How to Achieve Effectiveness in Problem-Oriented Landscape Research: The Example of Research on Biotic Invasions

Kueffer, Christoph; Hadorn, Gertrude Hirsch
January 2008
Living Reviews in Landscape Research;2008, Vol. 2, p1
Academic Journal
It is increasingly expected from environmental research such as landscape research that science directly contributes to the solving of pressing societal problems. However, despite increased efforts to direct research towards societal problems, it is not obvious if science has become more effective in supporting environmental problem-solving. We present in this article a framework that facilitates the analysis and design of problem-orientation in research fields. We then apply the proposed framework to a concrete example of a problem-oriented landscape research field - namely research on biotic invasions. Invasion research addresses the problem that some organisms, that have been introduced by humans to a new geographic area where they were previously not present, spread in the landscape and pose negative impacts. We argue that problem-oriented research is more than applied research. Besides research on specific questions it also encompasses boundary management, i.e., deliberations among experts and stakeholders on the framing of adequate research questions about processes, values and practices for effective problem-solving. We postulate that such research may assist problem-solving in three ways, by analysing causal relationships (systems knowledge), clarifying conflicts of interests and values (target knowledge), or contributing to the development of appropriate means for action (transformation knowledge). We show that over the past decades a broad range of different research approaches has emerged in the young field of invasion research in order to produce systems, target and transformation knowledge for invasive species management. Early research in the field was dominated by the development of systems knowledge, but increasingly the three knowledge forms are treated more equally. The research field has also become more interdisciplinary and contextspecific. Boundary management in invasion research is mainly restricted to informal networks (communities of practice), while formal processes such as transdisciplinary research are scarce. We suggest that the paucity of structured and explicit boundary management processes will limit the future development of a more effective science for invasive species management. In particular, we envisage three obstacles that can only be removed through explicit boundary management. First, the existing theoretical frameworks are currently only partly able to integrate natural and social sciences research on the processes underlying invasions. Second, a clarification of the normative thinking about alien plant invasions is needed. Third, research on transformation knowledge has so far not fundamentally challenged the existing conceptual framing and institutional setup of invasive species management.


Related Articles

  • Invasive species in Southeast Asia: the knowledge so far. Peh, Kelvin S.-H. // Biodiversity & Conservation;Apr2010, Vol. 19 Issue 4, p1083 

    This review deals with alien species invasion in Southeast Asia, an important conservation and management concern in the region. I report on the current and potential future impacts of biological invasions on biodiversity in Southeast Asia. Current knowledge of the invasive species in Southeast...

  • EXPORTING TROUBLE. Di Menna, Jodi // Canadian Geographic;Nov/Dec2004, Vol. 124 Issue 6, p42 

    Provides information on invasive plants and animal species that affect the biodiversity and ecosystem of Canada. Impact of comb jelly on zooplankton and pelagic fish populations; Damage caused by grey squirrels on local red squirrel populations and woodlands; Control measures initiated to...

  • A Decade of Ecosystems. Carpenter, Stephen R.; Turner, Monica G. // Ecosystems;Jun2007, Vol. 10 Issue 4, p519 

    The article presents various articles published in the journal for the past decade. The first year of the publication of the journal which was in 1999 featured the article which tackles vigorous hybrids of landscape and traditional ecosystem ecology. Meanwhile in 1998 an article which evaluated...

  • Starfish wanted, dead or alive. Byrne, Maria // New Scientist;10/19/96, Vol. 152 Issue 2052, p53 

    Focuses on the population explosion of the starfish Asterias amurensis in Tasmania, Australia. Lack of natural predators; Reproductive potential of the starfish; Impact of starfish population on the local ecosystem.

  • The AQEM/STAR taxalist – a pan-European macro-invertebrate ecological database and taxa inventory. Schmidt-Kloiber, Astrid; Graf, Wolfram; Lorenz, Armin; Moog, Otto // Hydrobiologia;Aug2006, Vol. 566 Issue 1, p325 

    The European list of aquatic macro-invertebrate taxa, and its associated ecological database, originated within the context of the AQEM project and have been extended during the STAR project. The AQEM/STAR taxalist is a product of co-operation between applied freshwater ecologists and scientists...

  • Modelling biological invasions over homogeneous and inhomogeneous landscapes using level set methods. Britta Basse; Michael Plank // Biological Invasions;Feb2008, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p157 

    Abstract  The establishment, spread and subsequent degradation of existing environments by invasive species is a worldwide problem affecting native and agricultural ecosystems. The phenomenal cost to governments as a result of research and eradication or control drives the need...

  • Diversity and functional responses of nitrogen-fixing microbes to three wetland invasions. Serena Moseman; Pei Qian; Lisa Levin // Biological Invasions;Feb2009, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p225 

    Abstract  Impacts of invasive species on microbial components of wetland ecosystems can reveal insights regarding functional consequences of biological invasions. Nitrogen fixation (acetylene reduction) rates and diversity of nitrogen fixers, determined by genetic fingerprinting (T-RFLP)...

  • Invasive Species as Ecological Threat: Is Restoration an Alternative to Fear-based Resource Management? Gobster, Paul H. // Ecological Restoration;Dec2005, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p261 

    The article focuses on the research work done on the social aspects of invasive species by searching the literature. Academic journals take measured and objective outlook in describing the patterns of spread and impact of various invasives and evaluating attempts to reduce or control their...

  • Allee effects and pulsed invasion by the gypsy moth. Johnson, Derek M.; Liebhold, Andrew M.; Tobin, Patrick C.; Bjørnstad, Ottar N. // Nature;11/16/2006, Vol. 444 Issue 7117, p361 

    Biological invasions pose considerable threats to the world’s ecosystems and cause substantial economic losses. A prime example is the invasion of the gypsy moth in the United States, for which more than $194 million was spent on management and monitoring between 1985 and 2004 alone. The...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics