CATCH: a clinical decision rule for the use of computed tomography in children with minor head injury

Osmond, Martin H.; Klassen, Terry P.; Wells, George A.; Correll, Rhonda; Jarvis, Anna; Joubert, Gary; Bailey, Benoit; Chauvin-Kimoff, Laurel; Pusic, Martin; McConnell, Don; Nijssen-Jordan, Cheri; Silver, Norm; Taylor, Brett; Stiell, Ian G.
March 2010
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;3/9/2010, Vol. 182 Issue 4, p341
Academic Journal
Background: There is controversy about which children with minor head injury need to undergo computed tomography (CT). We aimed to develop a highly sensitive clinical decision rule for the use of CT in children with minor head injury. Methods: For this multicentre cohort study, we enrolled consecutive children with blunt head trauma presenting with a score of 13-15 on the Glasgow Coma Scale and loss of consciousness, amnesia, disorientation, persistent vomiting or irritability. For each child, staff in the emergency department completed a standardized assessment form before any CT. The main outcomes were need for neurologic intervention and presence of brain injury as determined by CT. We developed a decision rule by using recursive partitioning to combine variables that were both reliable and strongly associated with the outcome measures and thus to find the best combinations of predictor variables that were highly sensitive for detecting the outcome measures with maximal specificity. Results: Among the 3866 patients enrolled (mean age 9.2 years), 95 (2.5%) had a score of 13 on the Glasgow Coma Scale, 282 (7.3%) had a score of 14, and 3489 (90.2%) had a score of 15. CT revealed that 159 (4.1%) had a brain injury, and 24 (0.6%) underwent neurologic intervention. We derived a decision rule for CT of the head consisting of four high-risk factors (failure to reach score of 15 on the Glasgow coma scale within two hours, suspicion of open skull fracture, worsening headache and irritability) and three additional medium-risk factors (large, boggy hematoma of the scalp; signs of basal skull fracture; dangerous mechanism of injury). The high-risk factors were 100.0% sensitive (95% CI 86.2%-100.0%) for predicting the need for neurologic intervention and would require that 30.2% of patients undergo CT. The medium-risk factors resulted in 98.1% sensitivity (95% CI 94.6%-99.4%) for the prediction of brain injury by CT and would require that 52.0% of patients undergo CT. Interpretation: The decision rule developed in this study identifies children at two levels of risk. Once the decision rule has been prospectively validated, it has the potential to standardize and improve the use of CT for children with minor head injury.


Related Articles

  • A multicentre study on the clinical utility of post-traumatic amnesia duration in predicting global outcome after moderate-severe traumatic brain injury. W C Walker // Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry;Jan2010, Vol. 81 Issue 1, p87 

    BACKGROUND: Past research shows that post-traumatic amnesia (PTA) duration is a particularly robust traumatic brain injury (TBI) outcome predictor, but low specificity limits its clinical utility. OBJECTIVES: The current study assessed the relationship between PTA duration and probability...

  • Is Memento For Real? Tanz, Jason // Fortune;4/30/2001, Vol. 143 Issue 9, p28 

    Focuses on the film 'Memento,' in which the main character is unable to form new memories as a result of a blow to the head. Assertion that the condition, called anterograde amnesia, is real and caused by damage to the hippocampus; Opinion of psychologist Donald Davidoff that the film was...

  • Drawing a Blank. Adams, William Lee // Psychology Today;Sep/Oct2007, Vol. 40 Issue 5, p34 

    The article provides information on dissociative fugue, a rare form of amnesia in which people suddenly begin traveling (or continue, if on the road). They forget their identity, fail to recognize loved ones, and cannot recall how they arrived wherever they are. The trance lasts from a few hours...

  • Utility of post-traumatic amnesia in predicting 1-year productivity following traumatic brain injury: comparison of the Russell and Mississippi PTA classification intervals. Nakase-Richardson, R.; Sherer, M.; Seel, R. T.; Hart, T.; Hanks, R.; Arango-Lasprilla, J. C.; Yablon, S. A.; Sander, A. M.; Barnett, S. D.; Walker, W. C.; Hammond, F. // Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry;May2011, Vol. 82 Issue 5, p494 

    BACKGROUND: Duration of post-traumatic amnesia (PTA) correlates with global outcomes and functional disability. Russell proposed the use of PTA duration intervals as an index for classification of traumatic brain injury (TBI) severity. Alternative duration-based schemata have been recently...

  • Association of initial CT findings with quality-of-life outcomes for traumatic brain injury in children. Swanson, Jonathan; Vavilala, Monica; Wang, Jin; Pruthi, Sumit; Fink, James; Jaffe, Kenneth; Durbin, Dennis; Koepsell, Thomas; Temkin, Nancy; Rivara, Frederick // Pediatric Radiology;Aug2012, Vol. 42 Issue 8, p974 

    Background: Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a leading cause of acquired disability in children and adolescents. Objective: To demonstrate the association between specific findings on initial noncontrast head CT and long-term outcomes in children who have suffered TBI. Materials and methods: This...

  • Skull x rays, CT scans, and making a decision in head injury. Tasker, R. C. // Archives of Disease in Childhood;Aug2005, Vol. 90 Issue 8, p774 

    This article focuses on the use of computed tomography (CT) in the diagnosis of child head injuries. The study group Children's Head Injury Algorithm for the Identification of Significant Clinical Events, presented the implications of applying Great Britain's National Institute of Clinical...

  • Checking Children For Brain Trauma Without A CT Scan.  // Child Health Alert;Oct2009, Vol. 27, p5 

    The article discusses research on checking brain trauma in children without the use of a computed tomography (CT) scan. It references a study by N. Kuppermannn et al, published in a 2009 issue of "Lancet." In the study, researchers examined records of children with minor head trauma. They also...

  • ANALYSIS OF TYPE OF BRAIN INJURY AND THEIR CORRELATION WITH VASCULAR DEMENTIA COGNITIVE DECLINE DEGREE. Piros, Elisaveta Ligia; Ciobanu, Gheorghe; Mustea, Anca; Deme, Sanda Maria; Grossmann, Harry; Podea, Delia Marina // Studia Universitatis Vasile Goldis Seria Stiintele Vietii (Life ;2012, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p47 

    Existing epidemiological tests known presently in Romania show that memory diseases are common, on top of those diseases hovering Alzheimer's disease, followed, in order, by vascular dementia, mixed dementia, fronto-temporal dementia and parkinsonian dementia. The study sought to evaluate...

  • Management of Academic and Educational Problems in Head Injury. Telzrow, Cathy F. // Journal of Learning Disabilities;Nov1987, Vol. 20 Issue 9 

    Examines the data pertaining to educational adjustment for traumatically brain injured (TBI) children. Educationally relevant sequelae of head injury in children; System problems in the delivery of appropriate educational interventions; Quality educational programs for TBI children.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics