Efficacy of Cap-Assisted Colonoscopy in Comparison With Regular Colonoscopy: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Yuk Tong Lee; Lai, Larry Hin; Hui, Aric Josun; Wong, Vincent Wai Sun; Ching, Jessica Yuet Ling; Wong, Grace Lai Hung; Wu, Justin Che Yuen; Chan, Henry Lik Yuen; Wai Keung Leung; Lau, James Yun Wong; Sung, Joseph Jao Yiu; Ka Leung Chan, Francis
January 2009
American Journal of Gastroenterology;Jan2009, Vol. 104 Issue 1, p41
Academic Journal
OBJECTIVES: Colonoscopy cannot be completed in up to 10% of cases. We postulate that cap-assisted colonoscopy (CAC), by fitting a mucosectomy cap to the tip of a colonoscope, could improve the outcome. METHODS: We conducted a prospective randomized controlled trial in two regional endoscopy centers. All colonoscopies were performed by experienced colonoscopists. Patients 18 years or older undergoing their first colonoscopy were recruited. Patients were randomized to the CAC group or to the regular colonoscopy (RC) group. The first successful cecal intubation rate, rescue cecal intubation rate, cecal intubation and total colonoscopy times, and polyp detection rate were compared. RESULTS: One thousand patients were enrolled (mean age 52.6 years, 46% men). There was no statistically significant difference in the first successful cecal intubation rate between CAC and RC groups (96.2% vs. 94.6%, P = 0.23). The cecal intubation and total colonoscopy times were shorter in the CAC group than in the RC group (6.0 ± 4.0 min vs. 7.2 ± 4.8 min, P < 0.001; 14.7 ± 8.6 min vs. 16.7 ± 10.3 min, P = 0.001). The adenoma detection rate was significantly lower in the CAC group than in the RC group (30.5% vs. 37.5%, P = 0.018), but there was no significant difference in the detection of advanced lesions. In case of failing cecal intubation, use of CAC as a rescue method could achieve a higher success rate than RC (66.7% vs. 21.1%, P = 0.003). CONCLUSIONS: Among experienced colonoscopists, CAC did not improve the initial cecal intubation rate and had a lower adenoma detection rate. However, it shortened the cecal intubation time and performed better as a rescue method. Its utilization should be reserved for selected cases, especially when initial cecal intubation fails.


Related Articles

  • Comparative study of conventional colonoscopy and pan-colonic narrow-band imaging system in the detection of neoplastic colonic polyps: a randomized, controlled trial. Inoue, Takuya; Murano, Mitsuyuki; Murano, Naoko; Kuramoto, Takanori; Kawakami, Ken; Abe, Yosuke; Morita, Eijiro; Toshina, Ken; Hoshiro, Hideo; Egashira, Yutaro; Umegaki, Eiji; Higuchi, Kazuhide // Journal of Gastroenterology;2008, Vol. 43 Issue 1, p45 

    Background. Detection and removal of adenomas by colonoscopy is an important means for preventing cancer; however, small adenomas may be missed during colonoscopy. The narrow-band imaging (NBI) system clearly enhances the microvasculature in neoplastic lesions, making it appear as a dark...

  • Characteristics of Rectosigmoid Adenomas as Predictors of Synchronous Advanced Proximal Colon Neoplasms. Papatheodoridis, George V.; Triantafyllou, Konstantinos; Tzouvala, Maria; Paspatis, Gregorios; Xourgias, Vassilios; Karamanolis, Demetrios G. // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Sep1996, Vol. 91 Issue 9, p1809 

    Background/Aim: Colonoscopy is recommended to every patient with adenoma in rectosigmoid to disclose synchronous proximal neoplasms. The aim of this study was to determine whether characteristics of rectosigmoid adenomas are associated with proximal advanced neoplasms. Patients/Methods: One...

  • QUALITY OF PERFORMANCE AT SCREENING FLEXIBLE SIGMOIDOSCOPY CORRELATES WITH ADENOMA DETECTION RATES. Thomas-Gibson, S.; Swain, D.; Schofield, G.; Saunder, B. P.; Atkin, W. // Gut;Apr2004 Supplement 3, Vol. 53, pA8 

    Adenoma detection rates (ADR) at screening flexible sigmoidoscopy (FS) are known to be variable. Authors have previously described an objective performance score for screening FS based on video footage. Video footage from 260 FS cases was selected from 40000 cases from Flexible Sigmoidoscopy...

  • An Effective Instillation Method for Water-Assisted Colonoscopy as Performed by In-Training Endoscopists in Terms of Volume and Temperature. Ryu, Ki-Hyun; Huh, Kyu-Chan; Kang, Young-Woo; Choi, Young-Woo; Im, Euyi-Hyeog; Lee, Tae-Hee; Kim, Sun-Moon; Kim, Yong-Seok; Sun, Jae-Hyung // Digestive Diseases & Sciences;Jan2012, Vol. 57 Issue 1, p142 

    Background and Study Aims: There is general consensus that water instillation helps insert a colonoscope. However, the most effective method for water instillation has not yet been established, especially for endoscopists-in-training. The aim of this study was to determine volume and temperature...

  • Review: Computed tornographic colonography has high specificity but low-to-moderate sensitivity for detecting colorectal polyps: COMMENTARY. Bhutani, Manoop S.; Pasricha, P. Jay // ACP Journal Club;Nov/Dec2005, Vol. 143 Issue 3, p78 

    This article comments on a clinical study according to which computed tornographic colonography has high specificity but low-to-moderate sensitivity for detecting colorectal polyps. Unlike many other malignant tumors, colorectal cancer is preventable by detection and removal of precancerous...

  • Fellow Involvement May Increase Adenoma Detection Rates During Colonoscopy. Rogart, Jason N.; Siddiqui, Uzma D.; Jamidar, Priya A.; Aslanian, Harry R. // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Nov2008, Vol. 103 Issue 11, p2841 

    BACKGROUND: Adenoma detection rate (ADR) is increasingly used as a quality indicator for screening/surveillance colonoscopy. Recent investigations to identify factors that affect ADR have focused on the technical aspects of the procedure or the equipment. OBJECTIVE: To assess whether...

  • Three points and a fixed penalty for speeding colonoscopists.  // Gut;Mar2007, Vol. 56 Issue 3, p416 

    The article focuses on the issues examined in the study concerning colonoscopy practice in Great Britain by endoscopists. New endoscopic technologies like magnification imaging, chromoscopy, narrow band imaging and confocal endomicroscopy have been developed to help both detection and in vivo...

  • Histopathology using the Vienna criteria: clinical decision making is still adequate. Hurlstone, D. P. // Gut;Oct2004, Vol. 53 Issue 10, p1545 

    This article examined the safety and efficacy of high magnification chromoscopic colonoscopy for the diagnosis of neoplasia in flat and depressed lesions of the colorectum. However, fundamental differences still exist between Japanese and Western histopathologists that make comparative studies...

  • Endoscopy training: time to stop counting procedures? Bretthauer, Michael; Brandrud, Aleidis Skard // Gut;Nov2014, Vol. 63 Issue 11, p1686 

    The authors reflect upon the need to formalise and structure training of endoscopists. They recommend increasing the number of times the procedure is performed during training to ensure stained improvement in the quality of endoscopy and state that patient outcomes in cases like post-colonoscopy...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics