Increasing Press Freedom in Indonesia: The Abolition of the L�se Majest� and 'Hate-sowing' Provisions

Royan, Naomita
December 2008
Australian Journal of Asian Law (Federation Press Pty Limited);Dec2008, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p290
Academic Journal
This article considers the issue of press freedom in Indonesia by examining two recent Constitutional Court decisions: (1) the Eggi Sudjana and Pandapotan Lubis case, in which the Constitutional Court reviewed Criminal Code provisions regarding the offence of deliberately insulting the President or Vice-President; and (2) the Panji Utomo case, in which the Constitutional Court reviewed Criminal Code provisions regarding the expression of hostility, hatred or contempt towards the Indonesian government. In both cases, the Constitutional Court ruled that the articles in question -- which enabled the state to penalise the media for merely reporting either insults to the President or Vice-President or expressions of hostility, hatred or contempt towards the Indonesian government -- were unconstitutional, as they contravened constitutionally enshrined rights including equality before the law, freedom of expression, freedom to communicate, freedom of association and freedom to obtain information. The Constitutional Court's decisions are a victory for freedom of expression; unfortunately, however, the rulings do not apply retrospectively to the cases of Eggi, Pandapotan and Panji. The abolition of these offences confirms Indonesia's trend towards an increasingly unrestricted press that is gradually being disentangled from government interference.


Related Articles

  • Media Law in Egypt and the Universal Principles of Freedom of Expression. Shaat, Mostafa Essam // Arab Media & Society;Spring2015, Issue 21, p1 

    The article reports on the discrepancies between media law in Egypt and the international commitments made by the government to implement principles of freedom of expression.

  • Number 10 should heed worries over foreign ownership. Darby, Ian // Campaign;8/2/2002, Issue 30, p12 

    Comments on the implications behind the appointment of David Currie as head of Ofcom in Great Britain. Accusation on the cronies of Prime Minister Tony Blair landing top job in public office; Effect of the Draft Communication Bill on the liberalization of the media; Concern of advertisers on...

  • LACK OF PREDICTABILITY IN THE CRIMINAL LAW. THE OFFENCES OF "INSULT" AND "LIBEL". Aldea, Adrian // Bulletin of the Transilvania University of Brasov. Series VII: S;2010, Issue 52, p183 

    At present, provision in the criminal law for the offences of "insult" and "libel" is a controversial issue in Romanian criminal law. Lack of predictability of the criminal law regarding the two above mentioned crimes has consequences on the security of legal relations and affects the defence of...

  • In support of Free Flow Act. Slovak-Barton, Cyndy // Hays Free Press (Buda, TX);12/20/2006, Vol. 103 Issue 36, p4 

    The article focuses on the Free Press publishers' testimony before a Legislative committee in support of the Free Flow of Information Act in the U.S. The author believes that for the media to become a "formidable opposition," it needs the ability to shelter those who give information that can...

  • Friends of the press.  // Columbia Journalism Review;Mar/Apr1972, Vol. 10 Issue 6, p3 

    This section comments on the issue of law and reform in the field of journalism in the U.S. as of March 1972. The same hidden majority in Congress that rescued the press from antitrust laws by approving the Newspaper Preservation Act surfaced again late in 1971. By 50 to 36, the Senate accepted...

  • Globalization and the European Union: Freedom of Expression Law Resources. Drucker, Susan // Free Speech Yearbook;2002/2003, Vol. 40, p173 

    Presents an introduction to international media law resources of the European Union (EU). Illustration of the globalization of the U.S. mass media; Coverage of the freedom of expression and information laid by the EU; Information on the law formulated by the EU for the freedom and pluralism of...

  • Television in a post-Soviet union. McNair, Brian // Screen;Autumn92, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p300 

    The article analyzes some options and possible developments routes faced by the televisual media in the former Union of Soviet Socialist Republic (USSR) states during their transition to a mixed-market economy. The first telecenter was completed in the Shabalovk region of Moscow in 1938,...

  • Observatorios ciudadanos. Ezeta, Alejandra; Esquivel, Luis // Revista Mexicana de Comunicacion;dec2008/feb2009, Vol. 21 Issue 114, p18 

    No abstract available.

  • Communication Democracy or Gagging the Media?  // Washington Report on the Hemisphere;8/16/2013, Vol. 33 Issue 14, p1 

    The article argues that the Organic Communication Law is restricting opposition's sector in Ecuador. The new regulations for media, which took effect on June 25, 2013 is presented, which President Rafael Correa describes as democratizing Ecuadorian communication, but which the press claim as a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics