Mobile and Fixed-Bearing (All-Polyethylene Tibial Component) Total Knee Arthroplasty Designs: A Prospective Randomized Trial

Gioe, Terence J.; Glynn, Jason; Sembrano, Jonathan; Suthers, Kathleen; Santos, Edward R. G.; Singh, Jasvinder
September 2009
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Sep2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 9, p2104
Academic Journal
Background: Proponents of mobile-bearing total knee arthroplasty believe that it has potential advantages over a fixed- bearing design in terms of diminished wear and improved motion and/or function, but these advantages have not been demonstrated in a randomized clinical comparison to our knowledge. We conducted a patient-blinded, prospective, randomized clinical trial to compare mobile-bearing and fixed-bearing cruciate-substituting total knee arthroplasties of the same design. Methods: Patients between the ages of sixty and eighty-five years were prospectively randomized to receive a cruciate- substituting rotating-platform design or a fixed-bearing design with an all-polyethylene tibial component. There were no significant differences in the demographic characteristics (mean age, 72.2 years; mean American Society of Anesthesi- ologists score, 2.7; mean body mass index, 31.8 kg/m2) or preoperative clinical or radiographic measures between the groups. Routine clinical and radiographic follow-up measures included the Knee Society score (KSS), Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), and Short Form-36 (SF-36) outcome measures. Results: The results of 312 arthroplasties (136 with an all-polyethylene tibial component and 176 rotating-platform designs) in 273 patients were analyzed at a minimum of two years (mean, forty-two months) postoperatively. Although there was significant improvement in both groups, there was no significant difference between the groups with regard to the mean postoperative range of motion (110.9° and 109.1°, respectively; p = 0.21), the mean KSS clinical score (90.4 and 88.2 points; p = 0.168), or the mean KSS pain score (44.9 and 43.1 points; p = 0.108) at this follow-up point. There were ten revisions: seven because of infection, one because of patellar fracture, one because of instability, and one because of aseptic loosening. Conclusions: The two designs functioned equivalently at the time of early follow-up in this low-to-moderate-demand patient group. The rotating-platform design had no significant clinical advantage over the design with the all-polyethylene tibial component. Level of Evidence: Therapeutic Level I. See Instructions to Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.


Related Articles

  • Common Peroneal Nerve Palsy Following Total Hip Arthroplasty: Prognostic Factors for Recovery. Jai Hyung Park; Hozack, Bryan; Kim, Peter; Norton, Robert; Mandel, Steven; Restrepo, Camilo; Parvizi, Javad // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;5/1/2013, Vol. 95-A Issue 9, p799 

    Background: Common peroneal nerve palsy, although rare, is a serious complication of total hip arthroplasty. Although several publications have dealt with the risk factors for peroneal nerve palsy, there is little literature regarding the time it takes for the nerve to recover and the factors...

  • Fulfillment of Patients' Expectations for Total Hip Arthroplasty. Mancuso, Carol A.; Jout, Jennifer; Salvati, Eduardo A.; Sculco, Thomas P. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Sep2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 9, p2073 

    Background: Fulfillment of patient expectations is an important outcome of total hip arthroplasty. The objective of the present study was to determine the proportion of expectations that were fulfilled following total hip arthroplasty as well as how the fulfillment of expectations relates to...

  • Neurologic injuries after primary total ankle arthroplasty: prevalence and effect on outcomes. Primadi, Andri; He-Xing Xu; Taek-Rim Yoon; Je-Hwang Ryu; Keun-Bae Lee // Journal of Foot & Ankle Research;10/3/2015, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Neurologic injuries are complications that can arise after total joint arthroplasty. However, no comprehensive study has been conducted on peripheral nerve injuries after total ankle arthroplasty. The purpose of the present study was to identify the prevalence of neurologic injury...

  • Peroneal neuropathy after weight loss: a high-resolution ultrasonographic characterization of the common peroneal nerve. Meylaerts, Liesbeth; Cardinaels, Eline; Vandevenne, Jan; Velghe, Beatrijs; Gelin, Geert; Vanormelingen, Linda; Weyns, Frank // Skeletal Radiology;Dec2011, Vol. 40 Issue 12, p1557 

    Objective: The objective of this study was to use in vivo ultrasonographic imaging to analyze the common peroneal nerve in controls and patients who were diagnosed with peroneal neuropathy (PN) due to significant weight loss. We also looked for a relationship between weight loss (magnitude) and...

  • "High or low Inferior Mesenteric Artery ligation in Laparoscopic low Anterior Resection: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial" (HIGHLOW trial). Mari, Giulio; Maggioni, Dario; Costanzi, Andrea; Miranda, Angelo; Rigamonti, Luca; Crippa, Jacopo; Magistro, Carmelo; Di Lernia, Stefano; Forgione, Antonello; Carnevali, Pietro; Nichelatti, Michele; Carzaniga, Pierluigi; Valenti, Francesco; Rovagnati, Marco; Berselli, Mattia; Cocozza, Eugenio; Livraghi, Lorenzo; Origi, Matteo; Scandroglio, Ildo; Roscio, Francesco // Trials;2015, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p346 

    Background The position of arterial ligation during laparoscopic anterior rectal resection with total mesorectal excision can affect genito-urinary function, bowel function, oncological outcomes, and the incidence of anastomotic leakage. Ligation to the inferior mesenteric artery at the origin...

  • Surface Replacement is Comparable to Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty. Mike McGrath; David Marker; Thorsten Seyler; Slif Ulrich; Michael Mont // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Jan2009, Vol. 467 Issue 1, p94 

    Abstract  Conversion of a failed surface hip replacement to a conventional total hip arthroplasty is reportedly a straightforward procedure with excellent results. We compared perioperative parameters, complications, and clinical as well as radiographic outcomes of 39 hemi and...

  • Resurfacing is Comparable to Total Hip Arthroplasty at Short-term Followup. Michael Mont; David Marker; Jonathan Smith; Slif Ulrich; Mike McGrath // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Jan2009, Vol. 467 Issue 1, p66 

    Abstract  Metal-on-metal total hip resurfacing arthroplasty has had excellent reported results at early to midterm followup, and some studies suggest that outcomes are comparable to conventional THA. We compared the clinical and radiographic outcomes of two closely matched groups...

  • Associations of calf skeletal muscle characteristics and peripheral nerve function with self-perceived physical functioning and walking ability in persons with peripheral artery disease. Evans, Natalie S.; Kiang Liu; Criqui, Michael H.; Ferrucci, Luigi; Guralnik, Jack M.; Lu Tian; Yihua Liao; McDermott, Mary M. // Vascular Medicine;02/01/2011, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p3 

    We determined whether more adverse calf muscle characteristics and poorer peripheral nerve function were associated with impairments in self-perceived physical functioning and walking ability in persons with lower extremity peripheral artery disease (PAD). Participants included 462 persons with...

  • Risk Factors for Peroneal Nerve Injury and Recovery in Knee Dislocation. Peskun, Christopher; Chahal, Jas; Steinfeld, Zvi; Whelan, Daniel // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Mar2012, Vol. 470 Issue 3, p774 

    Background: Acute knee dislocation is rare but has a high rate of associated neurovascular injuries and potentially limb-threatening complications. These include the substantial morbidity associated with peroneal nerve injury: neuropathic pain, decreased mobility, and considerably reduced...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics