Butler, Richard J.; Ehrenberg, Ronald G.
October 1981
Industrial & Labor Relations Review;Oct81, Vol. 35 Issue 1, p3
Academic Journal
This paper first describes in a relatively nontechnical fashion several econometric techniques that the authors believe should be useful to industrial relations researchers. Those techniques are then applied to an analysis of whether public sector impasse procedures create a "narcotic effect," that is, a tendency for the bargaining parties, once they use the procedures, to become increasingly reliant on them in future negotiations. The authors reanalyze data from Thomas Kochan and Jean Baderschneider's study of the impasse experience of police and fire fighters under New York State's Taylor Law during the 1968-76 period and find that while a narcotic effect did exist, as Kochan and Baderschneider argued, that relationship lasted only during the early years of the period and was actually reversed in later years. The authors conclude by explaining how such a pattern of results could occur, tracing the implications of their findings for public policy, and suggesting other research questions that could be analyzed by the econometric methods they have described.


Related Articles

  • THE NARCOTIC EFFECT OF IMPASSE-RESOLUTION PROCEDURES. Chelius, James R.; Extejt, Marian M. // ILR Review;Jul85, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p629 

    Two previous studies of bargaining by police and firefighters in New York State, by Kochan and Baderschneider and by Butler and Ehrenberg, agreed there had been a positive narcotic et feet in the early years under the state's Taylor Act, but they disagreed over the existence and direction of any...

  • Oklahoma's Experience with a Unique Interest Arbitration Procedure for Fire Fighters and Police. Greer, Charles R.; Sink, D. Scott // Arbitration Journal;Dec82, Vol. 37 Issue 4, p21 

    Oklahoma's unique interest arbitration procedure, which may be invoked by either party following an impasse in negotiations, allows municipalities to reject the arbitrator's award while the unions have no such option. The state's experience with this procedure was evaluated over a ten year...

  • Putting 'First' into First Responders. Zalud, Bill // Security: Solutions for Enterprise Security Leaders;Mar2007, Vol. 44 Issue 3, p12 

    The article discusses the challenges and difficulties faced by private sector and public sector organizations that provide first responder services such as emergency medical technicians, firefighters, police officers, and private security personnel. Difficulties include communications...

  • Regulator launches public sector pensions consultation. Paterson, Jennifer // Employee Benefits;12/11/2013, p8 

    The article reports that consultation on public service pension schemes has been launched by the Pensions Regulator of Great Britain (TPR). It states that consultation on a draft code of practice will help pension providers meet governance requirements. It highlights that from April 2015 TPR...

  • HUMOR IN 'THE BAG' (THE UNIFORM), PART 2. Brennan, Tom // Fire Engineering;Sep2000, Vol. 153 Issue 9, p92 

    Part II. Relates lessons incurred from personal experiences in the firefighting profession. Importance of knowing the exact event of a fire scene before reporting to higher authorities; Importance of communication between supervisors and subordinates; Need for supervisors to encourage a...

  • In brief.  // Public Finance;1/10/2003, p7 

    Reports on developments regarding the British public sector as of January 2003. Complaints against the congestion charge implemented against nurses; Plans to give schools full autonomy from government; Fire service employers' support for the Fire Service Act.

  • Share and share unalike. Jacobs, Richard // Money Marketing;9/4/2003, p34 

    Discusses local government, police and firemen's pension schemes in Great Britain. Pension share placed against the local government scheme; Penalties applied by most insurance companies under the name of a market value reduction; State second pension or state earnings-related pension scheme.

  • Negligence Actions by Police Officers and firefighters: A Need for a Professional Rescuers Rule.  // California Law Review;May78, Vol. 66 Issue 3, p585 

    Discusses negligence actions by police officers and firefighters. Overview of the applicable tort doctrine; Definition of the professional rescuers rule; Application of the professional rescuers rule; Conclusion.

  • Police burned out by world cup stress.  // Personnel Today;7/16/2002, p52 

    Reports the response of the firefighters to a fire alarm at the police station in England.


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics