Privation theories of pain

Swenson, Adam
December 2009
International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Dec2009, Vol. 66 Issue 3, p139
Academic Journal
Most modern writers accept that a privation theory of evil should explicitly account for the evil of pain. But pains are quintessentially real. The evil of pain does not seem to lie in an absence of good. Though many directly take on the challenges this raises, the metaphysics and axiology of their answers is often obscure. In this paper I try to straighten things out. By clarifying and categorizing the possible types of privation views, I explore the ways in which privationists about evil are—or should or could be—privationists about pain’s evil.


Related Articles

  • Dispositional accounts of evil personhood. Russell, Luke // Philosophical Studies;Jun2010, Vol. 149 Issue 2, p231 

    It is intuitively plausible that not every evildoer is an evil person. In order to make sense of this intuition we need to construct an account of evil personhood in addition to an account of evil action. Some philosophers have offered aggregative accounts of evil personhood, but these do not...

  • Amor Sacrificial. Orozco Guzmán, Mario // Revista Mal-estar e Subjetividade;set2011, Vol. 11 Issue 3, p913 

    Sacrifice corresponds to an argument of love. Its exercise which is most of the times inscribed in the sacred order of culture, does not stop compromising the participation of "Bemächtigungstrieb" drive for mastery. In the meantime, sacrifice renders itself to the Other in order to become...

  • AFFECTIVE CONSTITUTION AND THE PROBLEM OF SUFFERING. Ballard, Bruce // American Theological Inquiry;2010, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p69 

    The article discusses the philosophical and existential dimensions of the problem and argument from evil as suffering. The author also examined the function of the affect in the constitution and interpretation of experience, along with implications for the debate on suffering. In addition, an...

  • Ä°LK MU'TEZÄ°LE'NÄ°N ÖZGÃœR Ä°RADE SÖYLEMÄ°: AMR B. UBEYD VE KADER ANLAYIÅžI. Aydinli, Osman // Journal of Divinity Faculty of Hitit University;2002, Vol. 1 Issue 2, p127 

    The name of 'Amr b. 'Ubaid have an important role in the early Mu'tazila movement. He was the advocate of free will and argued that man has the ability to create his own action, both good and evil. The controversy over free will and predestination had serious political implications as the early...

  • A THOMISTIC RESPONSE TO THE PROBLEM OF EVIL. Kerr, Gaven // Yearbook of the Irish Philosophical Society;2011, p38 

    The problem of evil is set up as a basic modus tollens argument: (i) if God is an all powerful, all knowing, all good creator, then evil does not or should not exist; (ii) evil exists; therefore God as thus conceived does not exist. Many responses to the problem of evil challenge the first...

  • The Conceptual Dynamics of Good and Evil in the Joseph Story: An Exegetical and Hermeneutical Inquiry. Jacobs, Mignon R. // Journal for the Study of the Old Testament;Mar2003, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p309 

    This article examines the dynamics of good and evil as represented in the Joseph story (Gen. 37-50). It examines the story's plot, the larger conceptual framework of the narrative's Pentateuchal setting, as well as the semantic indicators and associated attitudes/behaviors qualified as good ......

  • Morals by Law.  // America;9/14/1929, Vol. 41 Issue 23, p535 

    The author reflects on the promotion of good morals. According to the author, public morality can be promoted by giving every child an opportunity to receive a training that will form him to choose the paths of rectitude. The author notes that the state should retain its power to punish but it...

  • GOOD AND EVIL, THE NATURE OF THE SOUL. Aversano, Laura Silvana // Proceedings (Academy of Religion & Psychical Research );2004, p98 

    The following discourse focuses on the concept, structure, and definition of good and evil as it applies to the nature of the soul. The process of ascension, and psycho-spiritual perspectives as they relate to the light and the darkness will be discussed.

  • PHILOSOPHY AND THEOLOGY. KACZOR, CHRISTOPHER // National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly;Summer2011, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p381 

    The article discusses the conditions to which an action with two effects or double-effect, one good and the other evil, can be considered ethically permissible. It cites hypothetical cases describing the conditions which include that the action itself, its object is not intrinsically evil; the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics