Comparison of nine different real-time PCR chemistries for qualitative and quantitative applications in GMO detection

Gašpariè, Meti Buh; Tengs, Torstein; La Paz, Jose Luis; Holst-Jensen, Arne; Pla, Maria; Esteve, Teresa; Žel, Jana; Gruden, Kristina
March 2010
Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Mar2010, Vol. 396 Issue 6, p2023
Academic Journal
Several techniques have been developed for detection and quantification of genetically modified organisms, but quantitative real-time PCR is by far the most popular approach. Among the most commonly used real-time PCR chemistries are TaqMan probes and SYBR green, but many other detection chemistries have also been developed. Because their performance has never been compared systematically, here we present an extensive evaluation of some promising chemistries: sequence-unspecific DNA labeling dyes (SYBR green), primer-based technologies (AmpliFluor, Plexor, Lux primers), and techniques involving double-labeled probes, comprising hybridization (molecular beacon) and hydrolysis (TaqMan, CPT, LNA, and MGB) probes, based on recently published experimental data. For each of the detection chemistries assays were included targeting selected loci. Real-time PCR chemistries were subsequently compared for their efficiency in PCR amplification and limits of detection and quantification. The overall applicability of the chemistries was evaluated, adding practicability and cost issues to the performance characteristics. None of the chemistries seemed to be significantly better than any other, but certain features favor LNA and MGB technology as good alternatives to TaqMan in quantification assays. SYBR green and molecular beacon assays can perform equally well but may need more optimization prior to use.


Related Articles

  • Chemiluminescent bead-based hybridization assay for the detection of genomic DNA from E. coli in purified plasmid samples. Martins, S. A. M.; Prazeres, D. M. F.; Fonseca, L. P.; Monteiro, G. A. // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Jul2008, Vol. 391 Issue 6, p2179 

    A bead-based hybridization assay was developed for detection of traces of E. coli genomic DNA (gDNA) present in purified plasmid DNA (pDNA) samples. Standards of gDNA and pDNA samples were sheared by sonication and adsorbed onto aminopropyl controlled pore glass (CPG) particles (130 μm). A...

  • A high-throughput method for GMO multi-detection using a microfluidic dynamic array. Brod, Fábio; Dijk, Jeroen; Voorhuijzen, Marleen; Dinon, Andréia; Guimarães, Luis; Scholtens, Ingrid; Arisi, Ana; Kok, Esther // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Feb2014, Vol. 406 Issue 5, p1397 

    The ever-increasing production of genetically modified crops generates a demand for high-throughput DNA-based methods for the enforcement of genetically modified organisms (GMO) labelling requirements. The application of standard real-time PCR will become increasingly costly with the growth of...

  • Validation of the performance of a GMO multiplex screening assay based on microarray detection. Serge Leimanis; Sandrine Hamels; Florence Nazé; Guillaume Mbongolo Mbella; Myriam Sneyers; Rupert Hochegger; Hermann Broll; Lillian Roth; Klára Dallmann; Adrienn Micsinai; José La Paz; Maria Pla; Claudia Brünen-Nieweler; Nina Papazova; Isabel Taverniers; Norbert Hess; Britta Kirschneit; Yves Bertheau; Colette Audeon; Valérie Laval // European Food Research & Technology;Oct2008, Vol. 227 Issue 6, p1621 

    Abstract  A new screening method for the detection and identification of GMO, based on the use of multiplex PCR followed by microarray, has been developed and is presented. The technology is based on the identification of quite ubiquitous GMO genetic target elements first...

  • A preamplification approach to GMO detection in processed foods. Del Gaudio, S.; Cirillo, A.; Di Bernardo, G.; Galderisi, U.; Cipollaro, M. // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Mar2010, Vol. 396 Issue 6, p2135 

    DNA is widely used as a target for GMO analysis because of its stability and high detectability. Real-time PCR is the method routinely used in most analytical laboratories due to its quantitative performance and great sensitivity. Accurate DNA detection and quantification is dependent on the...

  • Detection of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) using isothermal amplification of target DNA sequences. Lee, David; La Mura, Maurizio; Allnutt, Theo R.; Powell, Wayne // BMC Biotechnology;2009, Vol. 9, Special section p1 

    Background: The most common method of GMO detection is based upon the amplification of GMO-specific DNA amplicons using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Here we have applied the loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) method to amplify GMO-related DNA sequences, 'internal'...

  • Advances in molecular techniques for the detection and quantification of genetically modified organisms. Elenis, Dimitrios S.; Kalogianni, Despina P.; Glynou, Kyriaki; Ioannou, Penelope C.; Christopoulos, Theodore K. // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Oct2008, Vol. 392 Issue 3, p347 

    Progress in genetic engineering has led to the introduction of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) whose genomes have been altered by the integration of a novel sequence conferring a new trait. To allow consumers an informed choice, many countries require food products to be labeled if the GMO...

  • Methods for detection of GMOs in food and feed. Marmiroli, Nelson; Maestri, Elena; Gullì, Mariolina; Malcevschi, Alessio; Peano, Clelia; Bordoni, Roberta; De Bellis, Gianluca // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Oct2008, Vol. 392 Issue 3, p369 

    This paper reviews aspects relevant to detection and quantification of genetically modified (GM) material within the feed/food chain. The GM crop regulatory framework at the international level is evaluated with reference to traceability and labelling. Current analytical methods for the...

  • Testing the interaction between analytical modules: an example with Roundup Ready soybean line GTS 40-3-2. Bellocchi, Gianni; De Giacomo, Marzia; Foti, Nicoletta; Mazzara, Marco; Palmaccio, Eleonora; Savini, Cristian; Di Domenicantonio, Chiara; Onori, Roberta; Van den Eede, Guy // BMC Biotechnology;2010, Vol. 10, p55 

    Background: The modular approach to analysis of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) relies on the independence of the modules combined (i.e. DNA extraction and GM quantification). The validity of this assumption has to be proved on the basis of specific performance criteria. Results: An...

  • Comprehensive GMO Detection Using Real-Time PCR Array: Single-Laboratory Validation. Mano, Junichi; Harada, Mioko; Takabatake, Reona; Furui, Satoshi; Kitta, Kazumi; Nakamura, Kosuke; Akiyama, Hiroshi; Teshima, Reiko; Noritake, Hiromichi; Hatano, Shuko; Futo, Satoshi; Minegishi, Yasutaka; Iizuka, Tayoshi // Journal of AOAC International;Mar/Apr2012, Vol. 95 Issue 2, p508 

    The article discusses a study which developed a real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) array method to detect genetically modified (GM) organisms. The genomic DNA extracted from an agricultural product is analyzed using various PCR assays. The study also evaluated DNA quantity, DNA...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics