Outcomes of planned home birth with registered midwife versus planned hospital birth with midwife or physician

Janssen, Patricia A.; Saxell, Lee; Page, Lesley A.; Klein, Michael C.; Liston, Robert M.; Lee, Shoo K.
September 2009
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;9/15/2009, Vol. 181 Issue 6/7, p377
Academic Journal
Background: Studies of planned home births attended by registered midwives have been limited by incomplete data, nonrepresentative sampling, inadequate statistical power and the inability to exclude unplanned home births. We compared the outcomes of planned home births attended by midwives with those of planned hospital births attended by midwives or physicians. Methods: We included all planned home births attended by registered midwives from Jan. 1, 2000, to Dec. 31, 2004, in British Columbia, Canada (n = 2889), and all planned hospital births meeting the eligibility requirements for home birth that were attended by the same cohort of midwives (n = 4752). We also included a matched sample of physician-attended planned hospital births (n = 5331). The primary outcome measure was perinatal mortality; secondary outcomes were obstetric interventions and adverse maternal and neonatal outcomes. Results: The rate of perinatal death per 1000 births was 0.35 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.00-1.03) in the group of planned home births; the rate in the group of planned hospital births was 0.57 (95% CI 0.00-1.43) among women attended by a midwife and 0.64 (95% CI 0.00-1.56) among those attended by a physician. Women in the planned home-birth group were significantly less likely than those who planned a midwife-attended hospital birth to have obstetric interventions (e.g., electronic fetal monitoring, relative risk [RR] 0.32, 95% CI 0.29-0.36; assisted vaginal delivery, RR 0.41, 95% 0.33-0.52) or adverse maternal outcomes (e.g., third- or fourth-degree perineal tear, RR 0.41, 95% CI 0.28-0.59; postpartum hemorrhage, RR 0.62, 95% CI 0.49-0.77). The findings were similar in the comparison with physician-assisted hospital births. Newborns in the home-birth group were less likely than those in the midwife- attended hospital-birth group to require resuscitation at birth (RR 0.23, 95% CI 0.14-0.37) or oxygen therapy beyond 24 hours (RR 0.37, 95% CI 0.24-0.59). The findings were similar in the comparison with newborns in the physician-assisted hospital births; in addition, newborns in the home-birth group were less likely to have meconium aspiration (RR 0.45, 95% CI 0.21-0.93) and more likely to be admitted to hospital or readmitted if born in hospital (RR 1.39, 95% CI 1.09-1.85). Interpretation: Planned home birth attended by a registered midwife was associated with very low and comparable rates of perinatal death and reduced rates of obstetric interventions and other adverse perinatal outcomes compared with planned hospital birth attended by a midwife or physician.


Related Articles

  • Born at Home. Feferman, Irv // Ontario Dentist;Nov2009, Vol. 86 Issue 9, p12 

    The article discusses the safety of home births. A Canadian study on the safety of home births attended by midwives as compared to hospital births attended by midwives and physicians is presented. It demonstrated that incidences of perinatal death and other complications were lowest in planned...

  • Hungarian home birth advocate gets two years in prison. Stafford, Ned // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);4/2/2011, Vol. 342 Issue 7800, p732 

    The article reports that Hungarian obstetrician and midwife �gnes Ger�b was sentenced to two years imprisonment in a case involving to home births.

  • Neonatal outcomes in obese mothers: a population-based analysis. Minsart, Anne-Frederique; Buekens, Pierre; De Spiegelaere, Myriam; Englert, Yvon // BMC Pregnancy & Childbirth;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: If it is well known that obesity increases morbidity for both mother and fetus and is associated with a variety of adverse reproductive outcomes, then few studies have assessed the relation between obesity and neonatal outcomes. This is the aim of the present study after taking into...

  • The Safety of Home Birth: The Farm Study. Durand, A. Mark // American Journal of Public Health;Mar1992, Vol. 82 Issue 3, p450 

    Pregnancy outcomes of 1707 women, who enrolled for care between 1971 and 1989 with a home birth service run by lay midwives in rural Tennessee, were compared with outcomes from 14 033 physician-attended hospital deliveries derived from the 1980 US National Natality/National Fetal Mortality...

  • Amid Fears And Controversy, A Doctor Chooses A Home Birth. GOLDSTEIN, JESSICA TAYLOR // Health Affairs;Jun2015, Vol. 34 Issue 6, p1057 

    A personal narrative is presented which explores the author's experience of giving a home birth for their third child in Wisconsin in the winter of 2014.

  • Home births in England and Wales, 1979: perinatal mortality according to intended place of delivery. Campbell, Rona; Davies, Isobel MacDonalds; MacFarlane, Alison; Beral, Valerie // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);9/22/1984, Vol. 289 Issue 6447, p721 

    Examines the relation between the intended place of delivery among births at home and perinatal mortality. Association between home birth delivery but booked for hospital unit and perinatal delivery; Increase of perinatal mortality in nulliparous women; Suggestion for the low perinatal...

  • Perinatal death associated with planned home birth in Australia: Population based study. Bastian, Hilda; Keirse, Marc J.N.C.; Lancaster, Paul A L // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);08/08/98, Vol. 317 Issue 7155, p384 

    Presents a study which assesses the risk of perinatal death in planned home births in Australia. Number of perinatal deaths which occurred; Reason Australian home births carried a high death rate; Methodology used to conduct the study; Discussion based on the conclusions of the study.

  • Five year prospective survey of risk of booking for a home birth in Essex. Shearek, J.M.L. // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);11/23/1985, Vol. 291 Issue 6507, p1478 

    Investigates the risk of booking for a home birth in Essex, England. Absence of perinatal death; Comparison between the patients booked for delivery at home and in hospitals.

  • Ghostbelly: a memoir. Mander, Rosemary // AIMS Journal;2014, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p25 

    No abstract available.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics