Pascal's Wager, infective endocarditis and the "no-lose" philosophy in medicine

Shaw, D.; Conway, D. I.
January 2010
Heart;Jan2010, Vol. 96 Issue 1, p15
Academic Journal
Doctors and dentists have traditionally used antibiotic prophylaxis in certain patient groups in order to prevent infective endocarditis (IE). New guidelines, however, suggest that the risk to patients from using antibiotics is higher than the risk from IE. This paper analyses the relative risks of prescribing and not prescribing antibiotic prophylaxis against the background of Pascal's Wager, the infamous assertion that it is better to believe in God regardless of evidence, because of the prospective benefits should He exist. Many doctors seem to believe the parallel proposition that it is better to prescribe antibiotics, regardless of evidence, because of the prospective benefit conferred upon the patient. This has been called the "no lose philosophy" in medicine: better safe than sorry, even if the evidence inconveniently suggests that following this mantra is potentially more likely to result in sorry than safe. It transpires that, just as Pascal's Wager fails to convince because of a lack of evidence to support it and the costs incurred by trying to believe, so the "belts and braces" approach of prescribing antibiotic prophylaxis is unjustifiable given the actual evidence of potential risk and benefit to the patient. Ultimately, there is no no-lose if your clinical decisions, like Pascal's Wager, are based on faith rather than evidence.


Related Articles

  • Pathology of Fatal Bacterial Endocarditis before and since the Introduction of Antibiotics. Wilson, Larkin M. // Annals of Internal Medicine;Jan63, Vol. 58 Issue 1, p84 

    Focuses on the pathology of fatal bacterial endocarditis before and since the introduction of antibiotics. Valvular involvement in cases of bacterial endocarditis; Etiology of the underlying heart disease; Presence of embolic phenomena with infarction.

  • No statistical difference. Esmail, Z. // British Dental Journal;7/23/2011, Vol. 211 Issue 2, p53 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Impact of the NICE guideline recommending cessation of antibiotic prophylaxis for prevention of infective endocarditis: before and after study," by M. H. Thornhill and colleagues in the May 2011 issue of the "British Medical Journal."

  • Management of Bacterial Endocarditis. Giessel, Barton E.; Koenig, Clint J.; Blake, Robert L. // American Family Physician;3/15/2000, Vol. 61 Issue 6, p1725 

    Focuses on antibiotic treatment of bacterial endocarditis in adults. Cause of bacterial endocarditis; Diagnostic criteria for the disease; Treatment with antibiotic regimen.

  • Use of antibiotics. Oakley, Celia // British Medical Journal;8/12/1978, Vol. 2 Issue 6135, p489 

    Examines the use of antibiotics on infective endocarditis. Cause of medical infective endocarditis; Choice of drugs and duration of treatment; Increase risk of phlebitis with secondary invaders.

  • Antibiotics for prevention of endocarditis during dentistry: Time to scale back? Durack, David T. // Annals of Internal Medicine;11/15/98, Vol. 129 Issue 10, p829 

    Editorial. Discusses the need to reassess the use of antibiotics to prevent endocarditis during dental therapy. Induction of bacteremia during dental procedures; Absence of correlation between dental work and infective endocarditis; Need to scale back the use of antibiotic prophylaxis against...

  • EASE: Early surgery after infective endocarditis diagnosis reduced complication. Fisher, Stacey L.; Foster, Melissa; Kalvaitis, Katie; Murphy, Casey // Cardiology Today;Jan2012, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p17 

    The article focuses on a study which compared the effectiveness of early surgery and antibiotic therapy in reducing complications among patients with infective endocarditis.

  • Antibiotics have limited benefit for infective endocarditis prevention.  // British Dental Journal;5/28/2011, Vol. 210 Issue 10, p467 

    The article focuses on the research conducted by Oral Medicine professor Martin Thornhill and his team in Sheffield, England regarding the impact of the prescription of antibiotics to the prevention of infective endocarditis.

  • SUBACUTE BACTERIAL ENDOCARDITIS: CONSIDERATIONS FOR THE PEDIATRIC PATIENT. Soxman, Jane A. // Journal of the American Dental Association (JADA);May2000, Vol. 131 Issue 5, p668 

    Focuses on the confusion regarding the need for antibiotics for prophylaxis in a pediatric patient with excellent oral hygiene. Toxic and adverse reactions to the medications; Risk factor for infective endocarditis; Creation of antibiotic-resistant oral streptococci; Reestablishment of...

  • Antibiotic prophylaxis. Tomás, I.; Limeres, J.; Diz, P.; Tomás, I // British Dental Journal;1/22/2005, Vol. 198 Issue 2, p60 

    Presents a letter to the editor about the recommendations on dental aspects of bacterial endocarditis prophylaxis.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics