Evidence-based guidelines in the evaluation of work disability: an international survey and a comparison of quality of development

de Boer, Wout E. L.; Bruinvels, David J.; Rijkenberg, Arie M.; Donceel, Peter; Anema, Johannes R.
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p349
Academic Journal
Background: In social insurance, the evaluation of work disability is becoming stricter as priority is given to the resumption of work, which calls for a guarantee of quality for these evaluations. Evidence-based guidelines have become a major instrument in the quality control of health care, and the quality of these guidelines' development can be assessed using the AGREE instrument. In social insurance medicine, such guidelines are relatively new. We were interested to know what guidelines have been developed to support the medical evaluation of work disability and the quality of these guidelines. Methods: Five European countries that were reported to use guidelines were approached, using a recent inventory of evaluations of work disability in Europe. We focused on guidelines that are disease-oriented and formally prescribed in social insurance medicine. Using the AGREE instrument, these guidelines were appraised by two researchers. We asked two experts involved in guideline development to indicate if they agreed with our results and to provide explanations for insufficient scores. Results: We found six German and sixteen Dutch sets of disease-oriented guidelines in official use. The AGREE instrument was applicable, requiring minor adaptations. The appraisers reached consensus on all items. Each guideline scored well on "scope and purpose" and "clarity and presentation". The guidelines scored moderately on "stakeholder involvement" in the Netherlands, but insufficiently in Germany, due mainly to the limited involvement of patients' representatives in this country. All guidelines had low scores on "rigour of development", which was due partly to a lack of documentation and of existing evidence. "Editorial independence" and "applicability" had low scores in both countries as a result of how the production was organised. Conclusion: Disease-oriented guidelines in social insurance medicine for the evaluation of work disability are a recent phenomenon, so far restricted to Germany and the Netherlands. The AGREE instrument is suitably applicable to assess the quality of guideline development in social insurance medicine, but some of the scoring rules need to be adapted to the context of social insurance. Existing guidelines do not meet the AGREE criteria to a sufficient level. The way patients' representatives can be involved needs further discussion. The guidelines would profit from more specific recommendations and, for providing evidence, more research is needed on the functional capacity of people with disabilities.


Related Articles

  • National Population Health Survey.  // Infomat: A Weekly Review;5/10/2002, p2 

    Reports on the release of the fourth cycle of the National Health Survey 2000/2001 in Canada. Contents of the survey; Contact information for a copy of the results.

  • Health Survey Comparison: Canada, the United Kingdom, and the United States. Seipel, Michael M. O. // Social Development Issues;2012, Vol. 34 Issue 3, p50 

    This study examines the perception of health care as reported by respondents from Canada, the United Kingdom, and the United States over three survey periods. Though their health care systems differ widely from each other, they seem to share some degree of mutual challenges and successes. The...

  • How some states rate on the health-o-meter. Montague, Jim; Pitman, Hilarie // H&HN: Hospitals & Health Networks;1/20/96, Vol. 70 Issue 2, p14 

    States that New Hampshire has topped the list of healthiest states in the nation the second time in a row, according to the 1995 ReliaStar State Health Rankings. Mississippi's rankin; What states are rated on. INSET: The healthiest states..

  • Patient Perspective. International Survey Highlights Different Nations' Perceptions Of Health Care.  // PT in Motion;Dec2010/Jan2011, Vol. 2 Issue 11, p9 

    The article focuses on the results of the survey of citizens' perception of health care which revealed various perceptions of health care among nations.

  • NHS Direct: virtually engaged. McLellan N J // Archives of Disease in Childhood;Jan2004, Vol. 89 Issue 1, p57 

    In the five years since its launch in March 1998, NHS Direct in England and Wales has established itself as the world's largest provider of telephone healthcare advice. NHS Direct now handles over half a million telephone calls and NHS Direct Online half a million on-line transactions every...

  • KIWIS HAVE POOR HEALTH-LITERACY SKILLS.  // Public Sector;Apr2010, Vol. 33 Issue 1, p3 

    The article presents the results of the survey conducted by Adult Literacy and Life Skills Survey indicating that Màori has poorer health-literacy skills compared to non-Màori in New Zealand.

  • briefs.  // Australian Nursing Journal;Jul2002, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p13 

    Reports on the launch of the report 'National Evaluation Report,' which discusses the challenges of coordinated care. Other information it provides.

  • Costa Rica reforms `model' health care system. Salas, Alvaro; Miranda, Guido // World Health;Sep/Oct97, Vol. 50 Issue 5, p10 

    Discusses information about social security and health care system in Costa Rica. Factors that are putting pressure on the health care system in the country; Objectives of the health care reform in Costa Rica.

  • Future of Social Security: Time is on Our Side. Baker, Dean // Progressive Populist;2/15/2012, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p17 

    The article explores the attempt by the Washington's elite to cut Social Security and Medicare.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics