Reply to my critics

Shoemaker, Sydney
March 2010
Philosophical Studies;Mar2010, Vol. 148 Issue 1, p125
Academic Journal
The article presents the reply of the author to his critics on his book regarding physicalism. He explains the physicality of mental properties and the concept of thin and thick properties. Further, he justifies his opinion on the coincidence of humans with other entities and their identification with just their bodies. Also, the realization-independent detection of mental properties is discussed.


Related Articles

  • The Generalization Argument, Multiple Realization, and Special Science Properties. Campbell, Neil // International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences;2010, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p457 

    Kim's supervenience/exclusion argument is designed to show that if nonreductive physicalists insist that mental properties are physically irreducible, their causal (and explanatory) status is preempted by the physical properties on which they supervene or depend. Numerous critics have responded...

  • Kan kompleksiteit siele red? 'n Teologiese pleidooi vir eenvoud. Brand, Gerrit // Tydskrif vir Geesteswetenskappe;Mar2012, Vol. 52 Issue 1, p103 

    Recent statements and reflections by public intellectuals' like the French based "international association "Ars Industrialis and the American author Marilynne Robinson, point to what they see as a crisis of the "spirit" or "soul" in contemporary society. (For present purposes "spirit" and...

  • Moving beyond the subset model of realization: The problem of qualitative distinctness in the metaphysics of science. Gillett, Carl // Synthese;Nov2010, Vol. 177 Issue 2, p165 

    Understanding the 'making-up' relations, to put things neutrally, posited in mechanistic explanations the sciences is finally an explicit topic of debate amongst philosophers of science. In particular, there is now lively debate over the nature of the so-called 'realization' relations between...

  • Empirismo logico e relatività ontologica. Ripensando Carnap. Collina, Beatrice // Epistemologia;ene-jun2011, Vol. 34 Issue 1, p171 

    No abstract available.

  • Role Functionalism and Epiphenomenalism. Moore, Dwayne // Philosophia;Sep2011, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p511 

    The type-type reductive identity of the mental to the physical was once the dominant position in the mental causation debate. In time this consensus was overturned, largely due to its inability to handle the problem of multiple realizability. In its place a nonreductive position emerged which...

  • El desorden de las cosas y el problema de la demarcación. García Duque, Carlos Emilio // Revista Estudios de Filosofía;feb2013, Issue 46, p61 

    In this paper, I analyze John Dupré's criticisms of the methodological unity of science. As it is known, from the premise of the disorder of things, Dupré rejects both strong and weak variants of unification, but his best arguments against the latter suppose that there is no satisfactory...

  • The myth of physicalism. BUSSEY, PETER // Science & Christian Belief;Oct2009, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p98 

    The author talks about the apparent myth of physicalism. In the author's opinion, the notion of physicalism stands as a form of modern fashionable myth. He believes that people tend to support physicalism with only a part of their mind while their attitudes and behaviour express otherwise. He...

  • Causation, coincidence, and commensuration. Audi, Paul // Philosophical Studies;Jan2013, Vol. 162 Issue 2, p447 

    What does it take to solve the exclusion problem? An ingenious strategy is Stephen Yablo's idea that causes must be commensurate with their effects. Commensuration is a relation between events. Roughly, events are commensurate with one another when one contains all that is required for the...

  • Locating the Overdetermination Problem. Witmer, D. Gene // British Journal for the Philosophy of Science;Jun2000, Vol. 51 Issue 2, p273 

    Assesses the use of the term physical in physicalism. Reasons for making physics as reference in physicalism; Notion on the existence of causal overdetermination; Claims on the causal impact of mental on the physical; Justification of physicalism; Correlation between the ordinary-physical and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics