Screening and brief interventions for hazardous and harmful alcohol use in primary care: a cluster randomised controlled trial protocol

Kaner, Eileen; Bland, Martin; Cassidy, Paul; Coulton, Simon; Deluca, Paolo; Drummond, Colin; Gilvarry, Eilish; Godfrey, Christine; Heather, Nick; Myles, Judy; Newbury-Birch, Dorothy; Oyefeso, Adenekan; Parrott, Steve; Perryman, Katherine; Phillips, Tom; Shenker, Don; Shepherd, Jonathan
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p287
Academic Journal
Background: There have been many randomized controlled trials of screening and brief alcohol intervention in primary care. Most trials have reported positive effects of brief intervention, in terms of reduced alcohol consumption in excessive drinkers. Despite this considerable evidence-base, key questions remain unanswered including: the applicability of the evidence to routine practice; the most efficient strategy for screening patients; and the required intensity of brief intervention in primary care. This pragmatic factorial trial, with cluster randomization of practices, will evaluate the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of different models of screening to identify hazardous and harmful drinkers in primary care and different intensities of brief intervention to reduce excessive drinking in primary care patients. Methods and design: GPs and nurses from 24 practices across the North East (n = 12), London and South East (n = 12) of England will be recruited. Practices will be randomly allocated to one of three intervention conditions: a leaflet-only control group (n = 8); brief structured advice (n = 8); and brief lifestyle counselling (n = 8). To test the relative effectiveness of different screening methods all practices will also be randomised to either a universal or targeted screening approach and to use either a modified single item (M-SASQ) or FAST screening tool. Screening randomisation will incorporate stratification by geographical area and intervention condition. During the intervention stage of the trial, practices in each of the three arms will recruit at least 31 hazardous or harmful drinkers who will receive a short baseline assessment followed by brief intervention. Thus there will be a minimum of 744 patients recruited into the trial. Discussion: The trial will evaluate the impact of screening and brief alcohol intervention in routine practice; thus its findings will be highly relevant to clinicians working in primary care in the UK. There will be an intention to treat analysis of study outcomes at 6 and 12 months after intervention. Analyses will include patient measures (screening result, weekly alcohol consumption, alcohol-related problems, public service use and quality of life) and implementation measures from practice staff (the acceptability and feasibility of different models of brief intervention.) We will also examine organisational factors associated with successful implementation. Trial registration: Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN06145674.


Related Articles

  • Breast Cancer Screening.  // Oncology Nursing Forum;Jul2006, Vol. 33 Issue 4, p685 

    Focuses on the use of breast self-examination (BSE), clinical breast examination (CBE) by a healthcare provider and mammography in breast cancer detection. Results of a trial on the efficacy, sensitivity and specificity of BSE; Percentage of the sensitivity range for CBE; Clinical trials...

  • Assessment of HBV Preventive Services in a Medically Underserved Asian and Pacific Islander Population Using Provider and Patient Data. Mukhtar, Nizar; Toy, Brian; Burman, Blaire; Yu, Albert; Chen, Alice; Berman, Peter; Nguyen, Tung; Chan, Daniel; Hammer, Hali; McCulloch, Charles; Khalili, Mandana // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Jan2015, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p68 

    Background: Hepatitis B (HBV) represents a significant health disparity among medically underserved Asian and Hawaiian/Pacific Islander (API) populations. Studies evaluating adherence to HBV screening and vaccination guidelines in this population are limited. Objective: The purpose of this study...

  • Cost Comparisons between Home- and Clinic-Based Testing for Sexually Transmitted Diseases in High-Risk Young Women. Smith, Kenneth J.; Cook, Robert L.; Ness, Roberta B. // Infectious Diseases in Obstetrics & Gynecology;2007, Vol. 2007, p1 

    Home testing for chlamydia and gonorrhea increases screening rates, but the cost consequences of this intervention are unclear. We examined the cost differences between home-based and clinic-based testing and the cost-effectiveness of home testing based on the DAISY study, a randomized...

  • Offering Patients Colorectal Cancer Screening. Church, Timothy R. // JNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute;3/2/2005, Vol. 97 Issue 5, p328 

    Discusses results of a well-conducted randomized trial of five different methods of offering colorectal cancer screening tests to an average risk population in Italy. Guidelines in colorectal cancer screening; Details on the variety of organizational structures within a health care system;...

  • Perspectives and experiences of new migrants on health screening in Sweden. Faustine Kyungu Nkulu Kalengayi; Hurtig, Anna-Karin; Nordstrand, Annika; Ahlm, Clas; Ahlberg, Beth Maina; Nkulu Kalengayi, Faustine Kyungu // BMC Health Services Research;1/15/2016, Vol. 16, p1 

    Background: In Sweden, migrants from countries considered to have a high burden of certain infectious diseases are offered health screening to prevent the spread of these diseases, but also identify their health needs. However, very little is known about their experiences and...

  • Initial Refugee Health Assessments. Dicker, Susan; Stauffer, William M.; Nelson, Cindy; O'Fallon, Ann // Minnesota Medicine;Apr2010, Vol. 93 Issue 4, p45 

    The article discusses the purpose of medical screening for refugees who are new to Minnesota to determine certain health conditions such as infections. The screening involves identifying conditions that need a continuous follow up care. To solve this problem, the Department of Health's Refugee...

  • Medical Screening and the Value of Early Detection: When Unwarranted Faith Leads to Unethical Recommendations. MALM, H. M. // Hastings Center Report;Jan/Feb99, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p26 

    Discusses the ethical permissibility of the practice of recommending screening tests in the absence of randomized, controlled clinical trials. Consideration on the justifications for the practice of recommending screening tests prior to the completion of randomized clinical trials; Examples of...


    Background: In an effort to increase tuberculosis (TB) case detection, the Kaduna State TB program in Nigeria started Public-Private Mix (PPM DOTS) in 2002. This study assessed and compared the TB case management practices and treatment outcomes of the public and private health facilities...

  • Benefits of Screening for Lung Cancer With CT Are Not Proven.  // Ascribe Newswire: Medicine;6/10/2004, p28 

    The medical literature does not support the widely held belief that an advanced screening technique called computed tomography (CT) can save lives simply because it detects lung cancers at a smaller size than other screening techniques, according to researchers at Duke University Medical Center...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics