Accuracy and usefulness of BMI measures based on self-reported weight and height: findings from the NHANES & NHIS 2001-2006

Stommel, Manfred; Schoenborn, Charlotte A.
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p421
Academic Journal
Background: The Body Mass Index (BMI) based on self-reported height and weight ("self-reported BMI") in epidemiologic studies is subject to measurement error. However, because of the ease and efficiency in gathering height and weight information through interviews, it remains important to assess the extent of error present in self-reported BMI measures and to explore possible adjustment factors as well as valid uses of such self-reported measures. Methods: Using the combined 2001-2006 data from the continuous National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, discrepancies between BMI measures based on self-reported and physical height and weight measures are estimated and socio-demographic predictors of such discrepancies are identified. Employing adjustments derived from the socio-demographic predictors, the self-reported measures of height and weight in the 2001-2006 National Health Interview Survey are used for population estimates of overweight & obesity as well as the prediction of health risks associated with large BMI values. The analysis relies on two-way frequency tables as well as linear and logistic regression models. All point and variance estimates take into account the complex survey design of the studies involved. Results: Self-reported BMI values tend to overestimate measured BMI values at the low end of the BMI scale (< 22) and underestimate BMI values at the high end, particularly at values > 28. The discrepancies also vary systematically with age (younger and older respondents underestimate their BMI more than respondents aged 42-55), gender and the ethnic/racial background of the respondents. BMI scores, adjusted for socio-demographic characteristics of the respondents, tend to narrow, but do not eliminate misclassification of obese people as merely overweight, but health risk estimates associated with variations in BMI values are virtually the same, whether based on self-report or measured BMI values. Conclusion: BMI values based on self-reported height and weight, if corrected for biases associated with socio-demographic characteristics of the survey respondents, can be used to estimate health risks associated with variations in BMI, particularly when using parametric prediction models.


Related Articles

  • Chapter 5.3: Major public health problems – overweight and obesity. Boström, Gunnel; Eliasson, Mats // Scandinavian Journal of Public Health;Jun2006 Supplement 67, Vol. 34 Issue s67, p69 

    The article discusses obesity as a public health problem in Sweden. Body mass index is the method used to define obesity in Sweden. Obesity is more common in rural areas than in metropolitan areas. It is also more common among blue-collar workers than among white. People are encourage to reduce...

  • Prevalence of Overall and Abdominal Obesity among Adolescent High School Girls in Tabriz, Iran. Rafraf, M.; Mohamadi, E.; Gargari, B. P. // International Medical Journal Malaysia;Jun2013, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p27 

    Introduction: Obesity is a growing public health problem in both developed and developing societies. The aim of this cross-sectional study was to estimate the prevalence of overall obesity determined by body mass index (BMI) and abdominal obesity identified by waist circumference(WC)...

  • Variations In Body Mass Indices Among Post-Pubertal Nigerian Subjects With Correlation To Cormic Indices, Mid-Arm Circumferences And Waist Circumferences. Adeyemi, David Olawale; Komolafe, Omobola Aderibigbe; Abioye, Abdulraheem Idowu // Internet Journal of Biological Anthropology;2009, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p11 

    Overweight and obesity are the leading nutrition-related disorders of clinical and public health concern. Assessment and classification of these conditions are dependent on specific body mass index (BMI) cut-off points. A study of BMI with correlation to Cormic index (CI, sitting height/stature...

  • Fat free mass and obesity in relation to educational level. Seppänen-Nuijten, Elina; Lahti-Koski, Marjaana; Männistö, Satu; Knekt, Paul; Rissanen, Harri; Aromaa, Arpo; Heliövaara, Markku // BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p448 

    Background: The aim of the study was to describe the body composition of Finnish adults, especially by education, and to investigate whether fat-free mass (FFM) can explain educational gradients relating to body mass index (BMI) and waist-to-hip ratio (WHR). Methods: Data for this...

  • Nutrition diagnoses. Strauss, B. J. G. // Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition;2004 Supplement, Vol. 13, pS11 

    Management of nutritional disorders rests on making a diagnosis. The ICD-10 classification of diseases lists a large number of nutritional diagnoses without suggesting a measurement definition of each disorder. Some areas of clinical acceptance, such as visceral obesity are not listed. Use of...

  • Weighing obesity stigma: the relative strength of different forms of bias. Latner, J D; O'Brien, K S; Durso, L E; Brinkman, L A; MacDonald, T // International Journal of Obesity;Jul2008, Vol. 32 Issue 7, p1145 

    Objective:To compare the strength of weight bias to other common biases, and to develop a psychometrically sound measure to assess and compare bias against different targets.Subjects:A total of 368 university students (75.4% women, 47.6% white, mean age: 21.53 years, mean body mass index (BMI):...

  • Developmental Trajectories of Body Mass Index Among Japanese Children and Impact of Maternal Factors during Pregnancy. Haga, Chiyori; Kondo, Naoki; Suzuki, Kohta; Sato, Miri; Ando, Daisuke; Yokomichi, Hiroshi; Tanaka, Taichiro; Yamagata, Zentaro // PLoS ONE;Dec2012, Vol. 7 Issue 12, p1 

    Background: The aims of this study were to 1) determine the distinct patterns of body mass index (BMI) trajectories in Japanese children, and 2) elucidate the maternal factors during pregnancy, which contribute to the determination of those patterns. Methodology/Principal Findings: All of the...

  • Re-thinking 'the obesity problem'. Colls, Rachel; Evans, Bethan // Primary Geographer;Jul2010, Vol. 95 Issue 2, p99 

    In recent times the 'obesity problem' has become a key public health concern in Britain. As a consequence a range of policy initiatives have been put in place in order to treat obese bodies and to halt and prevent any increase in obesity rates. Situated within recent work in geography on health...

  • Relationship Between Dietary Pattern and Body Mass Index Among Primary School Children. Umairah, Sharifah Nur; Yahya, Binti Tuan; Datin, Madya; Yusof, Safiah Md. // Asian Journal of Clinical Nutrition;2012, Vol. 4 Issue 4, p142 

    Currently, childhood obesity has been growing at an alarming rate and it is a common nutritional problem among children in developed countries as well as in developing countries. It has become one of the most serious public health challenges of the 21st century. This study attempts to determine...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics