osteoporosis, and comminution present distinct clinical challenges, and the optimal treatment of these injuries remains...

  • Trends in epidemiology and patho-anatomical pattern of proximal humeral fractures. Bahrs, Christian; Tanja, Stojicevic; Gunnar, Blumenstock; Stig, Brorson; Badke, Andreas; Ulrich, Stöckle; Bernd, Rolauffs; Thomas, Freude // International Orthopaedics;Aug2014, Vol. 38 Issue 8, p1697 

    Purpose: Proximal humeral fractures are common and frequently associated with osteoporosis. Little is known about the association between the patho-anatomical fracture pattern of proximal humeral fractures and patient characteristics. The purpose of this six year longitudinal registry analysis...

  • Anterior Shoulder Dislocation and Ipsilateral Humeral Shaft Fracture. Hossein Karimi-Nasab, Mohammad; Shayesteh-Azar, Masoud; Sajjadi¿saravi, Majid; Mehdi Daneshpoor, Seyed Mohamad // Iranian Journal of Medical Sciences;Sep2012, Vol. 37 Issue 3, p202 

    Simultaneous dislocation of shoulder and humeral shaft fracture is a rare injury, and there is no clear protocol for its treatment. Herein we present a case of a 15-year-old boy, who suffered from a job-related accident and sustained fracture of humeral shaft associated with ipsilateral anterior...

  • Panel discusses use of reverse total shoulder arthroplasty for proximal humeral fractures. Levine, William N. // Orthopedics Today;Apr2014, Vol. 34 Issue 4, p34 

    The article discusses the highlights of a panel discussion on the use of reverse total shoulder arthroplasty for proximal humeral fractures. The panelists include physicians Mark A. Frankle, Christian Gerber, and Guido Marra. They discuss indications for performing a humeral head replacement...

  • Treatment of Rockwood type III acromioclavicular joint dislocation using autogenous semitendinosus tendon graft and endobutton technique. Gang Ye; Chao-An Peng; Hua-Bin Sun; Jing Xiao; Kang Zhu // Therapeutics & Clinical Risk Management;Jan2016, Vol. 12, p47 

    Background: The aim of this study was to evaluate the therapeutic effect of autogenous semitendinosus graft and endobutton technique, and compare with hook plate in treatment of Rockwood type III acromioclavicular (AC) joint dislocation. Methods: From April 2012 to April 2013, we treated 46...

  • Physeal injuries of the proximal humerus: long-term results in seventy two patients. Binder, Harald; Schurz, Mark; Aldrian, Silke; Fialka, Christian; Vécsei, Vilmos // International Orthopaedics;Oct2011, Vol. 35 Issue 10, p1497 

    Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate our treatment methods of proximal humeral physeal injuries retrospectively and elucidate the relationship between the trauma mechanism, the radiographic injury pattern, the consequent therapy and the functional outcome, and to further deduct and...

  • Simultaneous posterior fracture dislocation of the shoulder following epileptic convulsion. Jansen, Hendrik; Frey, Sönke P.; Doht, Stefanie; Meffert, Rainer H. // Journal of Surgical Case Reports;Nov2012, Vol. 2012 Issue 11, p1 

    Shoulder dislocations with fractures are a possible complication of an epileptic seizure and are often missed on the first sight. The incidence of sustaining an avascular humeral head necrosis (AVN) is high, and primary prosthetic replacement is the choice of treatment. In this paper, we...

  • Posterior dislocation of shoulder with humeral shaft fracture: a rare case with review of literature. Chirag, T.; Shyam, Ashok; Patil, Atul; Sancheti, Parag // European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology;Nov2012 Supplement, Vol. 22, p71 

    The posterior dislocation of shoulder with ipsilateral humerus shaft fracture is an extremely rare occurrence, with only six cases reported in literature. High index of suspicion is required for early diagnosis and good results. Another case is described here with up-to-date review of literature.

  • Inverse Schulterendoprothetik bei Frakturfolgezuständen. Gwinner, C.; Greiner, S.; Gerhardt, C.; Scheibel, M. // Der Orthopäde;Jul2013, Vol. 42 Issue 7, p531 

    Posttraumatic fracture sequelae of the proximal humerus represent an extremely heterogeneous pathology. In severe cases they are often associated with marked soft tissue scarring, osseous defects and insufficiency of the rotator cuff, resulting in a static instability of the humeral head. The...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics