History Rhymes: The German Precedent for Chinese Seapower

Holmes, James R.; Yoshihara, Toshi
January 2010
Orbis;Jan2010, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p14
Academic Journal
Abstract: We compare the rise of Chinese seapower today to the rise of Imperial German seapower a century ago. The comparison is worthwhile for two reasons. First, the comparison holds merits in its own right. We use German Admiral Wolfgang Wegener''s three indices of seapower–strategic position, the fleet, and strategic will to the sea–to assess the two countries’ maritime potential. This analysis leads inexorably to the conclusion that China holds far more potential for seapower that did the Kaiser''s Germany. And second, the Chinese themselves are consulting German history as they inquire into the triumphs and failures of past great powers. Trying to divine how they interpret the German experience could let Western practitioners and scholars of grand strategy glimpse China''s maritime future. In turn they can improve their own handling of strategy in East Asia.


Related Articles

  • DAI NIPPON. JARDEEN, JACK // Sea Classics;Sep2014, Vol. 47 Issue 9, p18 

    The article focuses on the Imperial Japanese Navy, which emerge from the Dark Ages and sought for world power status. Outlined is the journey taken by the Japanese Navy with its initial goal of establishing an aggressive, modernized Navy through ,testing and improvements. The attribution of the...

  • BRITAIN ON THE SEAS. Bywater, Hector C. // Foreign Affairs;Jan1938, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p210 

    This article discusses the effort that Great Britain is making to restore and consolidate her sea power. Tables published in the Navy Estimates for 1937 show the following combatant and auxiliary units as under construction in the 1938 fiscal year: five battleships, 21 cruisers, five aircraft...

  • PENSÉE MILITAIRE. COUTAU-BÉGARIE, Hervé // Revue Defense Nationale;2010, Issue 734, p113 

    This article looks at how the application of sea power has been, and indeed still is, affected by the many and varied changes in the strategic environment. It concludes that maritime power will continue to offer unequalled value to those nations capable of exercising it.

  • MARITIME SECURITY OPERATIONS IN THE PERSIAN GULF. Kürsener, Jürg // Naval Forces;2008, Vol. 29 Issue 4, p24 

    The article provides an overview regarding the mission of the combined maritime force in the Persian Gulf. The main tasks of the Coalition force are to set conditions for security and stability in the maritime environment, as well as complement the counter-terrorism and security efforts of...

  • Teaching Navies How to Be Navies. Bartee, Jon // U.S. Naval Institute Proceedings;Apr2009, Vol. 135 Issue 4, p70 

    The article reports that foreign maritime defense or the assistance by U.S. civilian and military agencies to another government to protect their society can achieve positive global effects and serve U.S. policy goals. Establishing a "1,000-ship Navy," or global maritime network, through the use...

  • CORRECTIONS.  // Naval History;Dec2005, Vol. 19 Issue 6, p62 

    This article presents several corrections the December 2005 issue of the periodical "Naval History." The Japanese lost one heavy cruiser, the Mikuma, during the Battle of Midway. Her sister ship, Mogaini, was so hardly damaged during the battle that she was out of service for more than a year....

  • How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 Kraska, James // Orbis;Jan2010, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p35 

    Abstract: Years of strategic missteps in oceans policy, naval strategy and a force structure in decline set the stage for U.S. defeat at sea in 2015. After decades of double-digit budget increases, the People''s Liberation Army (Navy) was operating some of the most impressive systems in the...

  • A COOPERATIVE STRATEGY FOR 21ST CENTURY SEAPOWER. Legien, Wolfgang // Naval Forces;2007, Vol. 28 Issue 6, p113 

    The article highlights the cooperative maritime strategy of the sea services in the U.S. Vice Admiral John G. Morgan, Jr. points out that the strategy is an interagency document written by the Navy, Marine Corps and Coast Guard for Congress and the public to understand Maritime Power. With this...

  • Honor the Human Capital: Loyalty and Priorities. Hanson, Marshall // Officer;May2005, Vol. 82 Issue 4, p48 

    Focuses on the mandate of U.S. Secretary of Defense Ronald Rumsfeld to transform the naval services and change the function of the military from a Cold War organization to a fighting force for the 21st century. Impact of the computers and communication technology in the Network Centric Warfare's...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics