Why do Asian-American women have lower rates of breast conserving surgery: results of a survey regarding physician perceptions

Pham, Jane T.; Allen, Laura J.; Gomez, Scarlett L.
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p246
Academic Journal
Background: US Asian women with early-stage breast cancer are more likely to receive a modified radical mastectomy (MRM) than White women, contrary to clinical recommendations regarding breast conserving treatment (BCT). Methods: We surveyed physicians regarding treatment decision-making for early-stage breast cancer, particularly as it applies to Asian patients. Physicians were identified through the population-based Greater Bay Area Cancer Registry. Eighty (of 147) physicians completed a questionnaire on sociodemographics, professional training, clinical practices, and perspectives on the treatment decision-making processes. Results: The most important factors identified by physicians in the BCT/MRM decision were clinical in nature, including presence of multifocal disease (86% identified this as being an important factor for selecting MRM), tumor size (71% for MRM, 78% for BCT), cosmetic result (74% for BCT), and breast size (50% for MRM, 55% for BCT). The most important reasons cited for the Asian treatment patterns were patient attitudes toward not needing to preserve the breast (53%), smaller breast sizes (25%), and fear and cultural beliefs (12%). Conclusion: These survey results suggest that physicians perceive major roles of both clinical and cultural factors in the BCT/MRM decision, but cultural factors may be more relevant in explaining surgical treatment patterns among Asians.


Related Articles

  • Researchers Find Mastectomy Not Overprescribed. Pavlou, Stephanie Z. // O&P Business News;2/1/2010, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p20 

    The article reports on the results of the research concerning the treatment patterns of breast-cancer patients and reasons behind their choices. The study has found that 75.4% of patients underwent initial breast-conserving surgery (BCS) and 22.2% had initial mastectomy. It adds that an...

  • 6 cancer myths-busted. Kronish, Elisa; Baker, Liz; Kane, Kristin; Mantica, Ana // Self;Oct2005, Vol. 27 Issue 10, p106 

    Focuses on several myths of breast cancer. Claims of researchers that deodorants can cause breast cancer; Decision of physicians to conduct a mastectomy to cancer patients; Facts about the efficacy of mammogram.

  • Breast reconstruction and post-mastectomy radiation practice. Chen, Susie A.; Hiley, Crispin; Nickleach, Dana; Petsuksiri, Janjira; Andic, Fundagul; Riesterer, Oliver; Switchenko, Jeffrey M.; Torres, Mylin A. // Radiation Oncology;2013, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p1 

    Purpose: The goal of this study was to explore the perspectives and practice of radiation oncologists who treat breast cancer patients who have had breast reconstruction. Methods: In 2010, an original electronic survey was sent to all physician members of the American Society of Radiation...

  • Failure to timely diagnose breast cancer.  // Contemporary OB/GYN;Jan2004, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p25 

    The article discusses a case filed by a patient against her physician for failure of a proper and timely diagnosis of breast cancer. History of the consultations and laboratory tests done to the patient are detailed. After being diagnosed at Stage III cancer, the patient underwent chemotherapy...

  • Misconduct relating to fatal breast lump. Yeats, Jodi // New Zealand Doctor;8/23/2006, p5 

    The article reports on the decision of the New Zealand Health Practitioners' Disciplinary Tribunal that physician Ajit Johri is guilty of professional misconduct for failure to take the necessary action to address the lump in the breast of a pregnant patient. The doctor failed to reexamine the...

  • Lumpectomy or mastectomy? E.B. // Medical Update;Mar98, Vol. 21 Issue 9, p6 

    Presents results of a study on the survival of women with early-stage breast cancer published in the medical journal `Cancer.' Possibility of longer survival for patients who had lumpectomies than with mastectomy subjects; actors that affect women's decisions in the performance of lumpectomy or...

  • I Chose Mastectomy. Biddle, Donna // Today's Christian Woman;Sep/Oct2000, Vol. 22 Issue 5, p48 

    Relates the story of the author experiencing mastectomy in the United States. Details on the health condition of the woman after the breast cancer surgery; Encouragement of friends and families before and after the operation; Hardships felt after the surgery.

  • Review confirms lumpectomy as safe as mastectomy. Godlee, Fiona // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);12/2/95, Vol. 311 Issue 7018, p1451 

    Reports that lumpectomy is as safe as mastectomy according to a worldwide review of randomized controlled trials of treatment of early breast cancer. Trial organized by the National Surgical Adjuvant Breast and Bowel Project; Scientific and political controversy about the trial; Reduction of...

  • Use of breast-conserving therapy increases, but variations persist. Friedrich, M.J. // JNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute;4/3/2002, Vol. 94 Issue 7, p480 

    Looks into the persistence of variations in breast conserving therapy (BCT) in the U.S. Influences affecting the decision of a woman to receive BCT or mastectomy; Recommendation issued by the National Institutes of Health; Likelihood of residents in wealthy counties to receive complete and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics