TITLE

Space, Time and the Constitution of Subjectivity: Comparing Elias and Foucault

AUTHOR(S)
Dolan, Paddy
PUB. DATE
February 2010
SOURCE
Foucault Studies;Feb2010, Issue 8, p8
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
The work of Foucault and Elias has been compared before in the social sciences and humanities, but here I argue that the main distinction between their approaches to the construction of subjectivity is the relative importance of space and time in their accounts. This is not just a matter of the "history of ideas," as providing for the temporal dimension more fully in theories of subjectivity and the habitus allows for a greater understanding of how ways of being, acting and feeling in different spaces are related but largely unintended. Here I argue that discursive practices, governmental operations and technologies of the self (explanatory claims of both Foucault and the Foucauldian tradition) take shape as processes within the continuities of the figurational flow connecting people across space and time. Continuity should not be understood as stability or sameness over time, but as the contingent relations between successive social formations. As Elias argues, there is a structure or order to long-term social change, albeit unplanned, and this ultimately provides the broader social explanation for the historicity of the subject. Though discursive practices happen in particular spaces, we must recognise these spaces, and the practices therein, as socially constructed over time in response to largely unplanned moral and cultural developments.
ACCESSION #
48792363

 

Related Articles

  • The Birth of the Subject: Michel Foucault and Norbert Elias. CHIŢA, Dan Alexandru // Hermeneia: Journal of Hermeneutics, Art Theory & Criticism;Jun2012, Vol. 2012 Issue 12, p163 

    This paper was written with the sole intention of showing how much Norbert Elias's masterwork, The Civilizing Process, resembles epistemologically not only Michel Foucault's methodology, but also that both hold the same perspective in regard to the issues of how the modern subject had been...

  • The Birth of the Subject: Michel Foucault and Norbert Elias. CHIȚA, Dan Alexandru // Hermeneia: Journal of Hermeneutics, Art Theory & Criticism;2012, Issue 12, p163 

    This paper was written with the sole intention of showing how much Norbert Elias's masterwork, The Civilizing Process, resembles epistemologically not only Michel Foucault's methodology, but also that both hold the same perspective in regard to the issues of how the modern subject had been...

  • Culturalism of Exclusion in an Established-Outsider-Figuration. Rommel, Inken // Historical Social Research;2016, Vol. 41 Issue 3, p175 

    »Kulturalisierung von Exklusion in einer Etablierten-Auβenseiter-Figuration «. This paper paradigmatically deals with the problem of understanding and explanation of established-outsider-figurations which have been mostly grasped in the dominant research, public understanding as well as...

  • The Planned and the Unplanned: A Roundtable Discussion on the Legacies of Michel Foucault and Norbert Elias. Binkley, Sam; Dolan, Paddy; Ernst, Stefanie; Wouters, Cas // Foucault Studies;Feb2010, Issue 8, p53 

    Information about several topics discussed at a conference at the University of Hamburg, Germany on the works of sociologists Michel Foucault and Norbert Elias is presented. Topics include the conflicts and convergences of Eliasian and Foucauldian theories. The conference featured several...

  • A (computational) social science perspective on societal transitions. Squazzoni, Flaminio // Computational & Mathematical Organization Theory;Dec2008, Vol. 14 Issue 4, p266 

    This paper aims to illustrate how social sciences, sociology in particular, have theorized on societal transitions. The first section introduces some preliminary definitions. The assumption is that a societal transition is more than a social, economic or technological change. It is a large-scale...

  • CONSIDERAÇÕES SOBRE A CONSTITUIÇÃO DO SUJEITO DO CUIDADO DE SI NO PENSAMENTO DE MICHEL FOUCAULT. Da Fonseca, João Paulo Ayub // Veritas;jan-abr2012, Vol. 57 Issue 1, p143 

    The present text aims to discuss how Foucault works out the problem of the constitution of the subject of the care of the self -- a theme which has filled his last books, courses, interviews and conferences. The problematizing of this "subject", and of the "techniques of the self" which...

  • Der Kopf des Königs — Recht, Disziplin und Regierung bei Foucault. Lemke, Thomas // Berliner Journal für Soziologie;1999, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p415 

    In the social sciences and philosophy Foucault is still regarded as a thinker who in his last works abandoned the genealogy of power in favor of a theory of the subject. On the basis of a comprehensive reconstruction of the Foucaultian problematics of power this article sets out to present a...

  • FOUCAULT O LA ÉTICA Y LA PRÁCTICA DE LA LIBERTAD. DINAMITAR ESPEJISMOS Y PROPICIAR INSUMISIONES. Ibáñez Gracia, Tomás // Athenea Digital (Revista de Pensamiento e Investigación Social);jul2014, Vol. 14 Issue 2, p3 

    This year marks the thirtieth anniversary of Michel Foucault's death and his work remains in force with singular power in the whole of social thought. His concepts and intuitions has not only aged, but seem singularly enhanced within the activism and the modulations of libertarian and anarchist...

  • LA SOCIOLOGÍA FIGURACIONAL DE NORBERT ELÍAS Y EL ESTRUCTURALISMO GENÉTICO DE PIERRE BOURDIEU: ENCUENTROS Y DESENCUENTROS. Capdevielle, Julieta // Aposta;Jan-Mar2012, Issue 52, p1 

    The article discusses the contributions of the sociological theory of Norbert Elias and Pierre Bourdieu into the field of social sciences. Following Corcuff, we can place the works of these two authors in constructivist theories. Theories which produce a displacement of the object of sociology,...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics