The skills gap in hospital management: a comparative analysis of hospital managers in the public and private sectors in South Africa

Pillay, Rubin
February 2010
Health Services Management Research;Feb2010, Vol. 23 Issue 1, p30
Academic Journal
A lack of management capacity has been identified as the key stumbling block to attaining the goals of health for all in South Africa. As part of the overall management development process, this research aims to identify the skills that are important for health services management and to evaluate managers' self-assessed proficiency in each of these skills. We also examined the impact of past training on perceived competency levels. A cross-sectional survey using a self-administered questionnaire was conducted among 404 hospital managers in the South African public and private sectors. Respondents were asked to rate the level of importance that each proposed competency had in their job and to indicate their proficiency in each skill. Both public and private sector managers rated competencies related to 'people management', 'self-management' and 'task-related skills' highest followed by 'strategic planning' and 'health delivery', respectively. The largest differences between mean importance rating and mean skill rating for public sector managers were for people management skills, task-related skills and self-management skills. The largest deficits for private sector managers were for people management skills, self-management skills and health delivery skills. Informal management development programmes were found to be more valuable in improving management skills. These findings reflect the reality of the local health service environment and the need of health managers. It will be useful in the conceptualization, design and delivery of health management programmes aimed at enhancing current and future management and leadership capacity in the health sector in South Africa.


Related Articles

  • Developing Tomorrow's Leaders. Runy, Lee Ann // H&HN: Hospitals & Health Networks;Apr2009, Vol. 83 Issue 4, p25 

    The article looks at the key steps to forming programs to help hospitals and health systems build leadership competencies and maximize organizational effectiveness. It is advisable to start small and build the program out, particularly for organizations uncertain of whether they can afford to...

  • Managementqualitäten des chirurgischen Chefarztes: überlebenswichtig! Jähne, J. // Der Chirurg;Apr2012, Vol. 83 Issue 4, p368 

    Due to increased economic challenges in the management of hospitals head surgeons do not only need excellent surgical expertise but also significant management qualities. The personality of head surgeons should include authenticity, sincerity, fairness and the ability to cooperate. Visionary...

  • Does it matter who owns health facilities? Duckett, Stephen // Journal of Health Services Research & Policy;Jan2001, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p59 

    The rhetoric of governments 'steering not rowing' and of purchaser–provider splits is still part of the language of public sector reform throughout the world, despite some retreat in the National Health Service in the UK. Implementation of separation of purchaser and provider roles has...

  • Assessing the 'Fit': Using Competencies to Select New Board Members. Totten, Mary K. // Trustee;Jul/Aug2012, Vol. 65 Issue 7, p17 

    The article discusses issues related to the selection of competent hospital board members. The factors that contributed to the difficulty of attracting desirable hospital trustees include a limited pool of potential trustees. Information is also presented on identifying and assessing...

  • Managerial competencies of hospital managers in South Africa: a survey of managers in the public and private sectors. Pillay, Rubin // Human Resources for Health;2008, Vol. 6, Special section p1 

    Background: South Africa has large public and private sectors and there is a common perception that public sector hospitals are inefficient and ineffective while the privately owned and managed hospitals provide superior care and are more sustainable. The underlying assumption is that there is a...

  • Magic moments. Thomson, Sally // Nursing Standard;7/13/2005, Vol. 19 Issue 44, p70 

    Focuses on the benefits and rewards in good nursing management in Great Britain. Framework in nursing management; Importance of leadership, people, caring, and financial skills, and information management as qualities in a good nursing management.

  • Competencias para la enfermera/o en el ámbito de gestión y administración: desafíos actuales de la profesión. Soto-Fuentes, Paz; Reynaldos-Grandón, Katiuska; Martínez-Santana, Dayann; Jerez-Yáñez, Oscar // Aquichan;Mar2014, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p79 

    The job skills involved in nursing make it possible to reduce inequalities and limited access to services, and to support safe and quality care. The training nurses receive is fundamental to the composition and dynamics of the nursing work force, the quality and appropriateness of nursing care,...

  • Challenges of Organizational Leadership Development in Iran's Private Sectors. Mehrabani, Shadi Ebrahimi; Mohamad, Noor Azmi // International Proceedings of Economics Development & Research;2011, Vol. 7, p35 

    Nowadays, organizations all over the world are trying to be more competitive by investing on growing their leaders. Since organizational leadership development is considered by many researchers, there is much evidence that this process is facing weaknesses in many organizations, especially in...

  • Multi-Pronged Approach Best When Evaluating Quality. Miller, Neale // Nursing Economic$;Sep/Oct98, Vol. 16 Issue 5, p275 

    Presents news items related to leadership and hospital management. Suggestions for performance measurement guidelines for nurse executives; Improving of the pressure ulcer prevention practice of caregivers in nursing homes and hospitals; Impact of the Year 2000 date conversion problem on health...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics