Patterns of Secularization and Religious Rationalization in Emile Durkheim and Max Weber

Goldstein, Warren S.
July 2009
Implicit Religion;Jul2009, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p135
Academic Journal
Emile Durkheim's and Max Weber's sociologies of religion contain three different patterns of secularization and religious rationalization: the unilinear, the dialectical, and the nonlinear (which includes the paradoxical). Based on an analysis of Durkheim's and Weber's writings on religion, this paper argues that the process of religious rationalization and secularization is not always linear but can also take place in a dialectical or paradoxical manner. Whereas in the unilinear and dialectical theories of religious rationalization and secularization there is a progressive development, in the nonlinear or paradoxical theory, development is arrested. While the unilinear and dialectical theories are associated with the Occidental development to modernity, the paradoxical nature of theoretical religious rationalization was characteristic ofthe "arrested" development ofthe Orient, while the paradoxical aspects ofsecularization are associated with unresolved contradictions of modernity (the postmodern).


Related Articles

  • RELIGIÃO COMO SOLVENTE -- UMA AULA. Pierucci, Antônio Flávio // Novos Estudos;jul2006, Issue 75, p111 

    On the opposite direction of Durkheim, to whom the role of religion is to reconnect the individual with the society he belongs, this essay states that nowadays religion's social power is quite the opposite: it separates people from its origins. Taking Max Weber's work as a guideline, it supports...

  • REPLY TO ZELDITCH. Gray, David J. // American Sociologist;Feb79, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p55 

    This article presents a response to a commentary on an article about mainstream sociology. Emile Durkheim, Max Weber and Karl Marx are important because their concepts have great explanatory power, even for modern times.

  • On Facts and Values. Ghenea, Ştefan Viorel // Scientific Journal of Humanistic Studies;Mar2015, Vol. 7 Issue 12, p11 

    In a society based on knowledge is very important to understand the mechanisms which stand on the bases of the knowledge, and the way that the knowledge is offering us the possibility to make true opinions about our inner life and about the external reality. Classical sociologists as Émile...

  • Theories of Secularization: From 'Positivist Certainty' to a Mere Social Myth? Delibaş, Kayhan // Eurasian Journal of Educational Research (EJER);Jan2006, Issue 22, p74 

    Founding fathers of sociology Karl Marx (1969, pp.303-304; 1990, pp.63-64), Emile Durkheim (1965, pp.75-476) and Max Weber (1974, pp.181-182) shared the view that traditional religion was becoming more and more trivial to the modern world. They all agreed that secularization was an inevitable...

  • KNOWLEDGE AND RELIGION IN SOCIETY: A COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE. Mazman, İbrahim // Ekev Academic Review;Summer2008, Vol. 12 Issue 36, p1 

    This study purposes to deal with the problem of how sociological approaches to the issues of knowledge and religion diverge according to their theoretical points of view. After we discuss Karl Marx, Karl Mannheim and Berger-Luckmann in the sociology of knowledge section, we will examine ideas of...

  • PART 4 Conclusion: Chapter Fourteen ON COMMUNITY AND SOLIDARITY.  // Social Cohesion & Legal Coercion;1997, Vol. 44, p309 

    Chapter 14 of the book "Social Cohesion & Legal Coercion" by Leon Shaskolsky Sheleff is presented. It draws on the work of German economist and sociologist Max Weber, French sociologist Emile Durkheim and German economist and philosopher Karl Marx to reflect on the implications of their...

  • Will sociology ever be a normal science? Boudon, Raymond // Theory & Society;1988, Vol. 17 Issue 5, p747 

    This article discusses on the consideration of sociology as a normal science. Normal science is a quiet and felicitous state of affairs where the scientific community corresponding to a discipline believes faithfully in a unique paradigm. Emile Durkheim's sociology had already little to do with...

  • POST-PARSONIAN SOCIOLOGY. Tiryakian, Edward A. // Humboldt Journal of Social Relations;1979, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p17 

    The article presents information about post-Parsonian sociology. In one sense, this expression can designate the state of American sociology, particularly in terms of core theoretical orientations, after the waning or passing of sociologist Talcott Parsons as the most influential figure in the...

  • Chapter 10: Moral Philosophy and Social Science. Selznick, Philip // Humanist Science: Values & Ideas in Social Inquiry;2008, p119 

    Chapter 10 of the book "A Humanist Science: Values and Ideals in Social Inquiry," by Philip Selznick, is presented. It explores the interdependence between moral philosophy and social science. It highlights the works of Max Weber and Emile Durkheim which emphasizes the transition of philosophy...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics