Evaluation of health promotion in schools: a realistic evaluation approach using mixed methods

Pommier, Jeanine; Guével, Marie-Renée; Jourdan, Didier
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Schools are key settings for health promotion (HP) but the development of suitable approaches for evaluating HP in schools is still a major topic of discussion. This article presents a research protocol of a program developed to evaluate HP. After reviewing HP evaluation issues, the various possible approaches are analyzed and the importance of a realistic evaluation framework and a mixed methods (MM) design are demonstrated. Methods/Design: The design is based on a systemic approach to evaluation, taking into account the mechanisms, context and outcomes, as defined in realistic evaluation, adjusted to our own French context using an MM approach. The characteristics of the design are illustrated through the evaluation of a nationwide HP program in French primary schools designed to enhance children's social, emotional and physical health by improving teachers' HP practices and promoting a healthy school environment. An embedded MM design is used in which a qualitative data set plays a supportive, secondary role in a study based primarily on a different quantitative data set. The way the qualitative and quantitative approaches are combined through the entire evaluation framework is detailed. Discussion: This study is a contribution towards the development of suitable approaches for evaluating HP programs in schools. The systemic approach of the evaluation carried out in this research is appropriate since it takes account of the limitations of traditional evaluation approaches and considers suggestions made by the HP research community.


Related Articles

  • Expanded School Mental Health: Challenges and Opportunities in an Emerging Field. Weist, Mark D.; Evans, Steven W. // Journal of Youth & Adolescence;Feb2005, Vol. 34 Issue 1, p3 

    Reviews the need for and development of expanded school mental health (ESMH) programs, which provide a continuum of mental health promotion and intervention through school-community partnerships. Since ESMH is a relatively new, but increasingly prominent field, countless issues are being...

  • Potentialities and deficiencies of qualitative research with families. Santos Luz, Geisa dos; Costa Santos, Silvana Sidney; da Silva, Mara Regina Santos; da Silva, Priscila Arruda // Investigacion & Educacion en Enfermeria;nov2012, Vol. 30 Issue 3, p346 

    Objective. To analyze the literature relating to qualitative research about the theme family that was published in Brazilian nursing journals in the period from 2006 to 2010. Methodology. Research involving investigation of bibliographic databases of articles presenting descriptors like the...

  • Madison Park School--South Australia. Steventon, Rob; Bortolozzo, Giulio // Primary Educator;1998, Vol. 4 Issue 5, p11 

    Features the development of Program Achieve, a personal development and mental health program for students and teachers at Madison Park School in South Australia. Areas of study of the R-12 program; Aim to address the learning, social and emotional needs of those who are achieving lower than...

  • One Province's Experience with Health Promoting Schools. Whitby, Caroline // Physical & Health Education Journal;2014, Vol. 79 Issue 4, p18 

    The article discusses findings from the province-wide project Children's Lifestyle and School- Performance Study II (CLASS II) which is part of a developing body of knowledge related to Health Promoting Schools (HPS) in Nova Scotia. It cites the project's examination of the links between health,...

  • A home-visiting intervention targeting determinants of infant mental health: the study protocol for the CAPEDP randomized controlled trial in France. Tubach, Florence; Greacen, Tim; Saïas, Thomas; Dugravier, Romain; Guedeney, Nicole; Ravaud, Philippe; Tereno, Susana; Tremblay, Richard; Falissard, Bruno; Guedeney, Antoine // BMC Public Health;2012, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p648 

    Background: Several studies suggest that the number of risk factors rather than their nature is key to mental health disorders in childhood. Method and design: The objective of this multicentre randomized controlled parallel trial (PROBE methodology) is to assess the impact in a multi-risk...

  • (REGIONAL GRANTS) CT Foundation Requires Concepts by Aug. 13.  // Community Health Funding Week;7/16/2010, p11 

    The article presents information on the grant application process of the Connecticut (CT) Health Foundation. It has been stated that there are two phases of the grant application procedure. The first phase of the application process requires submission of a concept paper that describes the...

  • (REGIONAL GRANTS) CT Foundation Requires Concepts by Aug. 13.  // Community Health Funding Week;7/16/2010, p29 

    The article informs about the application process for seeking grants from the Connecticut (CT) Health Foundation. It has been stated that there are two phases of the grant application procedure. The first phase of the application process requires submission of a concept paper that describes the...

  • AN INVESTIGATION INTO THE USE OF EXERCISE AS A MEDIUM FOR MENTAL HEALTH PROMOTION AMONG INSTITUTIONALISED CHILDREN. Chetty, Julie; Edwards, Stephen D. // South African Journal for Research in Sport, Physical Education ;2007, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p1 

    This study was contextualised within the community psychological model of mental health promotion and Erick Erikson's (1950) psychosocial theory with mental health promotion being conceptualised as a positive component of mental health and exercise conceptualised as a subset of physical...

  • Mental Health and Higher Education Counselling Services - Responding to Shifting Student Needs. Simpson, Andrea; Ferguson, Kerry // Journal of the Australian & New Zealand Student Services Associa;Apr2012, Issue 39, p1 

    The rising numbers of students in higher education with mental health issues has become a policy concern. With a specific focus on student counselling services, this paper highlights the historical role services have played in responding to changing student cohorts over time. An overview of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics