Screening and brief interventions for hazardous and harmful alcohol use in probation services: a cluster randomised controlled trial protocol

Newbury-Birch, Dorothy; Bland, Martin; Cassidy, Paul; Coulton, Simon; Deluca, Paolo; Drummond, Colin; Gilvarry, Eilish; Godfrey, Christine; Heather, Nick; Kaner, Eileen; Myles, Judy; Oyefeso, Adenekan; Parrott, Steve; Perryman, Katherine; Phillips, Tom; Shenker, Don; Shepherd, Jonathan
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p418
Academic Journal
Background: A large number of randomised controlled trials in health settings have consistently reported positive effects of brief intervention in terms of reductions in alcohol use. However, although alcohol misuse is common amongst offenders, there is limited evidence of alcohol brief interventions in the criminal justice field. This factorial pragmatic cluster randomised controlled trial with Offender Managers (OMs) as the unit of randomisation will evaluate the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of different models of screening to identify hazardous and harmful drinkers in probation and different intensities of brief intervention to reduce excessive drinking in probation clients. Methods and design: Ninety-six OMs from 9 probation areas across 3 English regions (the North East Region (n = 4) and London and the South East Regions (n = 5)) will be recruited. OMs will be randomly allocated to one of three intervention conditions: a client information leaflet control condition (n = 32 OMs); 5-minute simple structured advice (n = 32 OMs) and 20-minute brief lifestyle counselling delivered by an Alcohol Health Worker (n = 32 OMs). Randomisation will be stratified by probation area. To test the relative effectiveness of different screening methods all OMs will be randomised to either the Modified Single Item Screening Questionnaire (M-SASQ) or the Fast Alcohol Screening Test (FAST). There will be a minimum of 480 clients recruited into the trial. There will be an intention to treat analysis of study outcomes at 6 and 12 months post intervention. Analysis will include client measures (screening result, weekly alcohol consumption, alcohol-related problems, re-offending, public service use and quality of life) and implementation measures from OMs (the extent of screening and brief intervention beyond the minimum recruitment threshold will provide data on acceptability and feasibility of different models of brief intervention). We will also examine the practitioner and organisational factors associated with successful implementation. Discussion: The trial will evaluate the impact of screening and brief alcohol intervention in routine probation work and therefore its findings will be highly relevant to probation teams and thus the criminal justice system in the UK. Ethical approval was given by Northern & Yorkshire REC Trial Registration number: ISRCTN 19160244


Related Articles

  • Medical Screening and the Value of Early Detection: When Unwarranted Faith Leads to Unethical Recommendations. MALM, H. M. // Hastings Center Report;Jan/Feb99, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p26 

    Discusses the ethical permissibility of the practice of recommending screening tests in the absence of randomized, controlled clinical trials. Consideration on the justifications for the practice of recommending screening tests prior to the completion of randomized clinical trials; Examples of...

  • Chlamydia screening 'may even be harmful'. Wilkinson, Emma // Pulse;12/17/2008, Vol. 68 Issue 44, p8 

    The article reports on the launching of the national chlamydia screening programme in Great Britain despite the lack of supporting evidence about its effectiveness. The author emphasizes that she could not found randomised trials showing any benefit of opportunistic screening in under 25 years...

  • Screening for Carotid Artery Stenosis: An Update of the Evidence for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. Wolff, Tracy; Guirguis-Blake, Janelle; Miller, Therese; Gillespie, Michael; Harris, Russell // Annals of Internal Medicine;12/18/2007, Vol. 147 Issue 12, p860 

    Background: Cerebrovascular disease is the third leading cause of death in the United States. The proportion of all strokes attributable to previously asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis (CAS) is low. In 1996, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force concluded that evidence was insufficient to...

  • Medicine in the News. Diloreto, Stacy // Patient Care for the Nurse Practitioner;Jun2002, Vol. 5 Issue 6, p4 

    The article presents news briefs on medical research. A position statement issued by the American Diabetes Association and the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases recommends prediabetes screening for all overweight patients. The American College of Cardiology 2002...

  • Evidence-based clinical recommendations regarding screening for oral squamous cell carcinomas. Rethman, Michael P.; Carpenter, William; Cohen, Ezra E. W.; Epstein, Joel; Evans, Caswell A.; Flaitz, Catherine M.; Graham, Frank J.; Hujoel, Philippe P.; Kalmar, John R.; Koch, Wayne M.; Lambert, Paul M.; Lingen, Mark W.; Oettmeler Jr., Bert W.; Patton, Lauren L.; Perkins, David; Reid, Britt C.; Sciubba, James J.; Tomar, Scott L.; Wyatt Jr., Alfred O.; Aravamudhan, Krishna // Journal of the American Dental Association (JADA);May2010, Vol. 141 Issue 5, p509 

    The article presents a report from a panel convened by the American Dental Association (ADA) Council on Scientific Affairs that discusses the advantages and risks of screening for oral squamous cell carcinomas. It says that five systematic reviews and four clinical studies were analyzed from the...

  • One hundred years ago. Room, Henry // British Journal of Psychiatry;Nov2004, Vol. 185, p439 

    The article presents the clinical trial of a 41-year-old man who died of epilepsy on August 4, 1902 in the U.S. The physical appearance of the patient has changed, where its dwarfed figure was bent forwards while his coarse grinning faced bulge out between the misshapen spreading ears. Results...

  • Commentary: Can risk score models help in reducing serious outcome events in patients with stable angina? Terkelsen, Christian Juhl; Vach, Werner // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);10/15/2005, Vol. 331 Issue 7521, p872 

    Comments on the article "Risk score for predicting death, myocardial infarction, and stroke in patients with stable angina, based on a large randomised trial cohort of patients" in the current issue of "British Medical Journal." Question on whether or not the proposed risk score model can become...

  • Designing cost-efficient randomized trials by using flexible recruitment strategies. Menggang Yu; Jingwei Wu; Burns, Debra S.; Carpenter, Janet S. // BMC Medical Research Methodology;2012, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p106 

    Background: Sample size planning for clinical trials is usually based on detecting a target effect size of an intervention or treatment. Explicit incorporation of costs into such planning is considered in this article in the situation where effects of an intervention or treatment may depend on...

  • The Ankle-Brachial Index for Peripheral Artery Disease Screening and Cardiovascular Disease Prediction Among Asymptomatic Adults: A Systematic Evidence Review for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. Lin, Jennifer S.; Olson, Carin M.; Johnson, Eric S.; Whitlock, Evelyn P. // Annals of Internal Medicine;9/3/2013, Vol. 159 Issue 5, p333 

    Background: Screening for peripheral artery disease (PAD) may reduce morbidity and mortality. Purpose: To review the evidence on the ability of the ankle-brachial index (ABI) to predict cardiovascular disease (CVD) morbidity and mortality independent of Framingham Risk Score (FRS) factors in...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics