The Proliferation of Theoretical Paradigms Quandary: How One Novice Researcher Used Eclecticism as a Solution

Stinson, David W.
September 2009
Qualitative Report;Sep2009, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p498
Academic Journal
When a doctoral student plans to conduct qualitative education research, the aspect of the dissertation that often becomes problematic is determining which theoretical paradigm(s) might frame the study. In this article, the author discusses how he resolved the quandary through eclecticism. The author begins by describing briefly the purpose of his dissertation study, providing a justification for eclecticism in the selection of theories. He follows with a description of the three theories- poststructural theory, critical race theory, and critical theory-that framed his study and discusses briefly the methodology employed. The author concludes with a discussion of likely objections of his study and with an explanation of why his study was positioned within a critical postmodern paradigm.


Related Articles

  • Editorial Perspective: Writing Qualitative Manuscripts. Oliver, Marvarene // Journal of Professional Counseling: Practice, Theory & Research;Winter/Spring2011, Vol. 38 Issue 2, p1 

    The author focuses on writing qualitative manuscripts. She notes that qualitative methodology is often appropriate for the questions counselors and counselor educators want to research. In qualitative research, authors must ensure that the type of research and its methods are appropriate for the...

  • Research and Prospect of Educational Technology in China. Jing Wei; Jixin Pan; Jing Zhi // Applied Mechanics & Materials;2014, Issue 644-650, p5632 

    In the crucial decade, Chinese educational technology has been growing steadily. Doctoral Dissertation has high academic value, which lays a solid foundation for the discipline. A statistical study on 121 doctoral dissertations on educational technology is conducted, which includes publisher,...

  • Qualitative and Quantitative Research: Paradigmatic Differences. Arghode, Vishal // Global Education Journal;2012, Vol. 2012 Issue 4, p155 

    The paper defines qualitative and quantitative research. Subsequently, the two broad research fields are analyzed and compared on the basis of ontological, epistemological, and methodological differences. The underlying assumptions of the quantitative and qualitative research methods are also...

  • So Why Aren't Counselors Reporting n = 1 Research Designs? Sharpley, Christopher F. // Journal of Counseling & Development;Summer2007, Vol. 85 Issue 3, p349 

    There is a growing urgency for counseling to be evidence based. The n = 1 research paradigm offers counselors in the field an opportunity to evaluate their clinical casework and report this in methodologically rigorous form to their peers. Data from the past 20 years of the Journal of Counseling...

  • FRAMEWORKS FOR RESEARCH AND THEORY DEVELOPMENT IN ENTREPRENEURSHIP. West III, G. Page // Academy of Management Best Papers Proceedings;1997, p113 

    To develop a theory of entrepreneurship, some recommend the need for qualitative research while some recommend a shift to quantitative research. Dichotomizing between macro and micro domains relevant to entrepreneurship and comparing these to qualitative and quantitative research questions, new...

  • Mixing methods and blending paradigms: some considerations for future research. Schwartz, Carolyn; Revicki, Dennis // Quality of Life Research;Apr2012, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p375 

    No abstract available.

  • Ethnography Lost and Found: Qualitative Methodology Between Science, Art, and Social Powers. Valsiner, Jaan // Forum: Qualitative Social Research;2002, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p47 

    The Handbook of Ethnography reviewed here is a thorough treatise of the field as it currently stands--enthusiastically proliferating the uses of qualitative methodology, while remaining disoriented by the role post-modernist thinking has played in the contemporary social sciences. As a result,...

  • Perceptions of the Doctorate in Broad Education for Business. Martin, Ken // Insights to a Changing World Journal;2012, Issue 3, p141 

    This thought exchange drawn from qualitative research focuses on educators' important viewpoints concerning the nature and characteristics of graduate study for the doctoral degree. The variety of doctoral degrees and the special needs of the possessors of these are important. Satisfying the...

  • What can it mean to say communication is effective (and for whom) in postmodernity? Eicher-Catt, Deborah; Catt, Isaac // Conference Papers -- National Communication Association;2008, p1 

    What is the locus of agency in de-centered subjectivity? Can a de-centered subject be effective? These are questions yet to be directly encountered where a dominant paradigm of communication presupposes communication as instrumentality and ignores at our intellectual peril the postmodern...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics