A case-crossover study of alcohol consumption, meals and the risk of road traffic crashes

Di Bartolomeo, Stefano; Valent, Francesca; Sbrojavacca, Rodolfo; Marchetti, Riccardo; Barbone, Fabio
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p316
Academic Journal
Background: The case-crossover (CC) design has proved effective to investigate the association between alcohol use and injuries in general, but has never been applied to study alcohol use and road traffic crashes (RTCs) specifically. This study aims at investigating the association between alcohol and meal consumption and the risk of RTCs using intrapersonal comparisons of subjects while driving. Methods: Drivers admitted to an Italian emergency room (ER) after RTCs in 2007 were interviewed about personal, vehicle, and crash characteristics as well as hourly patterns of driving, and alcohol and food intake in the 24 hours before the crash. The odds ratio (OR) of a RTC was estimated through a CC, matched pair interval approach. Alcohol and meal consumption 6 and 2 hours before the RTC (case exposure window) were compared with exposures in earlier control windows of analogous length. Results: Of 574 patients enrolled, 326 (56.8%) reported previous driving from 6 to 18 hours before the RTC and were eligible for analysis. The ORs (mutually adjusted) were 2.25 (95%CI 1.11-4.57) for alcohol and 0.94 (0.47-1.88) for meals. OR for alcohol was already increased at low (1-2 units) doses -2.17 (1.03-4.57) and the trend of increase for each unit was significant - 1.64 (95%CI 1.05-2.57). In drivers at fault the OR for alcohol was 21.22 (2.31-194.79). The OR estimate for meal consumption seemed to increase in case of previous sleep deprivation, 2.06 (0.25-17.00). Conclusion: Each single unit of acute alcohol consumption increases the risk of RTCs, in contrast with the "legal" threshold allowed in some countries. Meal consumption is not associated with RTCs, but its combined effects with sleepiness need further elucidation.


Related Articles

  • Alcohol Involvement in Fatal Motor-Vehicle Crashes--United States, 1999-2000.  // MMWR: Morbidity & Mortality Weekly Report;11/30/2001, Vol. 50 Issue 47, p1064 

    Compares alcohol involvement in fatal motor-vehicle crashes by age group and blood alcohol concentration levels for 1989 and 2000 in the United States. Criteria used in considering an alcohol-related traffic crash; Rise in the number of alcohol-related traffic fatalities in 1999-2000.

  • DROWSY DRIVING: The Unexpected Killer. Bridgemohan; Esherick, Joan // Dead on Their Feet: Teen Sleep Deprivation & Its Consequences;2004, p82 

    This article explores how widespread and costly the problem of drowsy driving. Drowsy driving is becoming a national epidemic, according to some experts, even more problematic and more common than drunk driving. Driving over long stretches of boring highway can have a hypnotic effect on any...

  • Impairment of driving performance caused by sleep deprivation or alcohol: a comparative study. Fairclough, Stephen H.; Graham, Robert; Fairclough, S H; Graham, R // Human Factors;Mar1999, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p118 

    A study was conducted to assess the relative impact of partial sleep deprivation (restriction to 4 h sleep before testing) and full sleep deprivation (no sleep on the night before testing) on 2 h of simulated driving, compared with an alcohol treatment (mean blood alcohol content = 0.07%). Data...

  • Alcohol, Fatigue and What Almost Was. TODD, TERRY L. // Wingman;Summer2010, Vol. 3 Issue 4, p24 

    The author emphasizes the dangers associated with driving under the influence of alcohol while fatigued and shares the experience of her husband who wrecked his truck due to his decision to drive home after a night of drinking.

  • Cancelling the licence to kill.  // Bulletin with Newsweek;6/3/2003, Vol. 121 Issue 6375, p49 

    One patient who got the shakes so badly after giving up grog, had to go to hospital. He drove himself there. The other was a woman who had previously been treated for alcoholism. She had come to hospital because she had been badly injured in a road accident. Gaughwin, the director of the Royal...

  • Kevin's Story II (Film). Wilson, Andrea; Fox, Bette-Lee // Library Journal;2/1/1990, Vol. 115 Issue 2, p118 

    Reviews the film "Kevin's Story II," which deals with the story of Kevin Tunnell who was convicted of manslaughter and drunk driving.

  • Alcohol related harm. Ker, K.; Ivers, R. // Injury Prevention (1353-8047);Aug2006, Vol. 12 Issue 4, p273 

    The article provides information on topics with regards to alcohol related injuries. Alcohol related injuries are predominantly a problem posed by the substantial number of moderate drinkers who occasionally drink to intoxication. Programs aimed at facilitating sensible alcohol consumption to...

  • Proportion of injured alcohol-impaired drivers subsequently convicted of an impaired driving criminal code offence in British Columbia. Purssell, Roy A.; Yarema, Mark; Wilson, Jean; Ming Fang; Simons, Richard; Kasic, Sharon; Abu-Laban, Riyad B.; Brubacher, Jeffrey; Lupu, Ioana // CJEM: Canadian Journal of Emergency Medicine;Mar2004, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p80 

    Background: Alcohol is a frequent contributing factor to motor vehicle collision injuries. Our objective was to determine the proportion of intoxicated drivers hospitalized following motor vehicle crashes who were subsequently convicted of an impaired driving criminal code offence. Methods: We...

  • Many good reasons not to drink and then drive.  // Saskatchewan Sage;Dec2004, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p13 

    This article focuses on reasons to stop drunk driving. The main one, of course, is that any time a person drive when his ability to do so is impaired, he is risking his own life and lives of others also. There are also serious legal implications if he get caught drinking and driving. In...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics