Ethics of Gender Identity Disorder

Ross, Colin A.
November 2009
Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry;2009, Vol. 11 Issue 3, p165
Academic Journal
Gender identity disorder is unique among all DSM-IV-TR diagnoses. It is the only disorder in which treatment is designed to confirm, reinforce, and validate the belief that is the basis of the mental disorder. In all other diagnoses, the symptoms in the diagnostic criteria are viewed as pathological and the goal of treatment is to remove the symptoms. In gender identity disorder, however, the body is altered to match the belief that is said to be a symptom of mental disorder. This is self-contradictory. Either gender identity disorder should be dropped from DSM-V, just as homosexuality was dropped from the diagnostic system, or gender reassignment should be discontinued. The core contradiction in the current approach to gender identity is an ethical problem in the mental health field.


Related Articles

  • Queer Diagnoses: Parallels and Contrasts in the History of Homosexuality, Gender Variance, and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual. Drescher, Jack // Archives of Sexual Behavior;Apr2010, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p427 

    The American Psychiatric Association (APA) is in the process of revising its Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM), with the DSM-V having an anticipated publication date of 2012. As part of that ongoing process, in May 2008, APA announced its appointment of the Work Group on Sexual and Gender...

  • Proposed Revisions to Gender Identity Disorder Diagnoses in the DSM-5. Lawrence, Anne // Archives of Sexual Behavior;Dec2010, Vol. 39 Issue 6, p1253 

    The article focuses on the proposed revisions to psychiatric diagnoses for the fifth edition of the "Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders" (DSM-5). These include the proposed changes to Gender Identity Disorder (GID) diagnoses in adolescents and adults. It also describes the...

  • Removing Gender Identity Disorder from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: A Call for Action. Ault, Amber; Brzuzy, Stephanie // Social Work;Apr2009, Vol. 54 Issue 2, p187 

    The author calls for the removal of gender identity disorder (GID) from the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. The author offers a brief overview of a GID diagnostic manual released by the American Psychiatric Association. The author details the definition and criteria of...

  • Classifying Intersex in DSM-5: Critical Reflections on Gender Dysphoria. Kraus, Cynthia // Archives of Sexual Behavior;Jul2015, Vol. 44 Issue 5, p1147 

    The new diagnosis of Gender Dysphoria (GD) in the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (American Psychiatric Association, ) defines intersex, renamed 'Disorders of Sex Development' (DSD), as a specifier of GD. With this formulation, the status of intersex...

  • Comparison of height and weight in homosexual versus nonhomosexual male gender dysphorics. Blanchard, Ray; Dickey, Robert // Archives of Sexual Behavior;Oct1995, Vol. 24 Issue 5, p543 

    Tests the authors' clinical impression that homosexual gender-dysphoric males are physically smaller than non-homosexual gender-dysphoric males. Findings of significant height and weight differences despite random measurement errors; Explanation for the observed differences in weight;...

  • ANONYMOUS SEX.  // National Review;6/19/1987, Vol. 39 Issue 11, p42 

    Comments on the decision of American Psychiatric Association's board of trustees to remove from its diagnostic manual, egodystonic homosexuality, the last remaining psychiatric disorder related to homosexuality. View that homosexual political power is based on the technique of claiming...

  • BEHAVIOR MODIFICATION: A Preview of 'Clockwork Orange' in 1984? Warman, Donald; Carrier, Jor; Gregory-Lewis, Sasha // Advocate;3/12/75, Issue 159, p8 

    Introduces two opposing views concerning a program at the University of California in Los Angeles that uses behavior modification technique on male children with cross-gender identity problems. Ethical questions; Ability and freedom of those who are subjected to modification to consent;...

  • BEHAVIOR MODIFICATION: STUDENTS: A Demand to Stop 'Gender Program'  // Advocate;3/12/75, Issue 159, p8 

    Focuses on the demand of Gay Students Union at the University of California in Los Angeles to stop a program that uses behavior modification technique on male children with gender identity problems. Suspension of all such programs; Full disclosure of exact research, procedures and objectives;...

  • BEHAVIOR MODIFICATION: RESEARCHERS: Trying to Help Transsexuals in Childhood.  // Advocate;3/12/75, Issue 159, p8 

    Discusses the objectives of a program at the University of California in Los Angeles that uses behavior modification technique on male children with gender identity problems. Development of techniques which may help a special group of adult males in the society face some of their personal...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics