The HIV-positive dentist: balancing the rights of the health care worker and the patient

Gardam, Michael A.; Flanagan, William F.; Salit, Irving E.
June 2001
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;6/12/2001, Vol. 164 Issue 12, p1715
Academic Journal
We describe a hypothetical case of an HIV-positive dentist without cognitive impairment who uses proper infection control procedures. The dentist's physician notifies the medical officer of health without the dentist's consent. Although HIV-positive health care workers, including dentists, have been identified in the past, proven HIV transmission to patients is very rare. Most authorities recommend that an HIV-positive health care worker be monitored by an expert panel, which could then, if necessary, refer to the regulatory body to revoke or restrict the person's licence to practice. Mandatory HIV testing is not required for health care workers because they generally do not pose a risk for infecting their patients; they are, however, ethically and legally obligated to report their HIV status to their profession's regulatory body.


Related Articles

  • Many people with HIV never tell their sex partners.  // Jet;02/23/98, Vol. 93 Issue 13, p12 

    Looks at the results of a survey of HIV patients treated at Boston City Hospital and Rhode Island Hospital from 1994 to 1996. The number of people with HIV that did not inform their partners about their condition; The number of people with HIV that did not use condoms; Patients who were most...

  • Disclosing the truth to terminal cancer patients: a discussion of ethical and cultural issues. Kazdaglis, G. A.; Arnaoutoglou, C.; Karypidis, D.; Memekidou, G.; Spanos, G.; Papadopoulos, O. // Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal;abr2010, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p442 

    One of the most difficult ethical dilemmas facing health care professionals working in oncology is whether, when, how and how much to tell terminal cancer patients about their diagnosis and prognosis. The aim of this article is to review the trends in this issue worldwide. While a majority of...

  • Confidentiality in practice; knowing when to keep a secret. Brennan, Mark G. // Vital (17417503);Jun2010, Vol. 7 Issue 3, p44 

    The article offers information on the responsibility that should be practice by dental care professional (DCPs) and dentists with regards to confidentiality. It mentions that every registered DCPs and dentist should respect, protect information which are personal as implied in the ethical and...

  • When is deception in research ethical? Athanassoulis, Nafsika; Wilson, James // Clinical Ethics;2009, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p44 

    This article examines when deceptive withholding of information is ethically acceptable in research. The first half analyses the concept of deception. We argue that there are two types of accounts of deception: normative and non-normative, and argue that non-normative accounts are preferable....

  • Disclosure of error taps 'very deep cultural norms.'.  // Medical Ethics Advisor;Apr2010, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p45 

    The article focuses on the disclosure of errors within health care delivery in the U.S. It discusses the acceptable means of telling the truth to the patient by the physician even if it is an error committed during the treatment. Also discussed are the advantages of disclosing an error to a...

  • Should genetic information be disclosed to insurers? YES. Holm, Soren // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);6/9/2007, Vol. 334 Issue 7605, p1196 

    The article presents the author's opinions on whether genetic information should be disclosed to insurers. Arguments are presented which suggest that it should because genetic information is not inherently more specific, predictive, sensitive, or private than other kinds of health information,...

  • Should genetic information be disclosed to insurers? NO. Ashcroft, Richard // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);6/9/2007, Vol. 334 Issue 7605, p1197 

    The article presents the author's opinions on whether genetic information should be disclosed to insurers. Arguments are presented which suggest that it should not because it can be misunderstood and its importance overestimated and used in a discriminatory way, and that the moratorium on use of...

  • AM I OBLIGATED TO TREAT A PATIENT WHO IS HIV-POSITIVE? Graeber, John J. // Journal of the American Dental Association (JADA);Aug2004, Vol. 135 Issue 8, p1172 

    Presents a question-and-answer advisory related to dental appointment with an HIV-positive patient. Discussion on the Code of Professional Conduct; Type of dental treatment provided to patients; Protection of patients confidentiality.

  • Facing up to phobia. Meskin, Lawrence H. // Journal of the American Dental Association (JADA);Oct96, Vol. 127 Issue 10, p1450 

    Recommends that treatment programs be developed to assist dentists who are reluctant in treating patients infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Reduction in precautions taken of transmitting HIV from patient to dentist; Information on the American Dental Association's Principles...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics