Navarro, Peter
January 1983
Industrial & Labor Relations Review;Jan83, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p214
Academic Journal
In examining the bargaining record of the coal industry since the mid-1940s, this paper demonstrates that union power in this industry has fluctuated considerably over the years and then describes the reasons for that fluctuation. The author argues that the level of coal consumption has had a consistently strong effect on the balance of bargaining power throughout the postwar period and that industry profits have also influenced settlements, but to a lesser extent. In recent negotiations, the most important power factor has been the sharp decline in the percentage of coal produced by mines covered by UMW contracts. In addition, not only has pre-strike stockpiling by major consumers blunted the union's strike weapon, but also the weakness of union leadership in recent years has helped to precipitate and prolong strikes. Only the evidence on the, union's democratic contract ratification procedure, adopted in 1973, is mixed' although providing a slight strategic advantage to the union on occasion, it has also led to confusion at the bargaining table and contributed to the weakness of the leadership. The author also illustrates the importance of including rule changes in measuring union power.


Related Articles

  • IMPACTS OF ENTERPRISE BARGAINING ON UNIONS AND EMPLOYERS: DISCUSSANTS COMMENTS. Creighton, Breen // Labour & Industry (Labour & Industry);May2012, Vol. 22 Issue 3, p275 

    THE PAPERS PRESENTED BY DAVID PEETZ, AND BY LOUISE Thornthwaite and Peter Sheldon raise many interesting and important issues about the evolution of enterprise bargaining in Australia over the last 20 years. This Comment focuses upon three issues which arise from the two papers, even though they...

  • The Right to Strike. Burkett, Philip H. // America;6/28/1924, Vol. 31 Issue 11, p266 

    The article argues that the right to strike is genuine right so is the right to form unions and to bargain collectively. It mentions that as a rule some specific class of workingmen strikes. Future generations will look back upon the much vaunted civilization with some degree of scepticism. It...

  • Is War Labor Board Getting Tougher?  // Saturday Evening Post;8/18/1945, Vol. 218 Issue 7, p104 

    The article presents the author's reflection on the labor-management relationship in the U.S. According to the author, U.S. is on the crucial period where strikes from the labor side are common. He notes that because of the War Labor Board's formation of the principle of collective bargaining,...

  • Learning from Clerical Unions: Two Cases of Organizing Success. Hurd, Richard W. // Labor Studies Journal;Spring89, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p30 

    This paper summarizes two successful clerical organizing campaigns, The first case describes the District 65 campaign to gain representation rights and contract protection for the clerical employees of Columbia University. The discussion reviews the tactics employed to win a representation...

  • Imposition of Union Seniority Rule During Contract Term Unlawful.  // Labor Law Journal;Aug72, Vol. 23 Issue 8, p526 

    The article reports on the case of the Stage Employees and Motion Picture Machine Operators. It states that an attempt on the part of a labor union to enforce a bylaw under which an employer was to hire on the basis of a union membership was unlawful. The rule denied jobs to laid-of workers and...

  • 'Nontraditional unions': A concept that may become a necessity for physicians. Jackson, Douglas W. // Orthopedics Today;Feb2008, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p3 

    The author emphasizes the need for a non-traditional union and a bargaining approach by physicians in the U.S. Physicians are said to have avoided traditional trade unions because of possible strikes and picket lines. Suggestions to physicians for working together without being a traditional...

  • Metal workers around Turkey set to strike.  // Journal of Turkish Weekly;1/19/2015, p19 

    The article reports on the plan of metal workers that are members of the Birleþik Metal-Ýþ union to hold a strike in Turkey on January 29, 2015 following the union's failed negotiations with the Metal Industrialists' Union (MESS) over a three-year contract for collective bargaining.

  • Labor Relations.  // Labor Law Journal;Mar58, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p181 

    This article presents decisions of courts and administrative agencies on industrial relations. A National Labor Relations Board order, adopting the hearing officer's report of investigation of the union's objections to a representation election, found that the totality of an employer's conduct...

  • Emergency Stoppages in the Private Sector. Wollett, Donald H. // Labor Law Journal;Aug71, Vol. 22 Issue 8, p477 

    Discusses issues related to labor disputes and emergency work stoppages. Argument that the interruption of privately-owned local level services does not frequently generate genuine public emergencies; Support for the decision of the Court of Appeals in Columbia to uphold the right of railroad...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics