Evaluation of the reliability of maize reference assays for GMO quantification

Papazova, Nina; Zhang, David; Gruden, Kristina; Vojvoda, Jana; Yang, Litao; Gašparič, Meti Buh; Blejec, Andrej; Fouilloux, Stephane; De Loose, Marc; Taverniers, Isabel
March 2010
Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Mar2010, Vol. 396 Issue 6, p2189
Academic Journal
A reliable PCR reference assay for relative genetically modified organism (GMO) quantification must be specific for the target taxon and amplify uniformly along the commercialised varieties within the considered taxon. Different reference assays for maize ( Zea mays L.) are used in official methods for GMO quantification. In this study, we evaluated the reliability of eight existing maize reference assays, four of which are used in combination with an event-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay validated and published by the Community Reference Laboratory (CRL). We analysed the nucleotide sequence variation in the target genomic regions in a broad range of transgenic and conventional varieties and lines: MON 810 varieties cultivated in Spain and conventional varieties from various geographical origins and breeding history. In addition, the reliability of the assays was evaluated based on their PCR amplification performance. A single base pair substitution, corresponding to a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) reported in an earlier study, was observed in the forward primer of one of the studied alcohol dehydrogenase 1 ( Adh1) (70) assays in a large number of varieties. The SNP presence is consistent with a poor PCR performance observed for this assay along the tested varieties. The obtained data show that the Adh1 (70) assay used in the official CRL NK603 assay is unreliable. Based on our results from both the nucleotide stability study and the PCR performance test, we can conclude that the Adh1 (136) reference assay (T25 and Bt11 assays) as well as the tested high mobility group protein gene assay, which also form parts of CRL methods for quantification, are highly reliable. Despite the observed uniformity in the nucleotide sequence of the invertase gene assay, the PCR performance test reveals that this target sequence might occur in more than one copy. Finally, although currently not forming a part of official quantification methods, zein and SSIIb assays are found to be highly reliable in terms of nucleotide stability and PCR performance and are proposed as good alternative targets for a reference assay for maize. [Figure not available: see fulltext.]


Related Articles

  • Development of qualitative PCR method targeting marker genes in transgenic plants. YUE Yun-Feng; WU Gang; WU Yu-hua; LU Chang-ming // Chinese Journal of Oil Crop Sciences;6/28/2011, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p280 

    To establish an effective screening method targeting marker genes for detecting genetically modified plants, we systematically analyzed the current application frequency of marker genes in commercial transgenic plants, and found that seven genes, including NPTII, PAT, CP4-EPSPS, bar, HPTII, GUS...

  • Expression and production of bioactive human interleukin-18 in transgenic tobacco plants. Bin Zhang; Ying-Hua Yang; Yong-Ming Lin; Qing Rao; Guo-Guang Zheng; Ke-Fu Wu // Biotechnology Letters;Oct2003, Vol. 25 Issue 19, p1629 

    The cDNA of human interleukin-18 (hIL-18) was successfully inserted into the genome of tobacco plant, Nicotiana tabacum cv. NC-89, using Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation. Insertion and translation of hIL-18 in transformants were confirmed by PCR, ELISA, and Western blot,...

  • Towards future reference systems for GM analysis. Trapmann, Stefanie; Corbisier, Philippe; Schimmel, Heinz; Emons, Hendrik // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Mar2010, Vol. 396 Issue 6, p1969 

    Despite the fact that the measurement unit for the quantification of GMOs in food and feed products has not yet been unambiguously agreed upon in Europe, international trade requires reliable GMO analysis measuring comparably the GMO content of products. The two reference systems, based either...

  • The use of 35S and T nos expression elements in the measurement of genetically engineered plant materials. Holden, Marcia J.; Levine, Marci; Scholdberg, Tandace; Haynes, Ross J.; Jenkins, G. Ronald // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Mar2010, Vol. 396 Issue 6, p2175 

    An online survey was conducted by the International Life Sciences Institute, Food Biotechnology Committee, on the use of qualitative and quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assays for cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter and Agrobacterium tumefaciens T nos DNA sequence elements for the...

  • Detecting authorized and unauthorized genetically modified organisms containing vip3A by real-time PCR and next-generation sequencing. Liang, Chanjuan; Dijk, Jeroen; Scholtens, Ingrid; Staats, Martijn; Prins, Theo; Voorhuijzen, Marleen; Silva, Andrea; Arisi, Ana; Dunnen, Johan; Kok, Esther // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Apr2014, Vol. 406 Issue 11, p2603 

    The growing number of biotech crops with novel genetic elements increasingly complicates the detection of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) in food and feed samples using conventional screening methods. Unauthorized GMOs (UGMOs) in food and feed are currently identified through combining GMO...

  • Detection of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) using isothermal amplification of target DNA sequences. Lee, David; La Mura, Maurizio; Allnutt, Theo R.; Powell, Wayne // BMC Biotechnology;2009, Vol. 9, Special section p1 

    Background: The most common method of GMO detection is based upon the amplification of GMO-specific DNA amplicons using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Here we have applied the loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) method to amplify GMO-related DNA sequences, 'internal'...

  • Development of a CTAB buffer-based automated gDNA extraction method for the surveillance of GMO in seed. Guertler, Patrick; Harwardt, Andrea; Eichelinger, Adelina; Muschler, Paul; Goerlich, Ottmar; Busch, Ulrich // European Food Research & Technology;Apr2013, Vol. 236 Issue 4, p599 

    Seed imported into the EU from countries growing genetically modified (gm) plants may contain traces of these gm crops. As a result of the zero tolerance policy of the EU, these products must be removed from the market. Along with the amount of biotech crops produced worldwide, the work load for...

  • Fast-tracking development of homozygous transgenic cereal lines using a simple and highly flexible real-time PCR assay. Mieog, Jos C.; Howitt, Crispin A.; Jean-Philippe Ral, Jean-Philippe // BMC Plant Biology;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: A crucial step in the evaluation of newly produced transgenic plants is the selection of homozygous plants. Here we describe an efficient and highly flexible real-time PCR-based method for the development of homozygous lines in plant models with complex (multiple) genomes and/or...

  • Evaluation of Adh1 alleles and transgenic soybean seeds using Scorpion PCR and HRM analysis. Madi, Zita; Brandes, Christian; Neumann, Georg; Quist, David; Ruppitsch, Werner; Hochegger, Rupert // European Food Research & Technology;Aug2013, Vol. 237 Issue 2, p125 

    The identification of both approved and non-approved genetically modified organisms (GMOs) is an integral part of GMO biosafety legislation in many countries. One aspect that may affect PCR-based detection of a GMO lies within the analysis of its genetic stability, as sequence alterations or DNA...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics