An Evaluation of the Seminal Work of Patricia Benner: Theory or Philosophy?

Altmann, Tanya K.
May 2007
Contemporary Nurse: A Journal for the Australian Nursing Profess;2007, Vol. 25 Issue 1/2, p114
Academic Journal
The purpose of this article is to review the seminal work of Patricia Benner, From Novice to Expert, in order to assert it as a philosophy and not a theory. In the literature there is no clear consensus on where this model stands - theory or philosophy. There is no intent to devalue Patricia Benner's work as it is valuable and has become widely used in nursing practice, research, education and administration. However, as a philosophy, Benner's interpretive work is more constructive. Appropriate use of this model requires an understanding of whether it is a theory or a philosophy, its underpinnings and an assessment of its development and testing. This can be accomplished by knowing the differences between a theory and a philosophy and by reviewing the ways of knowing and processes of reasoning which are necessary for skill acquisition. Much of the critique of Benner's work falls into two categories: it is not quantitative research and there are issues with the use of narratives. These will be reviewed. Judgment and understanding of the nature of Benner's model allows for its appropriate use in journal articles, research, or other projects and/or modification as necessary.


Related Articles

  • La filosofía de Patricia Benner y la práctica clínica. Carrillo Algarra, Ana Julia; García Serrano, Lucila; Cárdenas Orjuela, Claudia Marcela; Díaz Sánchez, Ingrid Rocío; Yabrudy Wilches, Nataly // Enfermería Global;oct2013, Vol. 12 Issue 32, p346 

    In order to explore how to apply Patricia Benner's philosophy on the clinical field, a research was done about the scientific literature, initially with a five year range. However, little material was found on that field and for this reason it was decided to increase the range to a period...

  • Musicking in the City: Reconceptualizing Urban Music Education as Cultural Practice. Gaztambide-Fern�ndez, Rub�n A. // Action, Criticism & Theory for Music Education;Aug2011, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p15 

    The article discusses the aspects of co-constitutive nature of theory and practice along with its unchanging entanglement and imbrication that is considered as praxis. It states that the teaching of music becomes a tool for thinking on how to change the world from the perception of those who...

  • A MOSQUITO BITE AGAINST THE ENACTIVE APPROACH To BODILY EXPERIENCES.  // Journal of Philosophy;Apr2011, Vol. 108 Issue 4, p188 

    In this article, the author discusses the difficulties faced by enactivists, both conceptual and empirical. As reported, the classical computational dichotomy between perception and action is rejected by the enactive approach to bodily experiences. It is argued by the proponents of the enactive...

  • Leadership Spotlight.  // FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin;Apr2008, Vol. 77 Issue 4, p22 

    The article focuses on the essence of leadership. According to the author, the desire and effort to help and serve others are the common attributions of good leaders. It highlights the philosophy on leadership which states that helping others is the highest form of leadership and can only be...

  • FOUR PHILOSOPHICAL MODELS OF THE RELATION BETWEEN THEORY AND PRACTICE. Jorgensen, Estelle R. // Philosophy of Music Education Review;Spring2005, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p21 

    This article introduces four philosophical models of the relation between theory and practice. Clarifying what is meant by theory and practice raises a nest of conceptual problems. Concerning theory, it may be tempting to equate the terms theory and philosophy. Among their shared properties,...

  • 2nd November: Proper 26 Matthew 23:1-12. NELAVALA, SUREKHA // Expository Times;Oct2008, Vol. 120 Issue 1, p27 

    The article focuses on the Bible verse Matthew 23:1-12. It notes that people have been following the trend of modus operandi wherein what people say does not necessarily match what they do. It examines the similarity of such trend with the verse wherein Jesus criticizes such lifestyle of a...

  • AÇÃO, SABEDORIA PRÁTICA E LIBERDADE EM PAUL RICOEUR. Marcondes Cesar, Constança // Prometeus: Filosofia em Revista;jan-jun2013, Vol. 6 Issue 11, p93 

    The most important question that is going to be answered is : which are the ethicals implications of Paul Ricoeur's philosophy of action?In this sense, we will study the concept of action in Ricoeur's work, and his contribution to the depth studies about man as an ethical individual, capable of...

  • Does Free Will Remain a Mystery? A Response to Van Inwagen. Griffith, Meghan // Philosophical Studies;Jun2005, Vol. 124 Issue 3, p261 

    In this paper, I argue against Peter van Inwagen’s claim (in “Free Will Remains a Mystery”), that agent-causal views of free will could do nothing to solve the problem of free will (specifically, the problem of chanciness). After explaining van Inwagen’s argument, I...

  • Theory of practice, rational choice, and historical change. Ermakoff, Ivan // Theory & Society;Sep2010, Vol. 39 Issue 5, p527 

    If we are to believe the proponents of the Theory of Practice and of Rational Choice, the gap between these two paradigmatic approaches cannot be bridged. They rely on ontological premises, theories of motivations and causal models that stand too far apart. In this article, I argue that this...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics