Urban, Glen L.; Johnson, Philip L.; Hauser, John R.
March 1984
Marketing Science;Spring84, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p83
Academic Journal
An accurate understanding of the structure of competition is important in the formulation of many marketing strategies. For example, in new product launch, product reformulation, or positioning decisions, the strategist wants to know which of his competitors will be most affected and hence most likely to respond. Many marketing science models have been proposed to identify market structure. In this paper we examine the managerial problem and propose a criterion by which to judge an identified market structure. Basically, our criterion is a quantification of the intuitive managerial criterion that a "submarket" is a useful conceptualization if it identifies which products are most likely to be affected by "our" marketing strategies. We formalize this criterion within the structure of classical hypothesis testing so that a marketing scientist can use statistical statements to evaluate a market structure identified by: (I) behavioral hypotheses, (2) managerial intuition, or (3) market structure identification algorithms. Mathematically, our criterion is based on probabilities of switching to products in the situation where an individual's most preferred product is not available. 'Submarkets' are said to exist when consumers are statistically more likely to buy again in that 'submarket' than would be predicted based on an aggregate "constant ratio" model. For example, product attributes (e.g., brand, form, size), use situations (e.g., coffee in the morning versus coffee at dinner), and user characteristics (e.g., heavy versus light users) are specified as hypotheses for testing alternate competitive structures. Measurement and estimation procedures are described and a convergent approach is illustrated. An...


Related Articles

  • Analytical Models of Competition with Implications for Marketing: Issues, Findings, and Outlook. Eliashberg, Jehoshua; Chatterjee, Rabikar // Journal of Marketing Research (JMR);Aug1985, Vol. 22 Issue 3, p237 

    The authors review a representative cross-section of analytical models of competition using a framework for competitive analysis developed from a marketing perspective. Models are classified by the substantive issues they address and by the underlying modeling strategy. The implications of the...

  • AN HISTORICAL EVALUATION OF CHAMBERLIN'S THEORY OF MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION AND ITS RELATIONSHIP.... Barr, Jennifer; Dubas, Khalid M. // AMA Winter Educators' Conference Proceedings;1994, Vol. 5, p256 

    Evaluates the theory of Chamberlin on monopolistic competition and relationship to marketing management. Descriptions on the economic theory and price competitions; Dominance in the market structure by firms; Creation of market and building customer loyalty for brands; Relation between division...

  • Brand Introduction Strategies and Competitive Environments. Gatignon, Hubert; Weitz, Barton; Bansal, Pradeep // Journal of Marketing Research (JMR);Nov90, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p390 

    Drawing on research in marketing strategy and industrial organization economics, the authors develop a model to describe she impact of strategies for introducing a new brand, aspects of the competitive environment, and firm characteristics on the performance of new brands. They test the model...

  • Introduction to Special Issue on Competition in Marketing. Weitz, Barton A. // Journal of Marketing Research (JMR);Aug1985, Vol. 22 Issue 3, p229 

    The timing of the Special Issue on Competion in Marketing is particularly appropriate because of the growing importance of competition in marketing activities. With a slowdown in world economic growth, firms must take business away from competitors if they are to sustain their own growth rate....

  • Organizational Design When a Firm is a Seller in Input Markets.  // Foundations & Trends in Accounting;2010, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p46 

    The article informs about a research that examines consequences of an output market entrant for being a seller in input markets. It mentions that manufacturers regularly sell items through traditional retailers, their own outlets, and catalog sales. It discusses several aspects of accounting for...

  • A rigorous idea screening process delivers new products Which gain corporate support. Karger, Ted // Marketing News;11/22/1985, Vol. 19 Issue 24, p20 

    The article talks about idea screening research in marketing. The author states that many organizations have shifted to such process, which makes it difficult for any concepts to be deemed promising, unless they satisfy compelling criteria and provide well documented, fully illuminated results...

  • The Procompetitive Effect of Demand-Enhancing Check-Off Programs. Crespi, John M.; Marette, St├ęphan // American Journal of Agricultural Economics;May2009, Vol. 91 Issue 2, p389 

    This article explores demand-enhancing check-off programs and how such programs may influence both private programs as well as industry market structure. Under duopoly, a firm may increase its sales through privately funding product quality improvements. However, such endogenous sunk costs may...

  • A Customer-oriented Approach for Determining Market Structures. Srivastava, Rajendra K.; Alpert, Mark I.; Shocker, Alian D. // Journal of Marketing;Spring84, Vol. 48 Issue 2, p32 

    A framework for market analysis based on customer perceptions of substitutability-in-use is presented. An empirical application in the financial/banking services market is used to illustrate that when product preferences are dependent on the use/consumption context (especially relevant when...

  • FORECASTING NEW PRODUCT SALES FROM LIKELIHOOD OF PURCHASE RATINGS: REPLY. Infosino, William J. // Marketing Science;Fall86, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p389 

    The author wholeheartedly agrees with Robert Pratt's comment that the role of purchase intentions in forecasting sales depends upon such things as the product, the concept statement, the time to introduction and the purchase situation. This paper supports that view with empirical evidence of the...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics